Town Council
at 16:00 · recording 3 hr 26 min
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
17 findings- Final FY26-27 document puts reserves $1,290,110 below the policy requirement Budget and Capital Improvements
- FY25-26 General Fund deficit went from about $281,672 in the preliminary budget to $67,573 in the tentative budget Budget and Capital Improvements
- Adopted FY2026-27 budget lists $100,000 in Cannabis Tax revenue, up from $75,000 adopted for FY2025-26 Cannabis
- Cannabis Business Registration Fee fell from $8,500 to $1,000 per certificate in FY2025-26 and stays at $1,000 in FY2026-27 Cannabis
- The Town's cannabis audits moved from a 2018 HdL contract to a search for a replacement and, in 2025, to Town-run audits Cannabis
- The FY26-27 budget document says the Town bought Mammoth Lakes Foundation land for $4.5 million, with Measure U paying $180,000 a year toward the debt Downtown and Main Street
- Measure U support for Edison Theater operations: $15,000 returned in FY25-26 and removed in FY26-27 Downtown and Main Street
- Fund 205’s FY2026-27 adopted budget lists $665,000 in revenue Fund 205 - Solid Waste
- The FY2019-20 franchise renewal raised the fee from 5% to 9.5% Fund 205 - Solid Waste
- Fund 220's adopted FY2026-27 budget is $4,248,684 in both revenue and expenditures, up from $3,866,744 in FY2025-26 Fund 220 - Airport Operations
- Staff proposed a 3.9% increase in Development Impact Fees and Affordable Housing Fees for FY26-27 Housing
- Final Budget FY26-27 lists a $18,970,000 total budget for the MACC, compared with $16,800,000 in FY25-26 Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center (MACC) (CIP GF9)
- Snow Storage Lot load fees are $55, $75 and $85 per load plus a 5% USFS surcharge in the FY25-26 schedule Snow Operations and Wildfire
- A $20.6 million state Infill Infrastructure Grant is the main funding for Parcel infrastructure The Parcel
- The FY26-27 final budget lists $23,000,000 in TOT revenue, up from $19,500,000 in FY25-26 Tourism and TOT
- The Town is budgeted to receive $148,000 (2%) from the TBID pass-through fund in both FY25-26 and FY26-27 Tourism and TOT
- A delinquent TOT return draws a 15% first-month penalty plus 18% annual interest Tourism and TOT
Transcript
421 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
5:21 Let's see. Hi, Bill. How are you? I'm well. How are you? I am here. Vertical and breathing? Yes. Good. Hi, Brent. How you doing? Great. How are you doing? I am very warm today. It's pretty nice out. It's like no breeze. It's beautiful. No, it's perfect. Yeah. It is perfect. I like it like 58 degrees. Well, you can't complain about the weather today. No, it's hot. Sorry, I'm just getting on scene. That was scary. Hello, everyone.
6:14 Good afternoon. Welcome to the June 18th, 2025 regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council. John Wentworth. Sorry, I had to get on Zoom because I believe that our council, Andy Morris, will be participating remotely, so I want to be able to see the chat if needed. And with that, Jamie, can you please call the roll?
6:44 Councilmember Sauser? Yep. Councilmember Truax? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Here. Janet Hatfield, may you please lead us in the pledge. Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right.
7:25 To start off this evening, we will take public comment from people either in the room or online for anything that is not otherwise on the agenda. Good evening, Madam Mayor, Council. I'm Betsy Truax, the Vice President of Community Engagement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and I just had a couple of updates I wanted to share with you this evening. Tomorrow and Friday, we are hosting a Trail Magic event for PCT through hikers at the Horseshoe Lake parking lot.
7:57 Please feel free to stop by and say hi. We'll be there from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. or until our supplies run out. And just want to thank local businesses that are providing snacks, beverages, and discounts on a passport card that we'll be handing out to some of those hikers. The goal is to encourage through hikers to take a zero day and visit our local businesses for all of their trail needs. So it should be a lot of fun.
8:22 Nine to one at Horseshoe Lake. Correct. Have we done that before? Last summer we did it actually down in Reds Meadow, but just this year with just the road situation and everything, I'm looking forward to being out there near the trolley stop at Horseshoe. That's awesome. Yeah, so come on by.
8:39 Also, Trashy Thursdays are back. So every Thursday from 5 to 6 p.m., except for July 3rd, we will be out cleaning up our town. This Thursday, we will be at Mammoth Creek Park and the Community Recreation Center. So come on out, help us pick up some trash. You might win a prize. I had fun out there with the mayor a couple weeks ago. So thanks for joining us. It was awesome.
9:01 On Tuesday, June 24th from 5 to 7 p.m., we are hosting a business after hours in conjunction with the Chamber of Commerce and Visit California at our California Welcome Center. We'd love for you to come and show our appreciation to Visit California, who will have representatives there, as well as our Welcome Center partners. So that's from 5 to 7 on Tuesday, June 24th, and Council, you should have received an invitation to RSVP from Rob. So let me know if you have any challenges with that.
9:30 Dang. Sorry.
9:33 Finally, on Thursday, June 26th, Community Coffee is on Zoom at 8.30 a.m. And we will have an update on the McCoy Arts and Cultural Center from Amy Callanan along with Kendra Knight will be there. We're highlighting a nonprofit every month now on Community Coffee. And we have so many great nonprofits doing terrific work in our community. So she'll talk a little bit about the relationship between the foundation and the MAC as we move forward. And then also we'll have an update.
10:02 Thank you. Anyone else in the room? It's a race. It's a foot race. Here comes Pat and David. Good afternoon, Madam Mayor, Madam Mayor Pro Tem and Councilmembers. David Eichmann, Interim Director.
10:31 of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. The Chamber's actively promoting the survey for the Eastern Sierra Housing Study. We're including that in our weekly newsletter every week. And yesterday, a direct email went out, not just to the 300 member businesses that are part of the Chamber, but to all 521 individuals that are on our listserv.
10:57 And we will probably do that one more time closer to the end of the survey period. Chamber upcoming events tomorrow from 4 to 5 is our next ribbon cutting right downstairs here, Appliances of Mammoth, one of the newest businesses in town. There will be refreshments 4 to 5. Ribbon cutting will probably be at 4.30. So you are all welcome to that.
11:24 And then, as Betsy said, I just want to reiterate the Business After Hours event next Tuesday from 5 to 7 at the Welcome Center. And especially to thank Visit California for all they're doing to keep the tourists coming to our state. And you won't have to use the porta-potties since now the bathrooms there are back open thanks to the town. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Pat Foster, Hot Creek Aviation.
12:02 I got kind of a fun one. For the last few years, there's been an outfit out of Bishop called the Bishop Flying Club, and they've got a few aircraft available for rent. They've been doing flight instruction. Been doing really well, actually. Been very, very popular. Last week, I put a deal together with the owner to base an airplane in Mammoth.
12:21 And the plane's been flying every day. A lot of their instructors are up here in Mammoth. A lot of their students are in Mammoth. And so if you have any interest in learning to fly, going up in a plane, they've got a discovery flight where you can go up and see what it's all about and see if you like it. Pretty cool, pretty cool deal. My son-in-law went through the process. He's already soloing, cross-countrying, really, really enjoying it. So that's something new that we have available in Mammoth. That's all I got.
12:49 Thank you. Thank you. Pat, quick question. Are they still doing helicopter tours at the airport? Say that again? Are helicopter tours also available there at the airport still? Is that kind of done? You know, he's there, he's available. I don't know how much he's been doing, but yeah, if you called him, Ed's available for helicopter tours. Absolutely. Hello. That's exciting. Good evening, Town Council. My name is Andrew Mulford. I'm the Trails Program Manager for the Town of Mammoth Lakes in our Office of Outdoor Recreation.
13:24 Here tonight to share a update on the Sherwin's Area Recreation Plan. As of last Wednesday, June 11th, we've got a signed decision memo for construction of Sharp Phase 3. That is a 13-mile project, 10 miles of brand new trail construction, 3 miles of rehabilitated and improved user-created trails, and along with that is
13:53 Six miles of user-created trails that we'll be naturalizing, closing, revegetating, and bringing back to sort of a natural state. So big thanks to, you know, some committed community members. This project has been a long time coming in the planning pipeline since 2009. So in 2009, the Sherwin's Working Group got together. Good mix of, you know, interested community members.
14:22 And Forest Service staff, and they came up with, I think, a really good plan out there, and we've been doing our best to bring that to fruition, kind of like an orchid that's stubborn and only bears fruit every few years. We got a little fruit in 2017, and we were able to build the Mammoth Rock Trail Connector, Meadow Trail Connector, and the Meadow Trail.
14:47 Four to five miles of new trail out there. This is the next bit of implementation that's been approved. And then there's also another phase, phase four, where we'll be working on keeping that moving along through the environmental review process. This summer, we're hoping to get the survey work done in support of that. And so just keeping that thing moving forward. But excited to share this news. I think, you know, some highlights from the decision memo.
15:18 The comment period was open for 30 days and we received over 47 comments, all positive and encouraging. I think also kind of an interesting sentence in here is this decision is consistent with the Inyo National Forest Land Management Plan. The project was designed in conformance with land management plan direction relevant to project activity. So I think
15:46 You know, it's been a long time coming, but we've got a really good working relationship between the forest and the town. It's just been good to see, you know, that partnership really come together through this process. So we will be implementing it with our crew of seven plus myself, so eight of us on the ground working on that, also with our army of volunteers, and we may bring in some help from the Bishop tribe.
16:16 So we're looking to hopefully implement all those miles in the next two working seasons. So it's an optimistic goal, but since we've had this designed decision memo as of last Wednesday, we've already constructed a half mile new trail. Encourage you to go out there and check it out. It starts at the Sierra Vista overlook on the bike path behind the college where there's some picnic tables and benches.
16:42 And we're working our way down from there to Sherwin Creek's campground, where we'll loop back and connect back into the Mammoth Rock Trail. I'll leave this with you all. If you'd like to take a closer look, all my doors always open if you'd like to come and look at maps, and I'm sure you've seen them all before, but big picture, the project was approved as it was kind of originally presented, so the proposed action didn't get changed.
17:10 During the review process, the review process, you know, we spent a lot of time in the final design of the proposed action to make sure that it avoided any known cultural resources or other sensitive resources out there, and that was successful in getting us across the finish line with a project that we can implement, so very excited and just wanted to share that good news. Thank you. Thank you. All right. I think we have a comment online.
17:47 Stacey, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you very much. Good afternoon, Mayor Bubser and Councilmembers. Stacey Corliss, Mammoth Lakes resident. And I'm commenting today on the very disturbing proposal that is included currently in bill language as part of the federal budget reconciliation process. It came out of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee last week.
18:19 That would make over 250 acres of public lands eligible for sale in order to balance the federal budget. Stacey, if I could just interrupt real quick. This would be without much public review at the discretion of federal government leaders. And it's interesting that I'm making this comment right after Andrew's good news because those very lands, that trail he just described along Mammoth Creek.
18:47 I'm looking at a map of lands that are potentially eligible right here in our area on the Inyo National Forest, and wow, it looks like that trail would be included. That would be up for sale potentially were this language to be included in the final budget package. Along with that are lands in the Mammoth Lakes Basin, Reds Meadow, the Sherwin Lakes area, Convick Lake, Rock Creek.
19:15 Parts of the June Lake Loop. I could go on and on. What I'm urging Council to do today, as I have in the past before, is to use your power and authority as our local government leaders to communicate with our federal leaders and tell them that this absolutely is not acceptable. Tell them what would happen to the town of Pimp Lakes were the incredible natural amenities surrounding our town to be sold off to the highest bidder or developed for energy.
19:43 For other extractive purposes, I'm just urging you to take this on and please get involved and speak out for your constituents. Thank you. Thank you so much. And Stacey, I just want to clarify one point because I knew what you meant. You said 250 acres and you meant 250 million. So for those in- Oh, it's 250 million. I'm reading and I was trying to get my comment in on time. Over 250 million acres of public lands.
20:12 Across the country are eligible, would be eligible if this language stood. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, and I strongly encourage people to go and see the map for themselves. We can make that available on Town Communications because it's a lot easier to describe what isn't at risk in Mono County than it is to give the list of what is. So thank you for your comment. Are there any other comments online or in the room? Come on up. Oh, there's another one.
20:40 Oh, sorry. Oh, wait. Please come to the podium and introduce yourself so everyone can. Hi, I'm Anne Guillempo.
20:49 Long-time Mammoth resident, 25 years. I'm a licensed psychologist, still working. I want to comment on the same thing that Stacey did. She covered a lot of ground. Let me cover a bit more since I have climbed all over the country. Colorado has a lot of private land. So basically you're driving private property, private property, private property, keep moving, private property, keep moving.
21:16 The last 14 are on our list. We ended up paying $150 to climb it because some retired Exxon execs had purchased the ranch. So, yeah, I think in terms of the reason that the tourist trade that is our life's blood comes to Mammoth,
21:36 Is so that they have access to the Lakes Basin, to Convict, to Sherwin, to all of our natural resources, all of our natural beauty. And, you know, to either run into a sign that says, stop, private property, you can't go here. Or, oh yeah, here, you can come, sure. Pony up 500 bucks and you can spend the afternoon in the Lakes Basin. So, I just don't see this ending prettily in any capacity.
22:05 Thank you. Thank you. And Jamie, I'm sorry, I didn't see another hand online. Go ahead. Carrie, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello. I am a past resident of Mammoth Lakes, and of course, I'm here to say the same as Stacey Corliss just said. A lot of people are using the narrative that public lands, the sale of public lands
22:36 We'll be a net positive that we'll build the housing on it. We don't want new housing in the wilderness interface for why housing density is better. But besides that, my companies are saying that it is safe and they can keep your water safe and your soil safe. And that is absolutely not true.
22:59 I am an environmental scientist, so something to consider and keep track of as you speak. You know, go up the ladder in the legislative process and confront what is in the reconciliation bill and the reason they're trying to pass this giant bill right away that no one is going to actually read through is because awful things like this are snuck into it. So thank you so much for your support.
23:29 Thank you. Anyone else online? Thank you. And I don't see anyone else in the room arising, so thank you so much for participating. We always appreciate public comment. And now I am wondering if there are any additions to the agenda. Well, I'm not wondering. You're not wondering, you know, don't you? Yes, Mayor Bubser, we do have a request to add the discussion item.
23:57 On the very topic that several public members have brought forth, this has come to our attention after our budget was, I'm sorry, our agenda was published, and so we are seeking to add this as an urgency item tonight for discussion with council.
24:17 And so there's a specific process by which that we have the ability to do that. I'll ask Andy to read those legal components at this point. But we will take the item up as long as it passes with four-fifths vote from council to add this to the agenda. And then we would start immediately with the discussion and potential outcome for communication from mayor to our...
24:43 Federal representatives at the state level, so our two state senators and our state house representative, Kevin Kiley. And you mean our federal senators, but I know what you meant. I said federal senators who are the representatives in our state, the two. Okay, gotcha. Just making sure we're clear that it's for Alex Padilla and Adam Schiff. Yeah. Thank you. Andy, would you? Yeah, happy to. And council, my apologies for not being there. I haven't left my house in three days. I'm sick as a dog.
25:12 The process to add something to the agenda is the same as we've used before. You just have to have a two-thirds vote, which in this case is going to mean four out of the five of you voting to find that there's a need to take an immediate action and that it came to our attention after the agenda was posted. So if four-fifths of you agree that something has to be done on this prior to the next council meeting, which is July 2nd, then you can vote to add it to the agenda with that finding.
25:42 Thank you. So do I now ask for a motion? Yes. Andy? Okay, great. Yes, that would be correct. Is there anyone who would be willing to? I move that we add it to the council agenda for this evening. All right. I'll second that. If there's a need for any additional discussion, I think it would be helpful to understand what the urgency is, given the fact that the U.S. Senate is supposed to vote. The timing of this is that we need to get, I think we need to get this done before the Senate takes a vote.
26:11 If that's necessary. And I understand that, John. My question on it, determining how much time we would spend on it here, would be, I believe Rob has the power already through our legislative agenda package to write a letter in opposition to this without us spending a whole lot of verbiage on it. Okay, well, I think you've got a motion to second, so if you want to go to a discussion, it's up to you, Madam Mayor. Is it okay to call the roll?
