TransparentMammoth

Topics / Budget

Initiative

Vehicle replacement program (Fund 915)

Fund 915 was created for FY21-22 to separate vehicle replacement from garage services [1] 2021-2022 Budget Book, p. 197. Staff said at an October 2022 meeting that the new fund was shown with no starting balance and a transfer in of $12,481,000 [2] Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00, 2:32:47. A November 2024 agenda packet says the Town paid off all debt borrowed from the fund in FY23-24, while the FY25-26 budget text still describes the internal loan as 'being paid off this year' [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 87[4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.1. The FY25-26 budget raised the annual inflation factor for vehicle replacement costs from 3% to 3.5%, and the adopted FY2025-26 budget lists $516,300 in total Fund 915 revenue [4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.1[5] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 59.

Updated

Findings

11 findings

  1. 1 Fund 915 was created for FY21-22 to separate vehicle replacement from garage services

    Updated

    The 2021-2022 Budget Book says Fund 915 was created for FY21-22, separating vehicle replacement from garage services [1] 2021-2022 Budget Book, p. 197. At the May 19, 2021 Town Council meeting, staff said the Vehicle Replacement Fund, previously in Garage Services, was being made into a new fund, Fund 915, to hold the money collected from departments to replace their vehicles (at 03:59:12 in the recording) [2] Town Council — 2021-05-19, 3:58:14. Earlier in that item, staff said that pulling vehicle replacement out would give a clearer picture of the cost of garage services (at 03:58:14) [2] Town Council — 2021-05-19, 3:58:14.

    The 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget says the garage fund used to contain the vehicle replacement program, and that some funding for that program may have masked discrepancies between revenue and the expense to deliver services [3] 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget, p. 50.

    An agenda packet for the November 20, 2024 meeting says the change was made to separate two diverse but equally important motor pool functions and to provide clarity on the cost of operations [4] Agenda (PDF), p. 87.

    Why it matters

    Staff said separating the two gave clarity into that activity (at 02:39:30 in the recording) [5] Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00, 2:32:47.

    Sources

    1. 2021-2022 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 197

    2. Town Council — 2021-05-19

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

    3. 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 50

    4. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 87

    5. Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

  2. 2 Staff said in October 2022 that Fund 915 showed no starting balance and a transfer in of $12,481,000

    Updated

    A staff report filed with the January 20, 2021 meeting lists a Vehicle Replacement designated reserve of $5,433,960 [1] Staff Report, p. 4. The staff report says that balance consists of Restricted Gas Tax Reimbursements, assigned fund balance, and the outstanding loan to the General Fund, and that the fund was still combined with Fund 910 on that date [2] Staff Report(1).pdf, p. 20. At the October 20, 2021 meeting, staff said they would take the $12,110,000 and move it to Fund 915 (at 02:48:14 and 02:48:42 in the recording) [3] Town Council — 2021-10-20 16:00:00, 2:42:35.

    At the October 19, 2022 meeting, staff said they showed Fund 915 as having no fund balance and then transferring in $12,481,000 (at 02:39:02 in the recording) [4] Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00, 2:32:47. Staff said expenditures were the vehicles bought, about a million two in the last year (at 02:39:02 and 02:39:30) [4] Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00, 2:32:47.

    Why it matters

    By our reading, the pages give $12,110,671 (June 30, 2021) and $12,481,000 (the October 2022 transfer in) without explaining the difference between them [2] Staff Report(1).pdf, p. 20[4] Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00, 2:32:47. The January 2021 reserve of $5,433,960 is a different measure and the records do not tie it to either figure [1] Staff Report, p. 4.

    Sources

    1. Staff Report

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

    2. Staff Report(1).pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 20

    3. Town Council — 2021-10-20 16:00:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

    4. Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

  3. 3 Town documents say the internal loan against the vehicle replacement fund was paid off in FY23-24, but the FY25-26 budget text says it is being paid off that year

    Updated

    The vehicle replacement fund contained both cash and debt because it was used as part of the stabilization of the Town's finances after the MLLA settlement agreement, according to the 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget [1] 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget, p. 50. The same budget says the General Fund makes an annual payment of $340,000 to pay back the internal loan, which it said should be paid off in the next seven years [1] 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget, p. 50. At the May 19, 2021 meeting, staff said the outstanding loan was $2,491,000 and was repaid at about $340,000 a year (at 04:00:50 in the recording) [2] Town Council — 2021-05-19, 3:58:14.

    A December 6, 2023 agenda packet says staff recommended paying off the remaining loan balance as part of that budget review [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 138.

    The February 21, 2024 staff report says the loan will be completely repaid prior to FY 2025 [4] Town Resolution approving form and authorizing execution of lease financing documents funding capital improvement projects.pdf, p. 1. An agenda packet for the November 20, 2024 meeting says that in FY23-24 the Town paid off all outstanding debt borrowed from this fund, leaving only available cash in the accounting [5] Agenda (PDF), p. 87.

    The FY25-26 Final Budget, filed with the June 18, 2025 meeting, says in its Debt Service Fund section that the inter-fund loan between the General Fund and the Vehicle Replacement Fund 'is being paid off this year' [6] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.1[7] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 51.