26:41 I want to hear what you say, Bill. I don't feel vocal today, so I'm leaving it off. No, you've got to put it closer, too, or else the public isn't going to be happy because they're watching and listening, so thank you. Jamie, please call the roll. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. Yes, thank you. So we'll just go ahead and take the item now, if that's good for all of you. Absolutely. Okay.
27:13 And so what we're bringing forward tonight is really a discussion, and Councilmember Sauser is exactly correct. We have a legislative platform that outlines at what point in time I can create a letter to bring that forward. I think the intent tonight would be to get a formal, more powerful sort of message out with regard to
27:40 The desires of the Council, and so that's why we wanted to bring that out in a public forum. And as Council Member Wentworth indicated, there's a timing of this which would need to be in the hands while in advance of our next Council meeting, which is July 2nd. And so that's why we wanted to cover that tonight and get the process out here. As I mentioned, or was mentioned in some of the public comments, the bill text that did leave the Senate
28:09 The Energy and Natural Resources Committee indicated a desire to sell about 250 million acres of public land across 11 western states. This was a combination of Bureau of Land Management land as well as the Forest Service land. And so they do have a map where you can see the proposed areas. I did have a conversation with the Forest Service about this on Monday. They indicated that there was
28:38 You know, a lot of stipulation and challenge for some of the Forest Service lands specifically that would still need to be worked through. And I think a lot of the text as it lies will probably face strong opposition. But if we don't get our voice in there, our voices will not be heard at this stage of the game when things are starting to be put together. So incredibly important to do that. I think there was also some council members who had things that they wanted to say with regard to the impacts of this.
29:07 It's far-reaching, right? It's not just right around what's in Mammoth Lakes. It's our overall utilization of public lands. So the proposed action will be to have a letter drafted and signed by the mayor in opposition of any land sale of federal lands and for those to be shared with our two senators at the federal level as well as our House of Representatives.
29:34 Kevin Kiley, who represents us in Washington as well. So I'll leave that to you for further deliberation and discussion. Great. First of all, does anyone have any questions? Questions just about the letter and the process? I think it's pretty straightforward, but I just want to make sure. So then what I'd like to do is hear from each of you if you're interested in giving some
30:06 Some of your input about what you want to make sure ends up in there. I think that would be good. We've already heard from the public, but we'll take public comment, and then after that, I guess we'll still need to vote. So does anybody have anything that they want to make sure that we're including as we draft this letter? Not including or just comments? Or comments. It's fine. Whatever you want. Just if you have anything to offer.
30:33 Go ahead. I've got a couple different things. As a person who utilizes a lot of these areas that are under consideration for recreation and for fishing and other sportsmen's activities, I'm very concerned about the loss of this area for potential use down the road. I'm not sure what the justification is other than money to balance the budget. If this had been worded in a way, and I just wrote a little sentence that was...
31:02 That I thought would have been more of what we would like to have because we were looking for potential, we were a town that's limited by our resources around us and what we have for property. And if it's something about wording that focused on sale of property, only occurring for important public objectives, not feasible on other land, such as community expansion or economic development, that outweigh other public values like recreation and state views, sales could be limited to isolated tracks and land difficult to manage or no longer needed for its original purpose.
31:31 Including still safeguarding protection of critical resources such as water, wildlife, and public access. I don't see anything that's part of where this is going and therefore I would strongly oppose and support us moving forward with the language to oppose this sale property. Okay. And just add to it, and Jamie sent it out, it was sent to an email in regards to that as well. I just want to make sure all the council members received that. Jamie sent it out a little bit ago.
32:00 Yeah, I saw that. I haven't had a chance to read it, but we'll make sure we do. Thank you. Mayor Pro Tem? I mean, I just think this would be devastating if this went through. So, you know, I don't have anything specific that I want to add to the letter, but, you know, I think that now's the time to say that this would be horrific for our community. Thank you. So, whoever, I'm assuming, Madam Mayor, between you and the town manager, you guys will be working together to draft it. Yes.
32:29 A couple things to just point out that the legislative language seems to be changing like by the day. Sure. It went from 250 million acres on Saturday to 300 million acres on Monday because exemptions were approved for grazing rights. So if you have grazing rights on federal public lands, you are no longer exempt. That land can be sold as well. So this is a very fast-moving thing, so I would encourage you to get as up to speed as you can with what this is going to look like.
32:57 The other thing that I think is important to mention is that our congressional district was recently, the boundary was recently redrawn to significantly represent the Sierra Nevada region in California. Any vote by any elected representative who portends to represent this region in favor of this would represent the most profound betrayal to his constituents, his or her constituents.
33:26 And to the value of this region, to our visitors, to an audience of millions. And I think that that really needs to be emphasized should this get to the Senate and go back to the House. This is a direct threat to our economy. I mean, let's just talk economics. This would degrade the equity that we have that compels visitation, that compels the mechanics of our economy and how this works. And it's a direct threat to our quality of life.
33:55 And also pay attention to the exemptions. If you look at the current maps, what's been coming out of D.C., things like ski areas are not exempt. So theoretically, Mammoth Mountain would be in a position to have to think about buying the mountain on which the ski area exists. Or another higher bidder of whom we don't know who that could be. Exactly. And things like grazing rights, that's very much in play.
34:23 So I would just encourage you to look at all those things. But just to really emphasize that a vote by elected representative to support this is a betrayal, the most profound betrayal that could be imagined. Got it. Thank you. Okay. So I agree that this could be a huge deterrent or issue, if you will. My problem is
34:49 The federal government right now is going through machinations on a moment-by-moment basis, and I have no idea what's going to come out of this. Could potentially the sale of some federal lands be to our advantage? Yes. I mean, they could be. We need land for housing. We need land for a lot of things. I don't know how this is going to go or how it's going to end up, but I do caution us from getting too wrapped up in the moment because I have no idea.
35:19 I don't think the man in charge in Washington has any idea what the ask is going to be now or later. I can tell you that I heard these same arguments about federal land being exchanged back when all the private land in Mammoth consisted of old Mammoth and the Sierra Valley sites. Everything else was public and it got sold and traded. So it doesn't always mean that it's a terrible thing, although as it stands, I'm firmly against it.
35:49 And would like to see us send a letter. I have no problem with that. But I just don't want too severe of a knee-jerk reaction when this is, again, something that we have no concept how it's going to come forward. Some of the verbiage that Brent is talking about could be added in somewhere along the lines. Congress could step in and change it. I am confused with the state of things on the federal side.
36:19 So, I mean, I have no problem with a letter in opposition, but some of what's in there, it's not always just a bad thing. Well, I think inaction would be worse than writing a letter and them changing something and it, you know, wasting our time to write a letter. I think, you know, not doing anything would be worse and, you know, selling it to the highest bidder. I don't think the town of Mammoth Lakes is going to be the highest bidder for these lands, so.
36:48 I'm glad to hear that everybody's supportive of it. I have no problem. I support writing a letter in opposition as it currently stands without modification and clarification, as a lot of our letters ask for with state and federal things as well. Great. Hearing that direction, I just want to highlight a couple of points that I think would be important to have in here.
37:16 You know, we'll talk about the town of Mammoth Lakes. We will talk about the fact that these sales could take place with little or no public input. That's as it's currently written. The other thing is that I think it's very important we highlight the specific places that are literally adjacent to our town that are portals to the places people come here specifically to visit, such as, but not, you know, just some of the main...
37:44 One's to point out are the Lakes Basin, Reds Meadow, and even the slopes of Mammoth and June Mountains. I think the Sherwin Meadow and all that amazing work we've done, all of those are in play. So I think we'll talk about the fact that these landscapes are not only, you know, icons of natural beauty and biodiversity, but they're the very heart of our economy, that this is a strong economic detriment to our entire community. We'll talk about our visitors.
38:14 I think it wouldn't be a bad idea to mention that we've just done the SEDS and that was our community economic development strategy and it repeats multiple times in that report how important sustainable recreation is to our economy. I think when we talk about California jobs first and again note that many of the projects that the state of California is supporting are again because of sustainable recreation.
38:44 And then I think finally just making sure that we talk about how we've been reaching out to our congressmen, our member of Congress, Congressman Kiley repeatedly as we appeal to other elected officials, our federal officials. So I think that we all seem to be on the same page.
39:10 Two quick additions. One is... And then obviously the ones that I heard here on the dais. Sure. When you're looking at the maps, I would encourage you and Rob to be very...
39:19 specific about who's generating those maps. The only two, the big maps everybody's seeing are being done by the Wilderness Society and also by the Outdoor Alliance. There is no official federal map, there's just a language. That's their interpretation of the maps. The other thing is I would encourage you to CC our state representatives on this as well. Our states, we had a very good meeting with our state assemblymen recently, I think. Yeah, and if you thought of it maybe to add some language in there about how would the state
39:48 Or how would local communities engage with and dispose of these opportunities, which is not spelled out in the federal language, but that would represent, I mean, all kinds of hurdles and problems and things like that that would have to be anticipated and figured out down the road. So I would just consider those things. Absolutely. And then we should.
40:10 Think about, and I don't have the language even proposed yet, but part of the challenge here is that if a lot of federal lands around our area were sold off, you know, the problem is, I hear you, Bill, like, sure, a few acres to do some housing for federal employees right here in town might be beneficial, but if there's a big sell-off around here, there's no water. So...
40:33 There's just so many factors that haven't been contemplated. There's no infrastructure. Who's going to pay for all this? The town of Mammoth Lakes is not in a place where we could take this on. So with that, just to close the loop, is there any public comment online or anyone in the room who has anything to add? Ann Gimple again. Just one quick thing. If you look at the map,
41:05 It doesn't just impact us. It impacts Bridgeport, their public lands. It impacts Inyo County. All of their trailhead access is at risk. So I don't know how you guys feel about strength in numbers and coordinating with other public entities. Seems like the Board of Supes would be a slam dunk. I have no idea how easy Inyo's Board of Supes, or sorry, Town Council of Bishops are.
41:33 Bishops Town Council is to get along with. But, you know, I'm thinking that if you can draw in a few more folks so it's not just Little Mammoth Lakes, it's like the whole Eastern Sierra would be very negatively impacted by this. I think that your letter would have a lot more punch. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone online? Okay. Thank you very much. So, Jamie, would you please?
42:01 Do we have a motion and a second. Do we need to call the roll? You had a motion and a second to add it to the agenda. I think you need a motion and a second to create that item. Okay, thank you. Lost track of that. Thank you. I move that we send the proposed letter. I'll second. Okay. Jamie, if you could please call the roll. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. Thank you. May I make one more? Certainly. I want to point out something that was said. There are no official maps.
42:31 The maps are coming from non-official sites who are in opposition to any of this anyway. So that's why I was saying clarity. I need to see some clarity somewhere. Maybe we never will. I don't know. But for me personally, I would love to see an official map of what the federal government has in mind in this BBB they're trying to pass. And I think, Bill, to that point, another thing to perhaps consider with the letter is should
43:01 The legislation is written go through and you have right now, according to the map, 16 million acres in California that needs to be sold within five years. Who is managing? What is the management program for those 16 million acres while they're being sold? What happens if they don't get sold? These are the types of questions that you and Rob could consider. Those may be things. Well, and this is an important thing, John. Is this being sold as a business deal to try and
43:28 Recoup some money that's being given away somewhere else? Or is this being put together as a bill to help the citizens of the United States? Because that's the crux of what our government is supposed to be doing. And to that point, another thing for perhaps you all to consider is for some reason the state of Montana is exempt from this.
43:48 Now, is the state of Montana positioning itself to be the last good-looking state in the United States of America? That doesn't seem fair, and that doesn't seem to be in the national interest. Right. You may want to point that out as part of the commentary. All right. So, now we will go on to reports from commissions and departments. Mr. Brown, Parks and Recreation. Evening. May I may. May I pretend. Members of Council.
44:24 Staff in our community, we are very pleased to share our new beautiful Recreation Summer Guide. Plenty at the back if you want to jump in and have a quick look. So that means summer is officially here, apart from Thursday, Friday, maybe Saturday. But anyway, so please do spend a little bit of time. This is distributed throughout town at all our facilities, up and down 395. We're trying out a new map this year. So previously we've used kind of the town.
44:53 Loop, very busy map. We've tried to come up with something that's a little bit of in between, so you can kind of see the red kind of marker there, that was kind of our town loop, and it really tries to show the connectivity access to our kind of town facilities, a little visually appealing graphic showing kind of what you can do at each facility, and then it's numbered, so you can kind of reference the number to the back of the guide.
45:21 And just shows you kind of what the facility is, what it's about, what you can do there. And with everything, QR codes are everywhere. So we have one on the front there to help how many users connect with the Parks and Recreation department through our website. So there you go. Very proud of that. It's a little bit late. Normally we try and get that out in May. But again, here we are getting ready for summer.
45:46 A couple of other updates. We just kind of finalised plans today, met with a lot of our stakeholders for the July 4th fireworks show at Crowley Lake. Again, town's hosting a wonderful show. Encourage everybody to come along if you can. Come down to the lake, kind of see the fireworks go off. It's about a 17-minute show. There's big stuff, little stuff. If you've seen fireworks, it's pretty much the largest show in Eastern Sierra. And we're hearing today...
46:15 From the crew that I think a lot of Bishop Inyo residents are coming up because their show is getting smaller, ours is kind of getting bigger and so forth. So we're really excited to kind of welcome a lot of our residents visitors to Crowley Lake for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Fireworks Show. You'll see a lot more information coming out about that soon. Parks and Recreation Summer Camps began on Monday. School kind of finished last week. They're now hosted at Mammoth Creek Park Community Recreation Center.
46:44 Rob and I had the privilege of meeting all our camp councillors at the traditional pancake breakfast by our resident chef, Doug Gebhardt, which is very good. Pancakes galore. Anyway, so I had a great kind of an introduction, welcome to our camp councillors, a really good crew. We have upwards of 25 staff working with our kids this summer, so we're really excited.
47:10 So all the check-in and pick-up for our kids is taking place on that kind of grass area while that construction continues. Whitmore Pool open to the public for full seven-day-a-week operations. We've been open, well, we started for one day with lap swim, shut for three weeks, reopened for lap swim, and now we're open seven days a week at Whitmore Pool. Sundays in July is always our kind of park and recreation month.
47:37 Free Swim Sundays, so we'll kind of get the schedule out for that. And then lessons, which are always full to kind of help promote water safety throughout the town begins on June 21st. The Mammoth Rec Zone is now also operating seven days a week. And that's kind of scheduled from noon to 6pm. Again, everything's kind of on our website. And then what we're trying to do is kind of keep this consistent schedule. So noon to 6 is all open play. So if you have a membership, you can come by at any time.
48:06 And play any of those activities. And then from 6 to 8 p.m. is our kind of drop-in pick-up time. So we're scheduling, depends on the day of the week. You can come in and play futsal, dodgeball, ball hockey, volleyball, basketball at that time. If you're a non-member at $7 membership, it's free. So we're really excited about that. Just a quick update on the annual membership sales program. We just kind of wrapped up that 50% discount in May. Now we're in kind of a regular sale period.
48:35 Until we hit the 50% discount again in October. So memberships, we're looking at 136 sold of annual memberships and 18 of the monthly memberships. And what is really kind of pleasing to see, last year we sold two, I think, or three family memberships. We're up to 40. So, I mean, work that out as a percentage. Really impressed to see that. 46 adult memberships. 33 kids have paid $50 to
49:04 Play in all our facilities year-round, which is great to see. And 18 of our senior military residents have paid, 16 of those have paid to be an annual member. And then, like I said, about 18 monthly membership. So that's our update. Happy to answer any questions. Really looking forward to a great summer. Thank you for the time. Thank you. Questions? No questions? Off to a good start. It is. Things crossed. Yep. I really like how the water filling stations that are on the bike path are called out. And I look forward to
49:35 The day when we have many more. Yes. Yeah. And thankfully, we have Rotary coming forward, helping us with a bottle filling station at the Pickleball Complex. So we'll have that going up here pretty soon. That's awesome. And again, another one at Whitmore. Thank you. Thank you, Rotary. Yeah. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you. Any other here comes to buy you? Good afternoon, Town Council, Mayor Bobser, Mayor Pro Tem, Manager, Clerk.
50:07 I'm Sabian Spring Airport Operations Manager for Mammoth Yosemite Airport. I've wanted to give you guys an update. It's been a while. We have a parking lot under construction that has been a bit of a treasure hunt. We've found lots of infrastructure under that pavement in the last few weeks, wrapping up about two weeks left. We really appreciate the patience of airport users for that. It's going to be a beautiful thing.
50:36 Springtime, our crew did lots of education, so we all got a chance to go out for aircraft rescue firefighting. One of us, two of us went to airfield striping and marking certification school, and I attended an airport snow, advanced airport snow academy.
51:02 You could teach that. Believe it. Every airport's a little different. They made the point, if you've seen one airport, you've seen one airport. So I did learn a lot, but we're excited to try out some of the new techniques that we learned through the summer and into the winter. I did want to make the point that as we're working out there,
51:29 Making continuous small moves toward utilizing the airport for emergency services and wildfire resiliency, that is our goal. We have daily opportunities to work with all the other town departments, and it's been a wonderful experience from roads to the engineers and public works.
51:58 To finance, it's working for this, working with this group is amazing and we're grateful for it. We do have flights starting next week, next Friday from Hawthorne and Carlsbad and they will be on Fridays and Sundays through Labor Day. Looking forward to that. That's all for now. If you have any questions.
52:25 Love to. Just wanted, did you now get to add, what's the acronym, A-A-W-S to your title? It's actually A-S-E. Yes, I do get to add letters at the end. More letters. We also went through our EMR, so Emergency Medical Responder, which is a 56-hour class we have to do every two years. Yep, just more letters. Thank you so much. All right. Mayor Bobser, I'd just have a quick update as well, if I may.
52:57 Certainly. So as we talked, as you know, the town was asked earlier this year to assist Forest Service in providing some staffing called recreation technicians based upon staffing shortages and inability to hire that would impact our visitation, right? So the town, back I think in March, town council approved the expenditure to hire those positions. I meet with a local
53:27 Four service representatives on a monthly basis on a one-to-one meeting and was asked on Monday or introduced to another issue they're having with regard to restrooms and that is the inability to service the contract for pumping out the vault toilets in the region and so I think those are typically pumped twice a year and they've asked us to
53:52 Uh, lean into that space and assist in advance of, uh, 4th of July. So I went ahead and authorized that in conjunction with a discussion I had with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, uh, Kim on a, on a Clario with regard to utilizing Camp Leca Pro funds, uh, to fund some of the units outside of town's jurisdictions. Uh, of the units that were requested, uh, one is at Convict Lake and the other one is at Hot Creek, uh, the trailhead overlook.
54:21 There, and those two are going to be funded by Camp Like a Pro Funds, and then the town will be taking care of everything else, you know, in our general region, which would include Lake George, Horseshoe, Agnew, Matt Agnew, as well as Rainbow Falls Trailhead, and, let's see, there's a couple more, but.
54:43 We'll be taking care of that just to make sure that those restrooms don't need to be closed, right? So these are really strong impacts. We continue to find opportunities to support them. These are really budget-level constraint issues from the Forest Service, and it was really tough decisions. I want to commend our local district ranger, Fred Wong. He was trying to get emergency funds, anything possible to ensure that this continues forward.
55:11 But just glad that we had the opportunity to provide that help. And then do we do the Sherwin Meadow Trailhead? Yes. So that one was already in our level of responsibility. Actually, the mountain is covering that for the motocross event. It's obviously going to have an impact on that. But yeah, those are outside of their area of responsibility. Just a quick question, Rob. Is the Forest Service able to have a presence on Scenic Loop Road at all?
55:41 On which one? On the scenic loop road. So on scenic loop, if you're talking about fire restrictions and the enforcement of that activity. Yeah, because there have been people out there with fires and it's a fair amount of people who are too close to the road, those type of things. Yeah, so they do have law enforcement. They're pretty spread thin when you think about the size of the INYO and the availability to do that. The town is also sort of trying to facilitate some work in that space.
56:11 We have a drone that Chief Casabian and Sergeant Hanson have been working on a program by which we can fly that area. We authorize the acquisition of some software that would give us pinpoint GPS locations, and we want to map all the locations where fires can occur out there and assist in the monitoring of that.
56:36 The drone has infrared cameras and is able to detect the heat sources and be able to do that. So we're talking about flying it in the evenings, Fridays and Saturday nights. What we want to do is get a very detailed map of the locations of where people are camping, the active sites and so forth. We still have to work out the enforcement for that. Our police department has a very limited range of responsibility out there. I think it's a quarter mile off of 203.
57:04 Up the Scenic Loop. The Sheriff's Office also has some of that. And so what we're doing is convening a discussion amongst the law enforcement agencies of the Forest Service as well as our town to see if we can work out something to address that. Because the restrictions that have been in place since the 16th, so two days ago, will need enforcement. They will need activity. And that's work that we need to do in that space. I'm curious to add on to that.
57:33 Years ago, unless it's been changed again, the law enforcement budget was taken out of the local forest budgets, and it is its own budget that comes out of Washington. So I'm wondering if a letter to our congressman wouldn't be appropriate there as well, talking about this risk and the need, if we aren't going to fund the forests, to at least fund the law enforcement that is necessary because of the lack of funding elsewhere. Yeah, and I can't, I want to speak to direct
58:03 On that, we do, the town itself received a grant annually from the federal government to provide assistance in law enforcement in the Lakes Basin area, and I think that was cut this year based upon budget cuts. So I think that's the source that you were discussing, but that was really more of a direct responsibility that was given to the town and funded by that that has now gone away. What I was talking about is the funding for the Forest Leos, their law enforcement.
58:31 Group, not anything to do with the contract with the town. It used to be that each forest had to fund their own law enforcement. That was taken out of their budgets years ago and is now coming out of Washington, as I understand it. So it would be an interesting conversation. I may try to make that call myself. If you learn anything and you feel a letter would be necessary, just let us know.
58:56 I just want to ask a clarifying question. You said that our law enforcement can only go a half mile into the forest area? So it's about a quarter mile. Dan Casabian, Chief of Police. So when you go up Minaret Road and you make the right on the scenic loop, we're about a quarter mile in, kind of where it bends to the right and then goes up, kind of crest. That's where the city limits or the town limits are.
59:28 We can continue, obviously, on, and we're usually first responders to any kind of traffic collisions or anything that happens out there, but we are not the ones that enforce anything out there. That would be CHP or the county. And then within the forest area, either CHP county or forest service. So our jurisdiction, as far as enforcement goes, goes about a quarter mile in on the scenic loop.
59:55 If you look at a map, it's kind of drawn where the town limits are. So into the forest within that quarter mile is town limits. So that's us. But once you get past that, into the forest or the roadway, although we maintain the roadway, it's still not our jurisdiction. But what happens if there's a fire out there that was set by a visitor and there's no one from the Forest Service to come? We would respond.
1:00:24 Okay. We would, so we would be the, like a. But you can't enforce. You would just have to go deal with the fire, not the cause. So if we, so, so for example, if something was, if something was to happen, if something was to happen out there and a crime had been committed and we were the first to respond, we can detain, we can hold on to them. That's my. We can, we can, we can talk to them and stuff, but we're not going to interview and stuff like that unless it's an immediate threat. We would hold them and we'd wait for the local jurisdiction to come in.
1:00:52 They would take over the investigation. Thank you. You're welcome. I was to my amount. Thanks for our protection district. Just to echo kind of what Chief Casabian was doing, we regularly, just this weekend, we were on the scenic loop. It's technically outside of our district as well, but as the closest resource, we'll provide whatever assistance we can to make sure that that situation gets mitigated. Often after hours, there's not going to be a resource that's coming, but we communicate with them.
1:01:20 We have that personal relationship to where I just call Jason Wingard or the duty chief on and we just let them know what's occurring. Dispatch goes down to Bishop. So there is a process in place. It's not ideal. But if there is a threat within that vicinity, although it's outside of our districts or the town municipality, we have standing agreements to go out and deal with that. We'll note that our agreement right now with the poor service is expired and we're working to get that updated.
1:01:48 Kind of proceeding with standard practices. So if I could just have clarification. So if you're driving around the seat loop, you look outside, 300 yards off the road, someone's got a fire going in a non-fire pit. We don't enforce that. What do we do? Is that a call to the forest service? What happens in that scenario? So what I would recommend that we pass on to the public is anytime you have one of these, call 911. It's great when people are calling.
1:02:15 The stations directly or the police department directly. But ultimately what happens when you call 911 is you start the proper process. You also document all of this, which is really important is if you have a problem, you have to show that you have the data to back that up. When somebody puts that call in the 911, it will ultimately get resources going to deal with that issue. Again, it's not ideal, but ultimately we'll be responding if we feel like there's any kind of threat that goes just to the fireside. We always ask for law enforcement as well and obviously have that relationship to where we take care of each other.
1:02:45 We will be dealing with it. We're hoping that the closure now is going to start to mitigate how much of that we're seeing. But for the public, Mammoth wants a way to go. And also 911, so that's dispatch, right? The call goes to dispatch. They know which resources to dispatch to the location. If we're the closest, they're going to dispatch us. They're going to dispatch Mammoth Fire as the closest resources, but they're also going to dispatch.
1:03:10 The people who need to be there because it's their jurisdiction. Does that make sense? Yeah, it does, but more so, like someone's got a fire. It may not be a fire dispatch. Maybe someone's going over to say, hey, you've got to put the fire out. Right. If we see something, specifically, if law enforcement is driving down there and they see a crime being committed, whether it's a fire or something else, we can pull in there, we can talk to them, let them know there's no campfires. You need to put it out. If they don't comply, then we go to the next step. We either call, we'll call dispatch, we'll get somebody out there that can cite them and get the fire put out.
1:03:39 So just, Madam Mayor, if I could, just to add on to that. Again, what's in the mix at the federal level is the establishment of a new national fire agency, which if the current appropriation bills go through Congress, that could be established. It probably would not go into effect until next summer. But I would like to propose that as a future agenda item, we start looking at a
1:04:06 Some kind of representation from the council or an ordinance change or something that would allow, to your point, Brent, it's like we don't want to wait for a fire to start to go out and respond to it, but our Office of Outdoor Recreation, which is doing a lot of important work on federal landscapes that aren't being tended to, to be able to go out and do interpretive stuff, to go out to do some kind of patrolling thing or to be able to have a presence on the ground that says, by the way,
1:04:33 This is illegal. You cannot be doing this. So we don't need to get at this evening. But this is as the jurisdictional map starts moving around. These are the kinds of things I think we need to start getting engaged with. So we don't have to deal with that this evening. But I think that's something we need to put on our list. And that was a little bit about what I mentioned with the agencies getting together and fronting a solution. I think that works expeditiously for identifying these things. Yeah. So I just add that. And I would add to the agenda this thing about this National Firefighting Agency. It's not clear.
1:05:02 Whether the Forest Service gets gutted and then goes and becomes part of that agency, imagine how long it takes to set up a new national firefighting agency, there's going to be some interesting times along the way and I think we want to make sure we're all protected.
1:05:17 Thank you. And I think the most important thing I heard, which is something I'm not sure I would have considered, is if I saw a fire in the scenic loop, I'm not sure my initial thought would be to call 911. So that's really good advice. And perhaps something that we can make a did you know for our visitors and community members that that's an appropriate response because it's, you know, there's a no burn ordinance in place.
1:05:44 I sent some emails out to folks on that and
1:06:13 With regard to Whitebark, I don't know if, Janet, if you wanted to talk a little bit about it. Now is a good time. Great. I did send Jamie a map because I just think it's helpful. I know you guys know all the areas that we're talking about, but I think it's important for the public to be able to recognize those. So if you can pull just that first page up, Jamie, I think that would be fine. Scroll up a little. It's a multi-page PDF.
1:06:47 So Janet Hatfield, the Whitebark Institute, and yeah, I got your email passed to me, Rob. Thanks. So just wanted to provide an update on the progress so far of work planned for this summer. So just to recap for those who aren't tracking this very carefully, we had about 1,200 acres funded and planned for this season. The good news is our first contract, which is a handwork contract, there's about 35
1:07:17 So, next week, we should
1:07:46 Hear a break in the noise from chainsaws for the community, which is, I'm sure, welcome by SUP. And then the piling sort of lags behind the cutting typically, and that's by design because we get drier and drier into the season and we're hitting those project activity levels.
1:08:06 That prohibit work, particularly after 1 o'clock p.m., if at all. So Friday will be a complete shutdown day. We're expecting strong winds, and it's hot and dry in advance of the cold front that's coming through. So the crews will just be piling for the remainder of the week. They will resume cutting those last 11 acres early next week, and we expect that contract to be complete by the end of June. So a week or two ahead of schedule.
1:08:36 There will be three other contracts that move forward. The first will be starting June 30th. That will be between chairs two and four up on the north side of 203 at the ski area. That is a mechanized unit. It's approximately 180 acres. We expect it to last six to eight weeks in duration. There's some complexity because of some of the beetle flight ecology that's ongoing.
1:09:02 The rest of the work, two contracts, one at Coldwater Creek Campground, which will close the Duck Pass Trailhead for a time under a forest order closure and work out at the Sherwin Creeks Trail around the Voorhees Camp. Both will proceed after the Labor Day weekend to try to minimize impacts to the recreation community.
1:09:33 We got a lot of work in early as planned and designed while temps were cool and risk was low. We're coming into a really tricky part of the season that limits our work and we're working with the INYO on that. A big part of that is they've added a remote weather station out in the Glass Mountains and it dries us out a lot quicker because those data are averaged. So that's been a challenge but we'll hope for some monsoonal moisture a little later in the summer which typically helps us
1:10:02 Get more work done. There are also two other projects happening, not under whitebark, but the Caltrans median work between Mammoth and June, if you've driven north, is partially completed, and then we have the California Deer Association continuing hazard tree work out at the Inyo craters.
1:10:21 They've been doing handwork with the Bishop Paiute Tribal Crew the last few weeks, and they expect mechanized equipment to get the bulk of the remaining 350 acres done, conditions permitting. So happy to answer any questions related to timing, locations, etc. Go ahead. Janet, I have a question. I was out wandering, as I often do. The area from the Mammoth City site to the Lake Mary Road.
1:10:51 Where does that fit in the overall plans? I'm not seeing it necessarily on this map. Because it's dead. I mean, there's a dead forest out there again, which always scares me somehow. Yeah. So can you scroll up a little bit, Angie? Sorry, I just called you Angie, Jamie. So I'm not sure.
1:11:18 Is it planned for this year's work? Or I'm not sure? I don't know. Okay. That's sort of what I'm asking. Where does that fall in the scope of all of it? Can you know where he's talking about? Alex? Do you remember referring to kind of where Lake Mary had some little Mammoth coming back up? Yeah, that intersection right there. From the Mammoth City site, which used to be an interpreted site, and now it's to the Lake Mary Road. Yep.
1:11:51 On the, what would it be, the west side, is, is, you know, a standing dead lodge full forest. We're seeing it all over. Is that where some house tree work happened last year from the NL?
1:12:01 A little bit, yeah. Yeah, yeah. So where we also worked on Mupp's site. So some of those areas, we actually, when we sat down with the Forest Service at the beginning of the year, we kind of had the existing plans, and then there was also some discussion on areas that concern us. And those were brought up. There's also kind of the Water District was in those conversations, and that's close to their facilities.
1:12:21 Put it on their radar that we're trying to get those work as soon as possible. Again, a lot of that has to do with agreements and trying to get to get to do some of that work. Some of those will be handwork and some will be mechanized. So neither of those sites is kind of a larger project, but we've got pieces of that that we put that they're going to try to prioritize as quick as possible. Mostly that area kind of from Panorama Dome and exactly what you were saying, we've got the dead trees.