    Why it matters

    The records show the General Fund repaid an internal loan taken against vehicle replacement money, with payments accelerated before a payoff in FY23-24 [8] Fund Balance FY22-23.pdf, p. 3[5] Agenda (PDF), p. 87. The FY25-26 budget wording differs from the FY23-24 payoff statement, and the pages do not explain the difference [6] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.1[5] Agenda (PDF), p. 87.

    Sources

    1. 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 50

    2. Town Council — 2021-05-19

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 138

    4. Town Resolution approving form and authorizing execution of lease financing documents funding capital improvement projects.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    5. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 87

    6. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 34.1

    7. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 51

    8. Fund Balance FY22-23.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

  4. 4 Departments are charged each year for vehicle replacement and the money is accumulated in Fund 915

    Updated

    At the June 18, 2025 Town Council meeting, staff said the Town charges the departments for the replacement needs of each vehicle, and those charges are direct expenditures to each department (at 02:08:13 in the recording) [1] Town Council — 2025-06-18 16:00:00, 2:07:17. Staff said the funds are accumulated in Fund 915, so that when a vehicle has exhausted its full life there are funds to replace it (at 02:08:41) [1] Town Council — 2025-06-18 16:00:00, 2:07:17. Staff also said an accident-totaled vehicle does not change the allocation, because insurance would fully fund that replacement (at 02:09:10) [1] Town Council — 2025-06-18 16:00:00, 2:07:17.

    Why it matters

    The costs appear in department budgets, such as Gas Tax, which staff said covers major equipment like loaders and snow blowers, while the accumulated money is held in Fund 915 [1] Town Council — 2025-06-18 16:00:00, 2:07:17.

    Sources

    1. Town Council — 2025-06-18 16:00:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

  5. 5 Staff raised the annual vehicle replacement inflation factor from 3% to 3.5% for FY25-26

    Updated

    The 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget says the expected replacement cost was incremented by 3% annually [1] 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget, p. 50. At the May 19, 2021 meeting, staff said they increment the replacement cost by 3% a year (at 04:00:02 in the recording) [2] Town Council — 2021-05-19, 3:58:14.

    The FY25-26 Final Budget says staff increased the annual inflation charge from 3% to 3.5% for FY25-26, because recent vehicle purchases show the cost of acquisition rising faster than staff's estimates [3] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.1. A separate page of the same budget says the annual increase was typically 3% and has increased to 3.5% as the Town has not been keeping up with the cost of inflation [4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 17. At the June 18, 2025 meeting, staff said they had made that modification this year, going from a 3% annual increase to 3.5% (at 02:09:10 in the recording) [5] Town Council — 2025-06-18 16:00:00, 2:07:17. The Final Budget Adoption FY26-27 document repeats the same sentence about the FY25-26 increase [6] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 51.

    Why it matters

    The FY25-26 Final Budget says the change had an impact on several General Fund departments as well as Gas Tax, Airport and CRC expenses [4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 17.

    Sources

    1. 2021-2022 Council Adopted Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 50

    2. Town Council — 2021-05-19

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

    3. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 34.1

    4. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 17

    5. Town Council — 2025-06-18 16:00:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

    6. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 51

  6. 6 The adopted FY2025-26 budget lists $516,300 in total Fund 915 revenue

    Updated

    Total revenue is $516,300 [1] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 59. For FY24-25, the same page shows an approved budget of $367,505 for the Equip Replacement Charge, $100,000 for interest, and total revenue of $467,505 [1] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 59. By our calculation, the adopted equipment replacement charge is $48,795 higher than the FY24-25 approved figure [1] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 59.

    The FY25-26 adopted expenditure cell is blank, and the net row shows $516,300 [1] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 59. The page labels that list as the FY23-24 budget, although its total matches the FY25-26 adopted figure [2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 50. The adopted budget for Fund 915 (Vehicle Replacement Program) for Fiscal Year 2025-26 includes a revenue line item for Equip Replacement Charge of $416,300 [1] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 59.

    Sources

    1. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 59

    2. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 50

  7. 7 The FY26-27 budget document says staff have not identified vehicle purchase needs for the initial budget

    Updated

    The FY25-26 Final Budget carries the same wording for FY25-26 [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 50.

    The FY26-27 Gas Tax Budget chart in that document lists Vehicle Replacement at $516,500 as a Gas Tax expense [2] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 25.

    Why it matters

    The document says any vehicle needs for FY26-27 would be addressed during quarterly budget reviews rather than in the initial budget [3] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 51.

    Sources

    1. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 50

    2. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 25

    3. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 51

  8. 8 Some fleet additions fall outside the vehicle replacement program

    Updated

    A Fund Balance FY22-23 document filed with the December 6, 2023 meeting says two requested additions to the fleet, a blower head and a bike trailer, were 'vehicles that are requested but not a part of the current vehicle replacement program' [1] Fund Balance FY22-23.pdf, p. 3. A staff report filed with the November 19, 2025 meeting says its requests include vehicles that fall below the threshold for the vehicle replacement program [2] Staff Report - FY 2025-26 Fund Balance Quarter 1 Update FINAL.pdf, p. 6. A document dated April 1, 2026 says a mini excavator is not currently in the Town's vehicle program, so adding it to the fleet will require one-time funding [3] 2nd qtr FY25-26.pdf, p. 3.1.