1:12:47 You're coming down into Old Mammoth through kind of the throat there. So it's certainly on our radar, and it's, you know, we've made it a priority with the Forest Service. So part of my question there, the Forest Service has not allowed us, the Office of Outdoor Recreation or anybody else, to go in and do anything at the Mammoth City site because of the potential ground. So are they going to allow us to remove those dead trees, or are they going to? Yep.
1:13:15 Second, unfounded. Sure. I did put an inquiry in based off a prior town council meeting conversation with the Forest Service, and they went immediately up the chain because of the circular site status, et cetera, et cetera.
1:13:31 We have a request in for advice on an over snow operation during winter, which would remediate a lot of the concerns for human health. So it looks like there could potentially be a path forward there. And that is, we were up there, we did a community meeting right before the work for the Red Fur Road neighborhood, which has been
1:13:57 All the cutting is done. The piling is happening now. And there was a citizen there who expressed a lot of concern about that lot particularly and pointed out the SCE power line that goes right through there, et cetera. And it had been a while since I had taken a hard look at that. And so that's what sort of instigated that inquiry. So I think that there is the Forest Service has heard the concern. We're looking at sort of new ways to operate to get in there and get some of that work done.
1:14:26 There's some challenges in we need to test the woody material to see what the uptake in that material is to understand if we can move wood off the site or if whatever we cut needs to stay on. So there's some interesting challenges to work through, but they hear the concern loud and clear, and we've tried to help elevate that. Thank you. The other thing to note on that is because we recognize that that portion is going to be so difficult,
1:14:52 We've made all the other areas around it kind of a priority. So we already regularly, we talk about Panorama Dome, Valentine, at Corner all the time. It's on our list. Do trees take up mercury and arsenic? Yes, they do. Well, how about that? It's more likely in the needles versus the bowl wood. So there's some different lessons learned from Montana and other places who have a lot of this kind of issue. And one of the...
1:15:19 Potential strategies would be to girdle trees in advance, let the needles fall out, you could accumulate those, dispose of them properly, and then maybe the wood is less of a concern, but there's a lot of red tape to work through because no one wants to be liable for any, you know, damages to folks' health, etc. And we're looking at could the material basically, if it...
1:15:44 Is deemed not appropriate be used to reclaim sites like Benton Crossing Landfill, who needs a lot of wood chips? So I don't know if that the testing will be pivotal in how that direction comes to us and what we're able to do, but it may be a pretty phased approach, quite honestly, which is better than nothing. So I think we're going to look for any and all activities we can do, but it will likely be a winter operation.
1:16:10 Thank you for your diligence on that. I know it's probably complicated, but really important that we eventually take care of it. Thank you. Anything else? Any questions? Yes, I got a couple things. Sure. So a couple things. First, my understanding is that a lot of the crews that you've hired come from Oregon and that they're very happy to be, or some of them, they're very happy to be working these, the temperatures are better.
1:16:35 And also that things are running ahead of schedule at this point, that you're making really good progress, you're meeting your goals. Is that an appropriate representation? Yes. They're an incredibly professional crew. It started out of the Medford, Oregon area. They do use farm labor certificates for workers, which is how they're very cost effective to get a lot of work done very, very quickly. Okay. So it's fair to say, as you said, that you're meeting your goals for this year so far. So congratulations on that. Thank you very much for that.
1:17:04 Also, the state of California is noticing significant amounts of funding for projects. I think there was a $10 million thing that came out of Sierra Nevada Conservancy just this week. It's tied to the, was it the Sierra Wildfire Alliance group that's been meeting? It's set up by White Bark. Could you speak a little bit to that?
1:17:26 So the funding coming out from Sierra Nevada Conservancy is, my understanding, I've just briefly scanned that, is a small pot of early action sort of type funds. I don't think they're branding it with the same terminology. For work that is shovel-ready that can be completed in the next two years. So again, we're seeing this as part of the emergency proclamation, get work done, there's no time to waste. It's a pretty small pot of money, if you guys have been paying attention to the budgets that we're talking about.
1:17:55 So it's not really a ultra attractive pot because we could use it in a single summer around these parts. I think we're being a bit more patient with the Prop 4 rollouts that look at the next round of the block grant funding that was branded as landscape investment strategy funding several years ago as maybe a more attractive opportunity in the near future to leverage the local investments that the town and others that we're pursuing.
1:18:24 Would help us realize to get some of the more priority acres completed. White Bark Proper is not eligible for Cal Fire Forest Health Grant until we are approximately halfway through the expenditure of our current grant. But I will report that the National Forest Foundation is also an implementation partner here, and they were recently awarded a $7 million award, analogous to the one that we're working on now.
1:18:52 That will conduct work all along the scenic loop and in June Mountain. So I think that's a real win for the INYO. And I know the California Deer Association is looking at their next award. So it's going to be coordinating of implementing partners and welcoming of any new grant applicants into that field to really try to leverage as much out of those Prop 4 funds as we can secure for this work. Okay. Just a couple other things. Okay. We are.
1:19:20 A little bit drifting off of the agenda. Actually, this is a specific request that I made of the town manager to get updates from Whitebark and from the Office of Outdoor Recreation on the work that we're doing. And so I'd like to follow because there's some state level. I'd like to add this a little bit. The other thing, Janet, is we received notification from the Limelight Hotel that they're interested in making a small but a modest donation to
1:19:47 White Bark and Deer Efforts. Rob can follow up with you on that, so that's of interest. And is there anything from the Office of Natural Recreation on the work that they're doing this morning? That was the presentation that was received earlier this morning. But that was just about the sharp trails. That's absolutely correct, yeah. Okay. So the reason I'm bringing all this up is I was in a meeting with the Natural Resources Agency last week with Secretary Crowfoot and their leadership. And I shared with them the work that's happening in Mammoth Lakes. And they were...
1:20:17 I'm quite impressed and enormously enthusiastic about what's happening. The state is positioning itself with all this public land stuff in an advocacy footing. They're looking for examples of the work that is happening around the state to highlight the governor's advocacy effort back to the federal government to try to mitigate some of this stuff. So all the work that you're doing is of enormous importance, and it's getting a lot of attention.
1:20:39 Our Mammoth Lakes Tourism Meeting was canceled today. It's been rescheduled for later in July, but I did have a chance to meet with Pat Foster, the Chair of Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and we were discussing the line that the community has to walk between saying, look at all the great things we're doing in Mammoth Lakes, but not getting ourselves in the position of saying, well, Mammoth Lakes has got it covered. We don't have to give them any money. We don't have to give them any resources. So in the conversation I had with Pat and with John Urdi,
1:21:05 I think it's time for perhaps to the deployment of our mayor, who is very well spoken and very articulate at this, to start doing some public service announcements or things like that, some videos and things like that to our audience. We are doing all this great work, but it's a drop in the bucket of the resources we need to make this happen. And this could help enhance to our visiting public. You need to be responsible visitors. Don't start fires.
1:21:31 Practice Sustainable Recreation Practices. I just think it's an opportunity for us to build upon and keep the momentum going of the work that we're doing and the level of attention we're getting at the state level. So thank you all for your patience. I think we're all going to be following up on this, but I want to make sure we connect with all these thoughts. So thank you. Thank you, Janet. All right. So Rob, did you have anything else or should we move on to? Nope, we're ready to go on. We're good to go on to consent?
1:22:00 Yes. All right. So next we will go through the consent agenda. Are there any items that anyone wants you to pull from consent? If not, I'll read them. I don't see, not seeing any. All right. So first we need to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of June 4th, 2025.
1:22:20 6.2, approve the resolution adopting the amended Town of Mammoth Lake Sustainable Purchasing and Practices Policy. 6.3, approve the resolution authorizing the temporary closure of certain town roads for the 4th of July Parade and Freedom Mile Run on July 4th, 2025. 6.4, accept the project closeout report for Sharp for the Trailhead Facilities Project.
1:22:42 6.5, accept the project closeout report for the child care center project. 6.6, award architectural and consultant design services contract for the child care center tenant improvement project to HMC architects. And 6.7, accept check register 6-12-25 in the amount of $1,220,891.97, whatever that amount is. Do I have a motion?
1:23:12 So moved. I'll second. Okay. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bobser? Yes. All right. Moving on to public hearings. So item 7.1 is the Town of Mammoth Lakes Fiscal Year 2025-26 Master Fee Schedule Update. So Mayor Bobser, as this is a public hearing, there's a process to open that? Oh, I do have to? All right.
1:23:42 Well, so is that I just opened the public hearing and then the presentation and then public comments, right? Correct. So the public hearing is open. Okay. Thank you. So the Town of Mammoth Lakes does update their fees throughout the year, but our major review of our master fee schedule occurs during budget adoption.
1:24:07 And so we've gone through from each department, a request goes out to review the fees that they are charging for the services provided. For the town of Mammoth Lakes, our fees are governed by, really, they're eligible for the cost required to produce that level of service and no further charges, right? So we have to do analysis of what it takes us to.
1:24:32 To perform the fees and sometimes we'll do a larger scale analysis. We haven't done one of those in a number of years, but we typically make smaller updates with regard to needs that we have within the community. So I'm going to go through real quickly and talk about a couple of them. In financial services, admin services fees, we did go through and it's going to make an update on the fee we charge to cannabis businesses for the business tax.
1:25:01 And in prior years, essentially, the charges for that were up to $8,500 per year. And those are pass-through costs to cover the cost of audits, both compliance audits and financial audits of each of those businesses. The cost of providing those services is going through the roof. They're not done by the town. They're passed through to other organizations. In order to stay with
1:25:30 That particular provider, we would have to increase the fees to $12,000 a year in order to make that happen. So what we've done is come up with an alternate solution in which the town will perform the financial audit, and we will rely on the state of California's compliance audits that each business receives annually, and they can submit those with their forms. So recommendation is to reduce the fee from $8,500 per year down to $1,000 per year to cover the cost of the town's audit.
1:25:59 Community Economic Development Building Division. Those fees are really dictated by International Code Council building valuation tables that are published annually, and this one was published in February of 2025. The town then updates our fee schedule based upon those recommendations. Within the development impact fees and affordable housing fees, a proposed increase of 2.3% is in accordance with the construction cost index.
1:26:27 Published by Engineer News Record of the preceding 12 months. That's an annual process by which we use. Through this discussion, there is a larger DIF, development impact fee study ongoing, and that would serve to inform how the DIF fees need to change based upon the needs of the community and how those have changed. So it's slightly different than these annual increases based on a
1:26:53 Cost increase of performing those services, if you will. So more of that will come as we get through that DIFF study and bring back to council for review. On a similar note, our public safety fees, it was two years ago that we updated the parking citation fees within the town, and I think at that time they probably tripled in cost for those who were in violation.
1:27:20 The idea was to sort of right-size us, get closer to where other resort communities were charging, but also to focus on diminishing the willingness to park where they're not supposed to. We do think that probably needs to be updated again, but we need a more comprehensive, deep study on that. And so look for that to occur sometime later this summer, maybe early in the fall. We want to do it in advance of our...
1:27:47 Our winter season, and at the same time, we may be looking at some part-time resources that could support the enforcement activities, so the experience on the landscape is a lot better, but nothing at this particular point. No changes in the public art fee. We've had that zero for a number of years. We think we will be bringing that back in 2026, but for this fiscal year, no changes. Parks and Recreation, we do a massive adjustment to fees.
1:28:14 Right prior to the sign-up for the season, and so Stu and team went through that process in February of 2025, and there's just one minor adjustment with regard to some charges for the Mammoth Creek Park grass area, so that's reflected in the adjustment. So really all in all, I can say our fee schedule changed very minimally this year, and just representing our ability to try to keep things consistent.
1:28:42 And do with what we have here. So happy to answer any questions. Okay. Go ahead. Questions? A simple question, Rob. So all we charge for the grass area is $17.50 per hour plus the shelter is like $20 an hour. Is that a correct fee schedule? There's a two-hour minimum, though. Okay. Are you good? I'm good. I'm just trying to make sure I...
1:29:10 I laugh, but it's a great question because we receive oftentimes the amenities and services and basically facilities we provide are so popular, right, that we do want to make sure, though, that they're affordable and people who have any aspect can enjoy them. And so we will look to keep our pricing very, very reasonable because it's really for the community. I think it's a great community benefit.
1:29:39 I'm just impressed that we can keep that low. Any questions? All right. So then next, is there any public comment or testimony for this public hearing? Anyone online? Okay, seeing none, then I will close the public hearing. And is there any need for deliberation?
1:30:10 Otherwise, I can also entertain a motion. Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council adopt the attached resolution establishing and updating a master schedule of fees and charges for town services for fiscal year 2526. I'll second. All right, Jamie, could you please call the roll? Council Member Souser? Yes. Council Member Truax? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. All right, then moving along, we have another public hearing.
1:30:36 And this is on the approval of appropriations limit, investment policy, reserve policy, debt policy, and annual budget for fiscal year 2526. So with that, I will open the public hearing. And it's all yours, Rob. Thank you. This is not even arguably the best presentation of the year. I just have to say that out loud. We'll wait. We'll see. You'll see. Yeah, we'll see. We will see. The year is early.
1:31:04 As soon as I get this thing to respond, we'll get moving here. Okay. All right. Thank you for that. And Mayor Bubser, you are correct. We have a number of things we are approving tonight with the final budget. There are, in addition to adopting the budget, we will be reviewing the number of policies that are there.
1:31:31 And so I'll walk through these each individually that are on the screen. So the first one is adopting resolution establishing the Town of Mammoth Lakes appropriations limits for 25-26. Appropriation limits increase annually based upon a calculation between how population adjusts and then how our CPIs adjust. And so those two factors together indicate a 4.75% increase.
1:32:00 And so we start with the previous numbers, maximum calculated limit, add those rates of increase, and then that's where we have the new appropriation limits of $33,759,798, so that we are within those limits on our budget as presented this evening. So this will be adopting a resolution establishing that that has been acknowledged and we're in compliance.
1:32:27 Second one, adopting a resolution amending the Town of Mammoth Lake's investment policy. And there is some write-ups associated in the staff report if there's any adjustments. There's no adjustments to our investment policy this year. Prior years, we've made adjustments to the amounts that we can have in both either camp or LAFE, which are municipal code investment areas. But no adjustments were necessary this year, and staff is monitoring that.
1:32:57 We are also adopting and amending the Town of Mammoth Lakes Reserve Policy for 25-26, and the policy for reserves does change annually. It's based upon a revenue baseline that we established during COVID time periods, and town staff will review what this revenue baseline needs to be on an annual basis, and it's really tied to where we are with the general fund revenue, as any reserves are designed to replace.
1:33:26 Missing revenues. That's why we use that as a baseline for focus. And the components of the reserve policy remain unchanged. They are reserved for economic uncertainty, which is 20% of our baseline revenue number. Then we have an operating reserve, which is 5% of that operating item. We have a debt reserve, which is 50% of any debt service payment that is paid for by the general fund.
1:33:56 We had some modifications to that this year as we took on the new town hall debt that required us to add that. And we increased these reserves through the budget process has been a council action for the last couple of years. So as we put the budget together, I'm required to find the funding within that process to make sure the reserves stay within policy.
1:34:22 And so since we've established this, I'd say in the last five to six years, we've been within policy of our reserves. And they're very healthy. 25% of our revenue being in a reserve plus what we have for our debt service is very, very healthy. The other one is...
1:34:44 Adopting a resolution affirming the Town of Mammoth Lake's debt policy. There are no adjustments to that, so it's the same policy we had from prior years, so we just need to reaffirm through resolution. And then finally, as we go through the budget discussion, talk about that tonight, we will adopt a resolution approving the Town of Mammoth Lake's annual budget as presented to Council with modifications if there are any that are provided.
1:35:07 In the packet, obviously there's a staff report that outlines, you know, the contents of all of these either policies or the budget components. We will walk through a brief amount of them as we look at the PowerPoint that I have prepared for you tonight. But I'll also point to the fact that in the attachment to the agenda item, there is a detailed line item list of every line item within our budget. So it's all there for review.
1:35:34 What you don't have is all the notes of all the content, but you do get to see a comparison of how the budget has been from the actual performance of the last couple of years versus the adopted budget for the prior year versus the recommended budget that we were hoping to adopt tonight for the next fiscal year. So try to give you enough components to look at so you see where things have come from and how we are making adjustments to address new needs.
1:36:02 Those are the things that we're going to do tonight. First item that I talk about here, and this is an interesting layout. It shows you all of the funds that were within the town. We often talk about the color of money because each of these do have restrictions or they do have specific components for which they exist for.
1:36:22 So when we talk about color of money, we're talking about these 37 different accounts and how they have different needs and ideas. We're going to spend the bulk of our time talking about the general fund, which is the very first top line item. And these are designed to kind of show you a change in fund balance where we look at how the revenues or resources are compared to expenditures and appropriations. So we know really what we expect to change.
1:36:52 Really a positive fund balance change of just over $30,000, just under $31,000 for the general fund with, you know, $33,676,000 in revenues versus $33,645,000 in expenditures. Each of these funds are tied to, you know, a specific area within our budget and they perform specific functions. We will talk about several of them tonight and working through that, but this is a really good page just to kind of see the volume of
1:37:22 Okay. Ask two questions on that.
1:37:49 How many of those are in separate accounts? So we see all these different accounts here. How many different bank accounts do we maintain for these? So we have one bank account, which is where our cash resides, and then we have two investment accounts, three investment accounts, where the funds can be held and earned, but we don't have separate.
1:38:17 Bank accounts for each of those. All the accounting occurs in our enterprise accounting system. So it's all tracked in there. So we look at, you know, cash is one item, but it's cash associated with each of these individual elements is all there. And so where that becomes important is when we get interest, right, which we do get fairly good interest in. Both CAMP and LEIF have been in the mid fours for as far as our interest.
1:38:41 We track their balances from a fund balance perspective, and then all the interest that's earned goes to their individual funds, and that's what you're seeing here is individual funds on the 37. And as a protection for the community, when we have large amounts of balances within our operating funds, more than what FDIC insurers, how are we protected for any potential loss of assets if there's anything ever happened to our accounts?
1:39:06 Yeah, so the funds that are invested are protected outside of the FDIC. We keep a balance in our bank accounts of under the limits. And so we're... We keep under $250,000 in our actual operating funds? I think it's $10 million for someone of our particular function. So we have... We have a fair amount of cash at times just trying to make sure we're...
1:39:32 Yeah, we try to keep cash on hand of around $3 million in a bank account. So some of this stuff is going to be a little bit of a review of things we've presented. The way I go through the budget on an annual basis is I try to break it down into small components. So the very first preliminary budget presentation we talked about all funds and employees and really how they lay out. We have, you know, the change in our full-time equivalents.
1:40:05 That's a top line number there, 5.25. A lot of that was based upon decisions and actions made during current fiscal year, 24-25. But they do represent a difference between what we budgeted last year with what we budgeted this year. So in the staff report, I go through the detail and reconcile what those are. We talk about the part-time employees. You see, you know, a slight increase in those of 3.8 and really what particular areas they're showing up in.
1:40:34 I'm sorry, 1.5 reduction in part-time. But our total change in FTE or full-time equivalence is 3.8, an increase from this year to last. We also show a breakdown of the salary adjustments. So in total, our salary and benefit cost change was $843,000. That's made up about 4.82%. That's made up of
1:41:02 Both salary increases, merit increases, and then the discussed employee count changes that are represented above, but as well as that is changes in our retirement, health insurance, and other of our benefit packages, which do change annually as well. So try to list that all out so we have some good variability, but I will say that as an organization, we are very diligent about
1:41:32 Changing our staff counts and increasing staff. We try to do that very specifically with identified needs and strategically how we want to address those. For example, we have at least two positions here associated with our police department and that's really augmenting the service that we have today. So that's where some of that is coming from. But we do address that on an annual basis and it's important to keep that going.
1:42:03 I show you the labor distribution. This shows throughout the general fund and others how they're distributed. So this page covers all general fund components of that by department. So when we were looking earlier about those 37 funds, within the funds are departments. And so each of our departments are categorized here. And then you see, you know, both salary.
1:42:25 And all the benefit costs associated with each of the departments. And those will roll up into the overall department costs, which you're going to see shortly when I talk about expenditures. As you see, we go through not only general fund, but then we have solid waste. We have our gas tax, measure R, airport, local transportation. All of that stuff is outlined. And in some cases, a single employee can be in multiple funds if they have
1:42:50 Work that is performed in each of those categories. So 100% of the employee may be distributed across a number of different categories depending on their workloads. And in our part-time staff, you know, you can see the components of where they occur, what their cost elements are, and the total. So in part-time staff, about a million 370 in cost. Part-time staff have to remain below a thousand hours on an annual basis.
1:43:17 There's a mixture of those based upon the types of duties they perform for us. Talk about labor costs, just showing the overall breakdown of those numbers. Its total cost of labor is $18,365,706 for the town across all labor costs. Switching gears a little bit to the revenue components, there's minor modifications in this for this particular
1:43:46 Budget presentation, I made some adjustments. I did not include them in this. They are in the staff report where it talks about the changes from the tentative budget was presented earlier in June to where we are with the final budget adoption. The modifications there were slight adjustment in sales tax, a slight adjustment in property tax, and both of those were sort of reducing the level of conservative estimates that I was making, meaning adding a little bit more revenue to that in order to help balance the budget.
1:44:16 For our presentation this evening. Yes. Going back on that screen, so when you're looking at like TOT, actual is only through what month though for that $27 million? So those two would be the actual full years of fiscal year, 22-23, so the end of June of 23, and the second one is 23-24, so June of 24. So those would be complete years. Okay. Yeah. And right now, year to date,
1:44:47 And year-to-date for us, it's interesting how we calculate that. We're not yet to the point of capturing Mays. So through April's receipt, we're over $25 million in receipt through April. We will collect May by the 20th of June. So by Friday, Mays are due. May TOT is due. We'll have an indication of that. Typically, May's a fairly light month. We expect it to be
1:45:16 Somewhere around a million or slightly lower than that. And then June starts to pick back up again. You see we're much busier in town. It can be 1.2. So we're anticipating maybe another 2 million. I think total T.O.T. for the year could rival 23, 24, around 27 and a half. So we were able to keep that T.O.T. budgeted revenue just at a million dollars increase this year at 19.5.
1:45:46 And again, it's really important based on the volatility of that to keep that number reasonable and something we'd like to try to achieve within the February time frame just because it is so important for us in the visitation but it's also highly volatile. I will kind of draw attention to the certified properties fee was a fairly significant adjustment this year and it was based upon the first year sort of prorated mid-year charge that we did.
1:46:13 For half of the certified property fee as we launched that a year ago. And then we renew that every January 1st. And so what we anticipate is about $837,000 in revenue this year as compared to $1,350,000 anticipated last year. So as we look at the total, we've increased TOT a million dollars, but really net with all the other adjustments we have, our general fund revenue is about $824,000 above.
1:46:43 Where we were prior. This is just a graphical representation, and Mayor Bubser, I know you asked me to put percentages in there. I did not get a chance to do that. I apologize, but we will firm that up next year with our budget processes. But good, you know, visual graphical, visual representation of just where we receive funds, the bulk of which is coming from transient occupancy tax.
1:47:13 Taking a look at expenditures by department, and as we look left to right on each, so each of the departments within the general fund are represented here. We do have two years of actuals, and those would be complete years. I don't show the current fiscal year because that is an incomplete year, and I don't want to sort of skew the numbers, if you will, but we will show adopted budget prior year and then recommended budget for the current one. The variances on the right to that are showing the change in what is recommended for the budget.
1:47:43 In each of the categories, and you can see where cost changes have occurred, and there's a story behind each one of those. I try to capture a lot of them in the staff report, and the staff report is 70 pages or 60 pages for a reason, because there's a lot of detail in there, a lot of information to be shared. But for the most part, if I could summarize our expenditures, we tried to maintain the level of service and as close to
1:48:11 Possible the expenditures from the prior year, unless we were investing in staff, which we had some adjustments to that as we worked through it, or any other sort of contractual needs that have occurred and come up, and there were a few of those within the police services, you'll see a strong increase there, but that was addition of bodies, addition of some contractual service elements as well, so most part we try to be very, very
1:48:39 And that's slightly lower than the anticipated revenue we should receive. I wanted to pause here because this section, as you see, our Department 480 at the very bottom there is Tourism Business Development. And that has
1:49:07 Really where the allocations from Measure A from TOT go. They're automatically calculated based upon our transient occupancy tax element. And we've talked about this in a couple of different presentations thus far this year about how we want to do, instead of taking the full balance of unallocated tourism dollars and pushing them into housing, that we were going to retain those, you know, for other needed purposes.
1:49:37 And in the beginning of our discussion, I was talking about wildfire protection being one of those areas. And then we've also got some, I think, direct support for our ambulance services in town specifically. And I wanted to put this slide together because really I'm recommending that within the budget we expend 100% of those funds in a tourism-based
1:50:06 Tourism-related expenditure column. I can make a nexus for how these affect our tourism 100%. Obviously, the wildfire protection, if we do have an incident that has effect on us, we will either lose our ability to be at a recreation destination or some portionally or entirely. So we have to protect the assets that we've been investing in, especially with
1:50:30 In regard to all the housing dollars that we've been putting into building and development. So really wanting to try to carve out some annual funding that will allow two things to happen. Certainly to further this program, to assist with regard to grant match and the availability of grants based upon our investment. We also want to encourage other community
1:50:57 We've got a number of large organizations in town, and they're often looking for the town, what are the town investing in this to determine really what they feel the need to invest. And so the idea is here that we want to provide this funding, and we can talk about it on an annual basis. It's probably something that we're going to have recommendations of some sort on an annual basis.
1:51:24 Nothing is long-term committed in that top-line item for Whitebark Institute. For 25-26, I'm recommending 546,000 be provided as unrestricted funds to advance that project. Secondary recommendation here, and these are all included in the budget before you tonight, so if there's modifications to this, then those would be modifications we would need to hear about. Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District is working on a solution for
1:51:55 Providing a second advanced life support ambulance in the town of Mammoth Lakes. And these ALS rigs, as they're known, have higher degree of medical services available on them. They're paramedic instead of EMT based. And they can provide a whole lot more services to the town. We have one in town right now, Medic 3. And this would be in conjunction with
1:52:23 Alish is in the chief to Myers need to add capacity within his own organization and he would be adding a paramedic firefighter instead of just a regular firefighter to that mix. But it's really a partnership that we're trying to explore right now. The town, I'm just starting to talk about our contribution to that tonight.
1:52:46 The 150, it's likely a five-year commitment as you're trying to set up a program like this. It's going to be something that's out there. But we'll be working through what that partnership looks like and who the participants are. Right now, for sure, it would be the town and Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. But we're working with others who have either previously been involved in a contract like this or are involved in the pre-hospital care support for this type of activity.
1:53:16 Finally, in the last two sections, so Mammoth Lakes Tourism has been working through, we're in the final year of our contract for 25-26, where we have a set amount of funding provided to them, $1,725,000. That's present in the budget tonight as well. But we also have two requests that came in that I decided to put into the budget for review for council. And this is really in support of helping Mammoth Lakes Tourism balance the budget.
1:53:45 And how they can keep providing the services that we need from them with some of the constrained revenues and challenges they've had. I think there's been some spending down of reserves in their arena. And so we need to, I'm recommending we support a couple of key elements in here. One being special event funding of $350,000. That's kind of a set amount that's been in their budget. Requests coming through that we put it through the tourism reserve.
1:54:14 So I'm making that recommendation tonight. The second one is the Welcome Center staffing. There's a support that comes from Mammoth Lakes Tourism to make sure that that Welcome Center is staffed and Forest Service is active in that space as well. And so we would just be leaning into that with a tune of $70,000 for this year. So in total for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, it's about $420,000 that's requested and that would be a part of their annual budget.
1:54:42 So we would pay this directly to them and they would include that as a direct pass-through for budget line items they have in their own budget. So I want to pause here and ask for any comments specific to these recommendations. Go ahead. Rob, thank you very much for this. Do you need a drink? I'm going to take a drink of water. There's water in there, right? It's just water. Okay, good. It's the best presentation of the year, right? It is.
1:55:14 So just a quick question. I support all of these allocations. We've talked in detail of what these all, for me, they make a lot of sense. I'm wondering if you could provide, maybe with John Urdi, could provide a little detail on the Welcome Center's staffing, because I know there was Forest Service involved in that, ESEA is involved in that. What does that look like? Especially, you know, we do what we can to make up for federal shortfalls.
1:55:43 What's coming out of Washington, but we're not taking on the whole enchilada. There are tacos in D.C. and there's enchiladas out here. So I'm just thinking about how we set this up for what next year would look like and if things get really dire, what does that whole program start to look like? And I'll let John talk about the details of that, but I do think this is an annual ongoing. It has been for a number of years and not something new.
1:56:12 Essentially with this, but John, go ahead. Yeah, John, our D-Man Flakes Tourism. So it's not new. We have always supported ESEA with staffing dollars. Back 15 years ago when MLT was formed, we actually had Welcome Center staff on staff of MLT. Instead of that, we opted to support them with funding. It's always been a $50,000 line item. Since COVID, we have not participated. So this is coming back now.
1:56:40 And it's coming back now because of some of the challenges based on the federal government challenge. Okay, so if the federal staffing were to go away completely, what does that scenario look like? I think the biggest challenge is just the agreement for the Welcome Center itself because it is a Forest Service building. Right. And I think that that's something that ESEA, or excuse me, Sierra Forever has been working on for multiple years, probably 10, to get that signed over so that they have that facility.
1:57:08 I don't know where that stands at this point, but I know it's been a long process trying to do that. And so this is a slight increase than what we've been involved with in the past because of some of those shortfalls. And this discussion even started back in October before the election when we sat down with the Forest Service and talked about what the shortcomings were going to be for this. Okay, but if the Forest Service were to go away completely, could the Visitor Center still operate? As long as we have rights to the building, yes.
1:57:35 Okay. There is, I know the Forest Service is under pressure. They have, INU's got an inordinate number of visitor centers, and they're looking at budget pressures on the visitor centers. I think Rob may be having a discussion with Leslie Ann about that at an upcoming meeting. So good to know, but change may be in the air. Yep, absolutely. And I think the whole compound, I mean, even our facility is owned by the Forest Service, so.
1:57:56 We lease it through the town. So it's a... Yeah, I know. It's a very complicated thing over there. I think also what we've been hearing is that getting any agreements with the Forest Service at this point, there is a DOGE capacity that's reviewing any agreement, any challenge cost share, anything, and agreements could take years at this point. So I think it's part of our sort of general situational awareness of what this may look like going forward. Yeah, and even little things. You know, we've been working with the Forest Service for the last year trying to renovate them.
1:58:23 Restrooms at the Welcome Center because they're circa 1960 high school restrooms. They're terrible. I kind of like them. It's the first thing a lot of people see. And so we've been working to try and do that. And it's still even to try and get it turned over so that we can do it through the town has been impossible. But they're open. But they're finally open, yes. They are finally open. Yeah, but it's, I mean, anything, anything, it was hard, difficult.
1:58:48 Frustrating before, it's now going to become truly impossible. Understood. And I think that at least locally, the Forest Service is leaning on Sierra Forever to pick up the additional needs. And so that's where we're coming in with asking for the support for that. And that is still, I'm assuming it's kind of a profit center for the... For Sierra Forever.
1:59:09 Yeah, it's still a profit center for them for the book sales and all that. Okay. Yes, and we have a big event there next Tuesday that we'd like all of you to join us with Music California. Music California. Yeah, looking forward to speaking with some representatives. Yeah. Bill, it's open, but they probably use single ply total paper now. I think it's half. I think it's half ply. Any other questions? I have some comments on what John said. Questions on the overall thing.
1:59:35 But since you're here now, the complaints I'm getting out of the Visitor Center isn't whether it's open or closed. The problem is that the Sierra Forever, and we'll call them easier because I've been doing it for years, Sierra Forever staff cannot issue Forest Service permits. So Forest Service staffing is essential for wood permits, for wilderness permits, for all of the things that contribute to our...