    Why it matters

    Equipment outside the program is not covered by the annual replacement charges and needs separate funding, according to these records [3] 2nd qtr FY25-26.pdf, p. 3.1[2] Staff Report - FY 2025-26 Fund Balance Quarter 1 Update FINAL.pdf, p. 6.

    Sources

    1. Fund Balance FY22-23.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

    2. Staff Report - FY 2025-26 Fund Balance Quarter 1 Update FINAL.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 6

    3. 2nd qtr FY25-26.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3.1

  9. 9 An April 2024 Town action sheet says the replacement of loader L19 is fully funded

    Updated

    A Town Council Agenda Action Sheet for the April 3, 2024 meeting, prepared by Public Works Director Haislip Hayes, recommends a motion approving a resolution that waives bidding requirements and awards a contract for one new loader to Cashman Cat for $494,800 [1] Waive bidding requirements and award contract for purchase of a new loader to Cashman Cat.pdf, p. 1. The sheet says funding is allocated on an annual basis to a vehicle replacement fund, so equipment can be replaced when it reaches the end of its useful life [1] Waive bidding requirements and award contract for purchase of a new loader to Cashman Cat.pdf, p. 1.

    The sheet says the airport will receive a 2007 loader (L19) to replace it once the new loader is delivered [1] Waive bidding requirements and award contract for purchase of a new loader to Cashman Cat.pdf, p. 1. It says loaders are generally replaced every 20 years, that the replacement of L19 is fully funded, and that as of 7/1/23, $507,942 was allocated towards its replacement [1] Waive bidding requirements and award contract for purchase of a new loader to Cashman Cat.pdf, p. 1.

    Why it matters

    The sheet gives an example of how annual allocations to a vehicle replacement fund are used to pay for snow-removal equipment [1] Waive bidding requirements and award contract for purchase of a new loader to Cashman Cat.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. Waive bidding requirements and award contract for purchase of a new loader to Cashman Cat.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

  10. 10 Grants are part of vehicle replacement planning in ESTA, Town and transit records

    Updated

    A draft ESTA Transit Services Contract filed with the February 2, 2022 meeting says ESTA shall pursue federal and state grant opportunities for vehicle replacement to minimize the fiscal impact on the Town for the purchase of vehicles [1] Draft ESTA Transit Services Contract 2022.pdf, p. 5. Staff said the Town would use about $134,000 from a Great Basin Air District grant for them (at 04:03:45 in the recording) [2] Town Council — 2021-05-19, 3:58:14.

    The June 14, 2019 staff report says the Town (TOML) would fund the 15% match, committing $43,909, toward a total project cost estimated at $292,727 to replace one trolley [3] B-2 5339(b) Grant Funding Award from Savings, p. 1.

    The staff member said that, because grants were anticipated to replace vehicles, a full fund was not necessary (at 02:35:56 in the recording) [4] Special Town Council — 2010-07-19, 2:31:28. In response to a question, another speaker said this concerned only the trolley and that police, snowblowers and other equipment were still programmed to send their annual replacement allotment (at 02:38:14) [4] Special Town Council — 2010-07-19, 2:31:28.

    Why it matters

    These records show grants and the Town's match funds being used alongside, and in one 2010 case instead of, annual replacement set-asides [3] B-2 5339(b) Grant Funding Award from Savings, p. 1[4] Special Town Council — 2010-07-19, 2:31:28.

    Sources

    1. Draft ESTA Transit Services Contract 2022.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 5

    2. Town Council — 2021-05-19

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

    3. B-2 5339(b) Grant Funding Award from Savings

      attachmentearliest date in cited textp. 1

    4. Special Town Council — 2010-07-19

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

  11. 11 The garage services fund (Fund 910), separated from Fund 915, has been budgeted with a deficit in the years cited

    Updated

    A December 4, 2024 agenda packet says the Vehicle Service Fund (Garage) had a projected budget of $1,424,093 for FY24-25 [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 241.

    The Final Budget Adoption FY26-27 says projected revenues of $1,815,000 and expenditure of $2,023,224 for FY26-27, with a negative fund balance of $208,224 [2] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 50. According to the FY25-26 Final Budget, the Vehicle Service Fund (Fund 910) has projected revenues of $1,562,563 for FY25-26 and projected expenditures of $1,784,565 for FY25-26, and the proposed budget is listed as having a negative fund balance of $221,912 for FY25-26 [3] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 49.

    Why it matters

    The garage fund was split from vehicle replacement partly so its costs and billing would be clear [4] Agenda (PDF), p. 87[5] Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00, 2:32:47. Both the FY25-26 and FY26-27 budgets say staff expect to finish an analysis by mid-year with a solution to the revenue-versus-expenditure discrepancy [3] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 49[2] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 50.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 241

    2. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 50

    3. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 49

    4. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 87

    5. Town Council — 2022-10-19 16:00:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date