2:00:03 Tourism and local health without Forest Service staffs we don't have. So the visitor center being open becomes kind of a, you could almost do that capacity in your offices. But that's my fear. We need to keep in mind that for me, the Forest Service not being at the visitor center, they have never been the hosts at the visitor center giving out information. But they provide all the forest permits that
2:00:32 A good deal of the time now is not available to the public. Might be something to add to the letter. Yeah. But you can get your backcountry wilderness permits online now. They don't do the same thing for wood and they do not. Which is what they're saying is that you can all get them online, but not everybody can just go online and get a permit. Fair enough. I hear you. It's not working very well either. We tried to get permits.
2:01:00 You couldn't purchase it online and then there was a number to call and it's like we're not returning calls at this time and we don't know when we will in the future. Okay. Add it to the letter. So one other question I have is those are some pretty old buildings over there so it's not just being able to access them but it's also being able to who pays for the maintenance. Our buildings are actually fairly new. No, yours are but I'm talking about the
2:01:28 The old theater? Oh, yeah, that's the Forest Service Administration buildings. Right. The Welcome Center and our offices, I think, were built in 2007, 2009, somewhere in there before I started here. So you're not talking about the other ones? So, no, no, we don't do anything. That building is locked. It's like a fortress. You can't get into there anyway. And like I said, the biggest thing that we have been looking at for years is how we can renovate those bathrooms for the visitors that come in, and that's the first thing they see. Okay.
2:01:56 We do maintain the MLT building actually is owned by the town. The lease underneath it is land for that. But we maintain that as part of our ownership. Yeah, I was thinking of the other one. And I didn't realize that the visitor center itself was pretty new. I just assumed it was built at the same time as the theater. No, very new, actually.
2:02:21 Again, come visit us on the 24th. It's a great facility. It really is. And it is a disservice to the visitors when we don't have that open. I mean, to go back to COVID when Forest Service wouldn't allow that to open, we actually borrowed a ticket booth from the mountain and put it in the parking lot and staffed it so that we had people still coming to town. We were able to at least respond to their questions and needs. Okay. Which initially is what that silly log cabin sitting next to you was brought to that location out of the meadows.
2:02:50 And put there forward, so somebody can man it and give information. Next time we'll do that. A little bit of history, sorry. Interesting. Okay. All right, back to... Yep. Thank you. Going back to a couple questions here, Rob. Yep. So starting with the White Bark Institute, so the $546,000, is that, where's that funding coming from? General Budget, Tourism Reserve? Tourism Reserve. Okay. So just as we go forward, I'm going to...
2:03:16 Continue to object that that comes from the tourism reserve. I don't believe that's appropriate. If it came from a different source, I would be more than glad to look at that, but I don't think that's appropriate. Maybe we need to label the tourism reserve, but I don't believe that's what the reserve was intended for. The fire protection district, the $150,000, where's that funding coming from? Everything on this page is the tourism reserve. Okay. Okay. Who does? My objection for some of this coming from the reserve, I just think it should be...
2:03:51 I recognize we're trying to watch how we do the budget, et cetera. I just don't feel it's appropriate. I've said enough of that. I don't need to go anymore. Okay. Thank you. Go ahead, Bill. I have a couple of things here, if I might. I'm having a problem. First, ongoing. The initial Whitebark ask was for a one-year, and we're going to be carrying that over, and I have no problem. Whitebark knows that I support their work, and God knows we need to get it done.
2:04:18 But somehow to me it seems like almost a misuse of funds to spend over half a million dollars to make ourselves look better so we can potentially get grants from the federal government whose responsibility it was to cover the dam for us in the first place. We did $610,000 that was supposed to also entice grants from other local businesses. Did we get local businesses to help? I'm having a problem with that. And as we all know, once you take something from any government group,
2:04:47 And pay for it out of your own pocket. Generally, that never goes away. So I have a problem with that there. My problem with the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District asked here is the same thing. The ambulance services, I understand it today, is provided through Mono County. Yet I don't see Mono County's name here. Mono County, over half the population exists in this town.
2:05:13 The vast majority of their budget comes from taxes paid for by people in this town, yet we find it necessary to come up with another funding stream to fund something that should be coming from the county of Mono to help the citizens of the town of Mammoth Lakes who pay their bills. I'm going to get off my stump there. That's my point on both of those. But I'm getting angry with everybody having their hands out to the town of Mammoth Lakes.
2:05:43 Because we have handled our budget in such a way that we can actually afford some of this. It's not that we are any wealthier. It's that we are providing a better service to our citizens than they are. In terms of the event funding and everything else, I would like to look at that in the contract next year, but I am fine with both of those things. Thank you. We're not deliberating at this point, are we, Madam Mayor? This is questions. Okay, thank you. Those were questions. Sorry. I don't have questions.
2:06:15 Council Member Wentworth, do you have questions? No, I don't. My question's been answered. Thank you. Okay. Then, so we can keep proceeding, right? Yes. Please proceed. Okay. Let me get it to respond to me. That would be great. So, next section, we're moving on into gas tax. So, gas tax, again, you've presented this previously. The way we balance gas tax, we certainly review what we expect to receive from a revenue base from
2:06:49 Taxes collected from the cell of gasoline in the state of California. Comes to us to support roads as well as snow removal efforts. And we also then have a transfer in which would be from the general fund to support this activities. We have a lot of employees who are classified in gas tax because that's where all of our snow removal, all of our public works, parks and so forth reside for the most part.
2:07:17 And so those expenditures are captured here. So we'll have, you know, a little bit of road rehab, a little bit of the capital project discussion, but a lot of this is around maintenance and repair of roads as well as snow removal activity. But we balance that with transfers from the general fund, which is about $3,250,000 on an annual basis. Show you sort of a representation of that particular fund from an expense standpoint.
2:07:45 Where each of those go through, so street maintenance, you know, large portion of that, snow removal, large portion as well as road rehabilitation. You'll see operating costs for vehicles in there and it's fairly substantial for this because that's where all of our major pieces of equipment like loaders and snow blowers, both their cost of replacement as well as their cost of fuel and operational expenses are captured.
2:08:12 We talked about these guys at the end of May. There's really no modifications to that. Go ahead. Just go back. For that cost for vehicle replacement, you don't necessarily spend that every year, though. You put it in reserve and as you have it. So it may not be a physical cost that year, but you eventually spend it. What that shows the representation there is we charge the departments for the replacement needs of each of the vehicles. So those charges are actually direct expenditures to each of the departments.
2:08:41 We accumulate those funds into another fund, 915, which is vehicle replacement. And then once the vehicle is exhausted its full life, we have the funds to fully replace it. So it's kind of an orchestrated process throughout, constantly under analysis on how the vehicle is performing and expenditures, cost, repair and maintenance and those things, as well as an incremental increase for how much we think that that value of that
2:09:10 Vehicle replacement will be over time. And I did make a modification to that this year when going for 3% annual increase to 3.5%. And just associated with that, so let's just say, for instance, someone's driving a town vehicle, they get an accident that's totaled. It doesn't change your allocation. You're still just replacing those based on the years it raised your hand. That's correct, yeah. And so events like that, we have insurance that would fully fund that replacement. But this is really just for something that wears out across time. Any other questions? Okay.
2:09:41 Guests, this is our Measure R fund, so it's broken into two components. Measure R fund 215 is our trails maintenance program. That receives an allocation of $300,000 annually from our Measure R sales tax component, and then we expend that in work on our trail system, either through direct labor costs, through our trail construction labor, or through contract with others.
2:10:10 And that would be in the contractual services components. But really balance that one out at $300,000 a year. Our revenue sitting at $2 million estimated for $25,000, $26,000. And then we have a set of traditional expenditures which are listed in that column talking about the $300,000 to trails, community support, community recreation center support.
2:10:37 Which would be the CRC operational expenses. And then trails managers. Some of the Office of Outdoor Recreation components are included in here and a portion of that staff is supplied by Measure R for the work that they perform. We also have the payment for debt service to the CRC. That's updated annually based upon the debt service payment, 613-227-425-26.
2:11:03 But in total, we should have expected change in fund balance, a positive fund balance change of $668,273 based upon anticipated revenues and expenditures for the year. We'll accumulate those into a fund balance and be able to allocate that fund to a major capital project or something within the appropriate expenditures associated with Measure R. I have just a question on RNU. So, Rob, you mentioned that we're going to be having some kind of a workshop.
2:11:33 In August about Measure R and Measure U? I believe we talked about doing that, yeah. I don't have anything on the agenda as of yet. Okay, I'm just wondering if you could maybe talk a little bit about what you're, I think we're all anticipating that conversation, but in terms of this year's budget, what would your expectations be for that conversation later in August, and could that potentially have any effect on the budget that we approved this evening?
2:12:01 That wouldn't be a problem, but I'm just wondering if that might be something. Yeah, I think if anything is identified as a need there, I do, we do quite a bit of analysis in preparation for this budget discussion and, you know, with regard to reviewing expenditures and revenues, I don't, I think we can stand behind everything I've got presented for you tonight in this area. Some of the discussions we talked about for August is really looking at, you know,
2:12:27 More policy decisions on how things are associated with whether repair and maintenance and other needs are and whose inventory of items provided, those types of things is a lot of the discussion that we want to talk about in that space. So, yes, you're anticipating a policy discussion? Yeah, I'm anticipating a policy discussion that probably won't affect budget for 25-26. Okay, good. Thank you. Yep.
2:12:52 And so similar to Measure R, Measure U, a different revenue source, user utility taxes for telephone, electricity, and gas. And so those components there, you'll see the revenue expectations, just over a million dollars, a million 110. We have some set programming costs in there, as well as some support for Office of Valley Recreation, a little bit of support also for Mammoth Lakes Recreation, that's where their funding comes from. And then we have...
2:13:21 This year, sort of new, is land acquisition for a portion of the purchase of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation property and the payment, the debt service payment for that for the next 13 years and recommending out of Measure U, $180,000 per year. And then we have a set aside that we talk about annually, $300,000, which would ultimately go to operating expenses for the MAC on an annual basis once the MAC is fully operational.
2:13:50 And so we just hold that aside just as a reminder. It doesn't go anywhere. It just is a set-aside, and then it falls to fund balance. So in this particular layout, Measure U will generate about $275,000 this year is a positive change in fund balance if all those things come to fruition. And again, slightly higher than that, the $575,000 is the real change in fund balance that will occur. But just really want to keep eyes on.
2:14:18 Future commitments of any of these funds because they do run the risk of being over committed and at that point you know we could have a challenge with that so really want to keep eyes on anything we have on the horizon for that. Looking at airport operations it has a couple of different components. We we talk about operations as both really the facility and how it takes to run that but then we also have some of our
2:14:48 Capital project costs associated with projects that are going on out there. Those capital project costs have several revenue components. A lot of them are FAA grant dollars. Most of the FAA projects have a required match from the town. The town has a fund balance in Fund 220 actually broken into two components. There's a fund balance associated with capital projects, and there's a fund balance associated with
2:15:15 Providing additional funding for air subsidies that the town fulfills on an annual basis through quarterly budget reviews. But I want to commend Sabine, who's in the audience tonight, on the work and effort she did with Fund 220 this year and really recognize an opportunity for saving in cost expenditures and where we can reduce those. So, you know, you can see the operational expenses declined.
2:15:45 $38,000 for the year, and that's pretty hard to do when you're fully staffed, and your incremental costs are given to you based upon salary and other things, so there's really a good opportunity to look for ways of cutting expenditures, and I want to commend her for those efforts. But that's also balanced, and it's balanced through the general fund contributions, so general fund contribution this year is $1,164,000. That's increasing for a number of reasons.
2:16:14 Post-COVID time periods, FAA was very generous in providing funding for operational expenses, and the town sort of stretched those out across the maximum number of years we could amortize them, which was four years, and so we sort of slowly weaned ourselves off of those funds, and they were fully exhausted in our current fiscal year of 24-25 earlier in the year, so we do not have any of that support going forward.
2:16:40 And so you'll see that adjustment in there. We reduced revenues of $285,000 just based upon those contributions alone. But in total, it's balanced. And really, the bulk of it out there is labor costs. And that's, you know, our organization, obviously, the costs associated with providing services really do land in total labor, which would be salary and benefits, which is why I talked about that in more detail earlier in this presentation.
2:17:09 We did have a presentation earlier on our capital projects. I'm not going to go through any detail of this. This is the list of capital projects. When you look at the combined fund statement, that one big 37 different funds area, you'll see the full expenditures listed in here, but then sometimes revenues associated with those projects are captured in prior year. So a lot of these things cross years, and that's why you see those.
2:17:37 Big changes in fund balance because sometimes monies were put in one year and taken out the next. But this is the plan that Hayes and team have put together for the work. You've heard a lot about each one of these components. There's a write-up of each one of them in the staff report. So I won't spend a great deal of time on them. If I could have a question on that, Rob. So we talked at the last meeting, or when we met last, about that signage, that sort of rogue,
2:18:03 The orphan signage that's out at Mammoth Creek Park is also at the Visitor Center. And I looked at the signage in the Visitor Center. It is particularly bad. When you drive in, it's faded. It's dysfunctional. This is something that happened, you know, back with the R finding that Public Works, Peter Burtisconi said, oh, no, no, we want to do this. We'll take care of it. And it's really a problem. So I don't know if there's a way to, we need to do something about that.
2:18:32 We are currently, we have a project this year for signage, and we were able to take the Shady Rest sign and add that to the scope. Okay. And then Hayes and team are going to be looking at what was out at the visitor center and what we could modify there. So we have eyes on it, and we have designs to resolve it this year. That would be great. Just because from a visitor, I mean, the bathrooms are not good, but just driving into that parking lot. Linus, he's over here. Yeah. Yeah. Sorry. Linus.
2:19:04 Thank you. I just have to say I've never had anybody have to be rescued by search and rescue in the middle of my presentation before, so it is quite an honor. Andy's sick as a dog, but somehow other ones can make it here. Yeah. Another sick dog is here. Okay. Moving right along. Development impact fees are pretty straightforward. These would be a representation of, you know, we talked about the fees earlier, but
2:19:36 When we look at the overall fees, fees are collected during our building permit issuance, so whatever we anticipate for building permits sort of feeds directly into what we would expect to receive here. These are obviously or very frequently over performing based upon really large projects we've had in the last couple of years.
2:20:00 And it's sort of, I don't want to say feast or famine there, but we've had a lot in the last couple of years that's been really strong for building, including that in the development impact fees. Assessment districts would have a number of revenues, and again, back to the staff report, you'll see the more the detail of exactly what the purpose of the district is, what the revenue sources are, which they can be a multitude of fees, parcel level fees.
2:20:27 to contributions from gas tax for snow removal efforts and others that provide the revenues necessary to cover the planned expenditures for each one of these districts, and they'll have expenditures associated with whatever reason they were put into existence. We do review each of these on an annual basis. They come to council with a staff report provided by MBS, and they do an analysis of what's planned.
2:20:55 What you see in my budget presentation is a summary of that. But again, you know, this is a couple of different looks at it that you all get to see, but really important to just sort of show that. Garage services, I'll kind of draw attention to that a little bit. I have a slight concern. What I am showing you here is garage services, which would be the charges for each of our maintenance expectations of our town vehicles.
2:21:21 And where they go to. So about $444,000 just cost of operation and maintenance of the vehicles on an annual basis. And then the replacement costs across all of the other agencies. And again, really a well-functioning program based upon having vehicles when we need them and making sure that our fleet remains current and active and services the needs we have.
2:21:48 And it's worked well for us for a lot of years. The balance in this account is roughly $10 million on an estimate basis, and that would be the funds available to purchase vehicles when their life becomes available. And Rob, for all vehicles, is it something that's non-road registered considered a vehicle, or how do you classify the difference? Yeah. You know, we do have a lot of our...
2:22:16 I think our loaders are all road registered. I know they're certainly recorded with CARB and they have their certificate numbers identified on the side of them. We don't have in the vehicle replacement is small pieces of equipment like we'll have maybe a larger lawn mower that costs around $35,000 but we won't have any of our handheld or push mowers or any of that type of stuff in there. But pretty much everything of substantial cost with that
2:22:46 That identified life cycle would be in the vehicle replacement program. Particularly, I was more requiring like when the sidewalks are plowed and the snowblowers are sidewalks, the non, the more pedestrian oriented equipment. Totally. Yeah, so our tracklaces, we have I think five, four or five tracklaces are included in the vehicle replacement program. Really down to the blades on the equipment because they're a substantial cost to replace. Those are all in the program.
2:23:18 Finally, so debt service schedule. We also got a look at that earlier. We update this annually based upon the debt service plan of each of the different debts that we have as a town. And you'll see that we've included the certificates of participation series 2024, which is the town hall construction costs. That's new this year. And then the rest of them are pretty much there. We did have some debt that was satisfied through this process.
2:23:47 And that would be the vehicle replacement loan that we've had for the last 10 years. That was satisfied last year. As well as the payments for the police facility. That was paid off slightly early in order to allow that facility to be used as collateral for our town hall construction component. And that was structured in such a way to save us money. And it worked out well. So that is the end of my presentation tonight.
2:24:17 Happy to answer any questions that you haven't had or listen to deliberations or entertain a motion on quite a large process. Thank you so much. I think I see that Councilmember Wentworth is signaling he has a question. A question on the town hall project. I don't know if we've gotten an update recently as to schedule. Are we on schedule? Where are we expected? Where are we hooked? Are we supposed to be dried in by time?
2:24:46 Yeah, we're supposed to be in by winter, from inside by winter, I should say. And the original plan was for the facility to be completed by mid-summer of 26, and that the town would move in by late September, be fully moved in, and our lease would be up end of September of 2026. The last conversation I had with Hayes, they were probably three months ahead of schedule.
2:25:15 In the construction. I can't say enough about AMGs doing the work on the building. They're phenomenal, and they're getting the job done. So it's quite nice to deal with a really good and responsive contractor, but they're doing very well. Great. Thank you. Questions? Mayor Pro Tem Rice? No, I'm sorry. Additional questions from this side of the dais? Yeah. All right. Then I will entertain any public comment, either in the room or online.
2:25:46 Seeing none in the room. Jamie, anyone online? All right, then I will close the public hearing. And so if there's any need for discussion, now is the time. I'm looking to see. No one's looking up. I'm just going to reiterate my comment about the use of tourism reserve. And I would highly recommend we look at relabeling that down the road. So maybe that has a different functionality name to it. So that's my only comment.
2:26:17 Anyone else? Well, just, again, I heard from you and from Bill some concern about that. If you guys have any alternative suggestions to make to the town manager about another source of funding, I think other council members would love to hear it. No, just for myself, I have no problem funding this out of the Tourism Reserve. Okay. My problems are funding things that should be other people's responsibility. Okay. Our need for housing is still critical. The need to be able to use some of this funding to reach our housing goals is still critical.
2:26:45 But we find ourselves in a situation where we're covering what, in my opinion, are other people's responsibility. I understand we need to do it. But it's really not about where it is coming from. If a fire burns down the town, certainly we have no tourism. So it's tourism related. If I'm in town and I do a compound fracture and I need medical assistance and the one ambulance is already out, having another one is still it.
2:27:13 Tourist-related expense. I don't have problems with that. It's just overall. And just to bifurcate that a little bit, I actually think that we should be looking as a council because fire and resiliency is such a big item. We should create a label of a fund for funds dedicated in that area. That's where I think we should go. Oh, okay. I see. All right. Thank you. I'm prepared to make a motion if that's where we're at. I am happy to accept that. Really?
2:27:44 Sure. Okay. So I would move that the Town Council adopt a resolution establishing the Town of Mammoth Lakes appropriations limit for fiscal year 2526. Adopt a resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes investment policy for fiscal year 2526. Adopt a resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes reserve policy for fiscal year 2526. Adopt a resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes debt policy for fiscal year 2526.
2:28:10 And adopt a resolution approving the annual budget for the Town of Mammoth Lakes for Fiscal Year 2526 as presented or with Council-directed modifications. It's just as presented, right? I think we didn't hear any, so as presented. Great. I will second. Great. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Souser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? After an overwhelming performance by the Town Manager, yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. Thank you.
2:28:40 All right. I would like to suggest we take a four-minute break just because I know that Joe Bacon has been extraordinarily patient, but we also take a quick, quick break. Thanks for being here. All right. My screen got very small.
2:34:24 We'll give them free rent. Okay. Let's see. All right.
2:34:46 Thank you, everyone. So next we're on to policy matters. Item 8.1 is the agreement with the Mammoth Lakes Performing Arts Foundation to administer an endowment to support operations and management of the Performing Arts Facility. Yes, thank you, Mayor Bubser. So this is an item that we're, you know, coming back to you with. We first presented this in early May and we had several questions and sort of, I had some gaps in the particular agreement.
2:35:16 So what we've taken the time to do in the last couple of months here is to work through answering and addressing the questions and concerns Council brought forth at that point, firming up some of the language and content of the agreement. And I want to thank Joe Bacon, who's here tonight with us.
2:35:36 Also for her efforts in being the other side of the coin and reviewing that process, as well as really establishing Mammoth Lakes Performing Arts Foundation, going through the process of getting that created with the state of California in order to perform this function. So the intent of this agreement is really to memorialize how that foundation will work to grow an endowment that will support the operations and maintenance of the
2:36:06 McCoy Performing Arts Facility, which we affectionately know as the MAC. And so that process, we've got some funding that came from the town issuing that, and actually prior to that, Mammoth Lakes Recreation issuing that from Measure U to support a match for a very generous donor in our community who
2:36:33 has a love for the arts and has provided a great seed money of I think it's $250,000 that's coming from Tambor Foundation and so the initial seed money for this endowment is going to be $550,000 and that'll be you know originally under management if you will by the Performing Arts Foundation. They're also going to be assisting in other fundraising
2:37:03 To support either specific equipment or needs of the facility. I mean, you can imagine a theater has some very unique needs over and above traditional facility needs. And so their level of expertise and passion of board members within this Mammoth Lakes Performing Arts Foundation really would support that level of expertise to know how to do that, right? To know how to go out and fundraise.
2:37:30 For these really specific items. So we try to capture all of that again in our agreement with the foundation and as you've hopefully read the staff report, I will say in Andy's online, you know, he was instrumental as well in going through and reviewing the process by which we need to include just some language about dissolution if necessary and how we go about that. The contract itself is for three years, but we do anticipate this.
2:38:00 You know, to continue beyond that, certainly through extensions, and those will be coming before you as well. So happy to answer any questions, and I think, Jo, if you would like to say anything as well, you're welcome to at some point, whenever counts. Go ahead. Jo Bacon, Secretary of Mammoth Lakes Performing Arts Foundation. I'm here to answer any questions or follow up on the ones that were asked at the other meeting.
2:38:26 And to congratulate John on Sherwin's Working Group in 2009 because we started this process in 2010. So you want... Any questions? No questions. I'd like to say my thanks to Jo for her involvement in getting the agreement dialed in because her participation, her feedback made it a much clearer and sharper document. So Jo, thanks very much for working with us on that.
2:38:59 Thank you, Andy. If you don't mind, I'd like to introduce you to the board, but I'm the only one in the room this evening. Our president is Tom Cage, who you all know is a successful businessman and a 22-year member of the Water Board. Nancy Holland is director of the Eastern Sierra Community Chorus. She's also involved in all kinds of performances in Southern California here as well. Jim Prusch, our treasurer, is the retired CFO for the Port of Los Angeles.
2:39:28 And actually had some very interesting conversations with our private donor who ships things out of there. There's me as the secretary, and then our director is Joni Lynch, who is vice president of marketing for the Mountain. And we're really looking forward to digging into this with the town, hoping those bids on Friday turn out to be good bids and we can move forward.
2:39:55 Fantastic. Well, I want to thank you, first of all, for stepping up into your role, and it's a wonderful board you've all formed, and so thank you for taking this on for our town. We're very grateful. Thank you. Is there, so if we didn't have any questions, I didn't see any questions, is there any public comment online or in the room? All right. Sure, go ahead. Yeah. Andy, just one quick question. Sorry, Andy, one quick question. We covered termination.
2:40:31 But in the governance documents for the non-profit, if they terminate, the money has to go to a 501c3. Does that cause any conflict? Because if they terminate before the end of an agreement, does that create any concern? No. This was an area where we kind of had to figure out how to address it because we're trying to do some things that are not typical. So the way that we've set it up,
2:41:01 The town's initial seed money is protected and other money that the foundation may have raised, it has to be dispersed in accordance with their documents and in accordance with applicable law. So we can't tell them that the money has to go to us. We can't tell them that the money that didn't come from the town has to be dispersed in a way that conflicts with their documents. So the language that's in here,
2:41:32 Does clarify that the town money comes back to the town, but the other money that they've raised has to be dispersed in a way that is both consistent with the law and consistent with the foundation's documents. And I think that's probably good enough. Okay. Okay. And then there was no comment, so I will entertain a motion. I would love to make a motion to approve the agreement with Mammoth Lake Performing Arts Foundation.
2:41:58 To perform fundraising efforts for and administer an endowment fund to support the operation and maintenance of the McCoy Arts and Cultural Center pending a final legal review by Mammoth Lake Performing Arts Foundation Board or legal representative. I'll second. Fantastic. Jamie, could you please? Additional discussion? Oh, sorry. No, I apologize. I thought I looked down. No, that's okay. I would just like to acknowledge the fact
2:42:27 Joe Bacon has been the foundation of so many critically important NGO, non-profit, extra-governmental organizations in this town. In addition to serving on the Planning Commission and as a multi-term member of the Town Council, if Joe's behind it, I'm good. Thank you. Thank you. And so now, Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes.
2:42:57 All right, it carries, and thank you. Thank you. Next, 8.2, consideration of the ordinance adopting the state fire hazard severity zone maps for the town of Mammoth Lakes. Here comes Nolan. Shockingly, somebody else gets to present tonight. It's very exciting. I don't know, I thought Rob could handle all this. He's doing great. And Chief Temeier's back. Hello, Mike. Switch down. Well, I see him down there. He's returned. Thanks, Mike. Go ahead.
2:43:27 All right, so let me go ahead and share my screen. Great, so I have, this item tonight is to consider the adoption of the state fire hazard severity zone maps for the town of Mammoth Lakes. This has been a kind of a joint effort between the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District and the town. So I have here with me, Mike McCarthy with the Fire Protection District. I believe your official title is Deputy Chief? Division Chief. Division Chief.
2:44:17 So he's going to walk through a little bit of the background and where we're at, and then I'll take over from there. All right. So again, Mike McCarthy from Mammoth Fire. This is, you know, we came back and presented to you earlier. So this is just kind of a quick update. State legislation, CAL FIRE is required by state law to determine the hazard severity and all the different private and state-owned parcels in the state.
2:44:48 The local agencies are then required to recognize those maps, to adopt those maps. We don't get to change the maps. We don't get to make the maps. And we're here because they are doing this as an update from the original maps back in 2007. And as you'll see on the next couple pages, I'll remind you of what maps look like. We used to have just a small section of town and very high, primarily in the very upper part of Old Mammoth and the Bluffs area with the updated maps.
2:45:17 The entire town is basically painted as very high and high now. And the biggest thing that they changed in their updated model was they modeled local actual winds instead of an assumption about 20 mile an hour winds across the entire state. And as just a reminder, the main thing the designation affects, these are hazard maps, not risk maps. They're hazard maps. They affect what building or fire codes apply to new construction.
2:45:47 Of course, we've already taken steps back in 2007 to require everybody to adhere to the most stringent requirements. So it doesn't change anything on building or fire code for us. We've already been doing that since 2007 or 2008. And it does affect which properties need to have a disclosure during a real estate transaction. So again, those in very high or high have to get a defensible space inspection as part of the real estate transaction either before or afterwards.
2:46:17 That once these maps are official, then that will affect basically every parcel in town when there's a sale. They'll have to get a defensible space inspection, which right now has only been applied to that kind of Bluffs neighborhood. So next slide, please. Again, the original map, you know, town is in the gray area. You can kind of infer that's the Bluffs neighborhood up there really in north of Sherwin Street and Woodman Street. It's a pretty small section of town.
2:46:48 Everything else was just not labeled. They only labeled the very high. And now with the new updated maps, essentially the trails area, kind of some of the area around the bowling alley, a little pocket near Hidden Valley is in the orange, which is high. Everything else is very high. But all the things that we're talking about apply to very high and high anyway. So it doesn't really matter which of those two distinctions you fall into for real estate inspections or building code or anything like that.
2:47:19 So that's where we're at today. I'll turn it back to Nolan. And then as far as the adoption steps, the state rolled the maps out on kind of efforts with breaking each area of the state into various zones. We got lumped in with Southern California, so our maps were released on March 24th of this year. Once those maps were released,
2:47:46 The entities then had 30 days to get the maps out for public notice and then 120 days to adopt a local ordinance recognizing the map. So that kind of 120 day period puts the deadline on then July, roughly July 24th to have the maps adopted. So we're here tonight to consider the first ordinance or the first reading of the ordinance.
2:48:11 If recommended for adoption, we would then be back on July 2nd for the second reading. Following that, the Fire Protection District will then ratify that ordinance at a future fire board meeting so that both entities have then recognized the maps.
2:48:29 So with that, the recommendation is to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance adopting the maps, as well as finding that the ordinance is not subject to CEQA because the activity is not considered to be a project. With that, that is the conclusion of the presentation. And so myself and Mike are available for any questions. Questions? Thank you so much, by the way. Questions?
2:48:58 All lands identified here are private lands, as best I can tell, or municipality lands, but none of it is forest service land. That's correct. CAL FIRE, the state legislation, it directs them to do this for state lands and private lands, not federal lands. So there's no change or any reclassification of the federal lands? Correct. Questions? Go ahead. I have a question for Attorney Morris. Is he available? Yes. Hello. Hello. Good evening.
2:49:27 So Andy, given this requirement from the state, their change to the wind, apparently it was the wind analysis that was a big change to that, and the pretty drastic exposure we find ourselves in, is this something that we could use as a rationale as the fire team are looking at extending our...
2:49:52 Sphere of influence and communication with visitors outside the town's municipal boundary for enhanced communication and awareness around the threat the town faces from the threat of wildfire that may be coming from federal public lands. Certainly. I think a couple caveats there. I mean, since the maps specifically don't address risks or hazards on federal public lands, we'd have to be able to explain to people what the connection is.
2:50:23 And the other thing is, just as a practical matter, I think it would take some doing to explain to people what these maps mean and don't mean. And if you just show people, hey, most of Mammoth is in a very high fire hazard severity zone, people may think, oh, I don't, maybe I don't want to come there because it's all going to burn. So, yes, I mean, certainly the maps, I think they have some use and we can use them to kind of communicate to visitors.
2:50:48 I think some thought will need to go into how to present that and frame the context in which the maps have been created. Well, and again, I guess I didn't make myself clear. The point would not be to take the maps out and show that to the visitors, but to use the maps as a rationale for us. The conversation earlier was about, hey, PD, we can't go out in the scenic loop because it's outside of our municipal boundary. Is this, could this be this new state we find ourselves in? Could this help?
2:51:18 Do whatever we have to do to extend the fire district, the PD, even the town from an information, the kind of things we're doing with wildlife awareness up in the lake space and those kinds of things. Is that something we could use? Yeah. I mean, I think what the maps show is that there's going to be a need for interagency cooperation, regional cooperation, federal and state and local cooperation, because none of us are existing on an island.
2:51:46 The town is surrounded by federal land, and that's just the reality. We need to work with the feds to deal with that. I mean, it's the same every place in the Sierras, where it's a combination of local jurisdictions, state responsibility areas, federal lands, and it really shows that everyone is going to have to work together to deal with the threat. Okay, well, thank you. I'm just hoping that that can be included in the conversation with all the people working on this.
2:52:13 I think the council is very interested in making sure that we look at any threat and wherever it's coming from to mitigate that. So thank you. Thank you, Andy. You can go back to your virtual non-presence. Oh, I've been dismissed. Okay. Councilmember Woodward, if I comment on that a little bit further. Sure. So the way that the modeling works is the main thing it's looking at is amber cast. Sure. And really the amber cast and it's based off the wind.
2:52:41 Clearly, you can make the inference that exactly you're making, which is the hazard is being impacted by the lands around us, even though we work pretty closely with CAL FIRE, and they will not give us the modeling on federal land. So that's absolutely correct. Expanding the sphere of influence would have some impacts. Ultimately, it comes back to those agreements to work on federal lands or get them to work.
2:53:08 on that land that's going to allow us to work that footprint outside of the local area. So even if our area for the district or the town was expanded, it's still ultimately federal land and getting those agreements is what's critical to being able to do that work. Sure. An observation. One is in the maps, it shows the UGB severity, but it doesn't show the whole town's municipal boundary.
2:53:35 I mean, the town's municipal boundary goes up into the lake space. Correct. How come, why can't we show that? So it's not looking at, there's basically three terms that are used in the fire service, FRA, SRA, and LRA. So federal responsibility area, state responsibility area, and then local responsibility area. And the interesting thing is, if you go outside in incorporated areas, we have the responsibility for what's called the LRA.
2:54:05 Local, private parcels within the town municipality. We don't actually have that on the federal land within the municipality. If you go outside of the incorporated areas, if you go into the county, so if you go to Crowley or Bridgeport, that's all SRA. They have responsibility for those local portions. So because the town is incorporated, we have a little more ownership of that local area and a little bit more power to influence it.
2:54:32 But it ends where private property ends. So while the town goes further and goes into federal land, we don't have the same powers once we leave local land, if that makes sense. Yeah, that makes perfect sense. But I think we all recognize we're in a position where a fire cannot start. A fire cannot start. And so if we have to go out to talk to people in the scenic loop to say there are fire restrictions in place, put your damn campfire out.
2:54:59 We have to be able to somehow figure out a way to do that and do that effectively. So that's, yeah. Well, once again, I want to reiterate, if our forests around us, which is what you're talking about, have been properly maintained in the first place, probably wouldn't be in a super high fire zone. It's created by our abutment up to those forests. I agree with you completely. Okay.
2:55:26 But I think back to the matter at hand because I don't want us to go too far afield because the matter is that we need to adopt this fire hazard severity zone map. That is pretty much something we just have to do. So are there any other questions? If not, I would love to entertain public comment.
2:55:48 No comment online or in the room, so I would happily entertain a motion. I move that we waive the first reading and introduce by title only an ordinance adopting the state fire hazard severity zone maps for the town of Mammoth Lakes and finding that the ordinance is not subject to CEQA pursuant to CEQA guidelines 15378 because the activity is not considered to be a project. I'll second. Great. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Salzer.
2:56:16 Yes. Councilmember Truax. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice. Yes. Mayor Bubzer. Yes. Great. The motion carries and we will move on to considering an extension to the Lease to Locals Program and thank you so much Nolan and Mike and Alish for being here and we are going on to the Lease to Locals Program operated under contract with Placemate and the commitment of a maximum $30,000 in additional administrative fees.
2:56:47 Great. So this is a follow-up item from the previous council meeting where we had an update from Placemate on the Lease to Locals program on the progress thus far. So as originally discussed, the initial contract was for a one-year period, which will expire here on July 4th, as well as discussed administrative fees within that contract. Originally it was paid out at a rate of $7,500 per month.
2:57:17 For that initial 12-month period. As previously discussed, we have not quite seen the results we were hoping for. However, there is the prospect of some additional properties that are in the pipeline coming on board. And so there is a request to extend the contract. Initially, that meeting is discussed or considered at a reduced rate of $6,000 per month.
2:57:40 And the direction given that meeting was for Rob and I to continue to negotiate with placemates to attempt to get that administrative fee to align more with results on the program. Talking with placemates, we did arrive at an agreed upon administrative rate going forward for a do not exceed amount of $30,000. So I've broken down on a monthly basement. Monthly.
2:58:11 Amount, that would be roughly $5,000 per month. But then we did also arrive at an agreement to pay for a per property that's brought into the program. So that's a property that has a successful lease under the program. We would be paying at a rate of $1,667 per property, but they do not exceed amount of $30,000. That was arrived at.
2:58:39 Looking at the properties in the pipeline and the anticipated subsidies that would be paid out to come to that number, there would obviously be some flexibility if a lot of properties leased up at a lower amount and we did more properties, then that would be great for the program. However, the amount paid would still not exceed that $30,000.
2:59:00 So that's really kind of where we're at from the previous meeting to now. I know Isaac has a few slides he was hoping to share of just summarizing their work effort and where they're at. Great. Thanks, Nolan. Hi, Councilmembers. I, this is largely, I shared their own screen. Sorry about that. There we go. This is largely repetitive of what Nolan just went over.
2:59:35 As a reminder, I'm Isaac Lin, and I'm the Associate Market Director for Placemate. And here we go. So just to set a little bit of context, I'll go, I'll run through this quickly because Nolan just did an excellent job going over it as well. On June 4th, I presented to you and gave an overview of where the program was at and the progress that had been made in throughout the pilot year.
3:00:02 To this point, 11 properties entered lease to locals from August 2024 through June of 2025. In that time, we also have seen strong lead generation, which indicates that there's quite a bit of future interest in the program. But there's also been a slow uptake in actually joining the program of the property owners that have expressed interest. And what was...
3:00:28 Asked for counsel to discuss was adding six months to the program by extending Placemate's contract at $6,000 a month or a total contract fee of $36,000, right, six months at $6,000 per month to allow for those interested property owners to move forward.
3:00:47 And what we heard from Council was a bit of a mixed bag, right? There was feedback that Lease to Locals uniquely serves the missing middle population. It serves a population of renters that no other housing program in the town is reaching. And we also heard that the sentiment that successful programs sometimes require additional time to build awareness and momentum to become successful.
3:01:15 That resonated with some council members. And then on the flip side, we heard that, you know, the total incentive spend of $122,500 compared to the administrative costs of just under $100,000, $97,500, was too high. And so staff directed
3:01:39 Council directed staff to negotiate with us on our admin fee, and there was one specific request for a performance-based proposal. So before I get into the specifics of that proposal, I just wanted to provide a bit of a pipeline snapshot to set a little bit of additional context for this discussion. Since that June 4th meeting, we've had eight new owners express interest in the program. So the pipeline is continuing to grow.
3:02:10 The future interest stage of the deals that we're working with is at 19. Nine of those owners are interested in starting leases this summer, and 10 of those owners are interested in starting leases in the fall, sometime between September and January. We also have four property owners that are actively looking for tenants, so they're closer to participating in the program. They're trying to find tenants and they're working on moving forward.
3:02:39 And then one property owner that has placed tenants and is nearly done with their application, and we expect that property to be submitted in the next couple of days. So in the total pipeline, there's 24 properties and a potential for just over $300,000 in additional grants. You know, we don't expect all of these properties to move forward, and some properties will fall out and move into not interested.
3:03:05 But what we're seeing with those new properties that are coming in is that they're refilling the funnel. And so we do still think that there is high potential for quite a few additional properties to be added to the participation in the program. So a bit of background to the proposal that has come before you tonight. There's just under $200,000 in funding that remains for incentives.
3:03:36 The average incentive per property that is participating in the program is a little bit over $11,000. So that means with the remaining incentive budget available, there's about enough money for an estimated 18 properties to move forward. And in our discussions with staff, we agreed to move our contract fee from $36,000 down to $30,000.
3:04:02 And to move to a performance-based contract, both to control admin costs and tie admin compensation to actual performance of the program. So the updated proposal that is before you tonight is a term that runs for the last six months of the year from July through December of 2025.
3:04:28 And we're proposing that place may be compensated at a rate of $1,667 per property that enters the Lease to Locals program. Again, there's about enough budget for 18 properties if that average incentive rate per property holds. So with a do not exceed budget of $30,000, we're proposing that each property that we submit be worth about $1,600, a little bit over $1,600.
3:04:57 And again, this is that performance-based incentive structure. And so if this is approved tonight, we'll come back with staff in the fall and we'll update you on program results and potentially bring an additional recommendation from that point, depending on how the next few months go. So with that, I'll stop sharing my screen and I'm here to answer questions along with staff. Thank you.
3:05:26 Nolan, did you have anything to add or should I take questions? No, no. Questions? Just one. So at that June 4th meeting we were told there was actually 12 units that had been rented. That shows 11. Is it 11 or 12? Oh, maybe 12. That could be a typo on my end. I thought June 4th we were told it was 11. No, it was modified to say 12, I believe. Well, it probably happened in that ensuing time period. Bill, any questions?
3:05:57 Maybe this has already been answered, so we're talking about this being our only model for the missing middle that we're renting to. Can you tell me, for the average two-bedroom unit that you are renting out, what is the renter actually paying in rent? Sure, let me pull up our tracker and I can tell you what the average rental rate for property is in one moment.
3:06:27 So we have 11, just to touch on the previous question, we have 11 properties that have been approved for incentive payments, and I believe they have a 12 that they did, they'll be submitting here shortly for payment. Thanks. And to respond to that question, I don't have the cost per unit readily available, but our average rent per property is just over $2,700 per property. Thank you. But we put in a, like it was $2,500 for a two-bedroom.
3:06:59 Was the cap, like there are caps for different bedroom sizes, right? That's correct. Okay. Any questions, Council Member Wentworth? Well, just a question, Rob, to you and the staff. Based on the discussion of the last council meeting, I'm assuming that you guys had a thorough and productive conversation. I was very happy with the outcome of it. I think they listened to exactly what we...
3:07:29 Meaning you guys indicated you needed, with the exception, I think, of there was some conversation around expansion of the program, which is, I don't know that that's really a budget discussion. That's more of the parameters in which we want to engage the program, which can be modified, and that was with regard to potential RV sites that I think Congress, or Congressman, could give you a promotion too.
3:07:56 Councilmember Truax brought up at that time, but with regard to the financial components, I was very excited with the outcome of the negotiation, so. Good, thank you. Mayor Pro Tem Rice. I don't have any questions, but thank you very much for bringing this back. I don't have any questions, so with that, I will take public comment. Is there anyone online, Jamie? Okay, then.
3:08:28 We can move on to deliberations. So who would like to make any comments first? I can go first. I was very pleased to see that you took the comments into a performance-based payment. So thank you for doing that. I think this seems very reasonable. Go ahead. I agree. I appreciate that in that way I am torn because this is a program to
3:09:01 Reach a certain audience that we don't really have enough program for, but I'm really constrained with how much it's costing us, and it's just, it's a mixed bag to me. I'm probably not going to be in favor of it, but I don't want to make a big state of that because I think we need also a program, so it's kind of a mixed bag for me on this one. I think that with this payment structure, it does get closer to, you know, it was $105,000 in administrative fees for $320,000, so it will be...
3:09:30 $135,000 for $320,000. That's great. It's better. I think it's much better than what it was. Any comments, Mayor? Look at you. Councilmember? There you go. Councilmember Sauser? You know, I've had problems with this program from the beginning, so I'm not sure that it's something that I can still support. I acknowledge our need for housing.
3:10:01 I just don't, at this point, think this is the way to go. I think that it would be interesting, like I guess I feel like I would like a little more data as to whether or not when the lease terms are up, if tenants stay in the properties or if they are evicted and it goes back to short-term rentals. So to me, the administrative fees are higher than I would like to pay, but I think if we were able to convert...
3:10:31 You know, for $11,000, if we're able to convert a short-term rental into a long-term rental for more than a year, for two years or three years, to me, that seems reasonable. And so I think that extending it for six months so that we have that data to see, and if none of them stay as long-term rentals, I'm right there with you, Bill, that I would not be in favor of continuing it any further.
3:10:55 But, you know, if we're able for $11,000 to get a long-term rental for somebody for multiple years, that sounds very reasonable to me. If it lasts for multiple years, I would agree with you. But the way the program is laid out, and I don't know how many, you know, to try to remember all the facts and figures I should is impossible. How many of these are seasonal, which puts us in the business of our employees losing their housing halfway through a year with no way to pick that up.
3:11:25 Puts people on the street when they're in the middle of a job. Just the way the whole thing works is, at this point, I'm not sure I can support it. If I may, I can jump in with a little bit of that data, if that's helpful. That would be helpful. We're at eight long-term leases, so eight 12-month leases and three seasonal. And I know we haven't seen the retention data at this point because of where we're at in when leases have begun.
3:11:55 In the Manif Lakes Program, and I touched on this when I last presented to Council, but the retention data that we see in other markets ranges from 50 to 70% typically, and that retention data gets at the number of property owners that report that they are continuing to long-term rent after the first year. So we do have many other programs that we've administered, and we typically see that really
3:12:25 Surprisingly high retention data where property owners decide to make the leap to start long-term renting and then they have a positive experience and they continue doing so. Councilmember Wentworth, anything to add? I don't. I'm aligning myself with Mayor Pro Tem, Rice's analysis. And Bill, I hear what you're saying. If this is just a puppy mill where we're just putting Band-Aids on something.
3:12:51 Okay, that's what it is. But I think what we should do is be thinking, let's see what comes out of this. But we need to focus on what is a solution. If this one's not working, okay, how do we get to that missing middle piece? But I think an extension for me seems reasonable at this point. And I would just continue to dissent in that
3:13:17 I think that this is one of the most efficient cost-wise programs we're offering right now because for $11,000 once we give it a couple of years but I think for us to decide about a program that hasn't even seen a full year seems short-sighted and if indeed we can get to a steady state this is the most efficient way we have to put roofs over people's heads because I can't think of anything else.
3:13:46 A, that we even can offer the missing middle, and B, for those things we can offer the select few who make over 150% of AMI, it's usually costing us a couple hundred thousand dollars to make those roofs available to people. So I still am just confused why there's so much pushback. And again, I don't think we could administer a program like this ourselves as a town for it.
3:14:14 Anywhere near the amount. So with that, I'm in strong support of continuing and making sure that we are doing everything we can as we often talk about the importance of housing on this dais to help the missing middle. So with that, I would. Would you consider a motion? I would absolutely. Okay, I would recommend. Oh, sorry. One thing just to clarify on the recommended motion from the action sheet, it says consider an amendment. So the motion would be to.
3:14:42 Recommended motion would be to approve an amendment. Okay. Thank you for the clarification. Sure. So I would move that the council approve an amendment to the placemate contract to extend the operating term of the lease to locals program to December 31st, 2025, and to commit a maximum of $30,000 in additional administrative fees, which will be paid out on a performance-based structure of $1,667 per property that enters the lease to locals program during the extended term.
3:15:12 I'll second. Great. With that, we have a motion and a second. Any further discussion, not seeing any? I will, I mean, Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? No. Councilmember Truax? No. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. All right. And with that, we are on to councilmember reports. Who would like to go first? I'll go first.
3:15:42 Mayor Boebser, is that okay? Oh, please. I was nodding. I was on an auditory orientation. June 7th, with Councilmember Sauser and Mayor Boebser, we all attended the June 7 ribbon cutting for the Sharp Trailhead. Very exciting day. Persistence shows rewards and having community buy-in and a good collaborative effort makes a difference. June 11th, as I mentioned earlier, I attended a
3:16:14 Meeting with the California Natural Resources Agency Leadership Recreation Focused Meeting in Sacramento. As I mentioned, the efforts in Mammoth Lakes are drawing attention from state leadership, which is encouraging and nice to hear. June 12th at 13, I was over on the west side, not in my council capacity, but attending the governing council of the Sierra Jobs First Collaborative. A lot of very interesting things coming out of that. What's emerging is probably
3:16:42 The opportunity for future roles of the SCOG and the Motherlode Job Training Center to deal with economic development opportunities, but also real recognition that not everything is going to work. I mean, we're separated by a mountain range, we're connected by a mountain range, but we can't get back and forth for six or eight months out of the year. Also, some interesting information that the counties on the west side are cutting budgets. I haven't heard that happening around here yet. Rob, we talked about that, but the four counties on the west side
3:17:12 10, 15% across the board, budget cuts, not sure why that is. They're laying off all their economic development staff. There's no, they're all leaving government. So any economic development opportunities are going to be outside of government, which is kind of interesting. I want to mention that the MOT board meeting today was canceled. It was canceled a couple of days ago. I'll work with Chair Foster and John Urdi on this, but
3:17:36 Given our schedule and their schedule, I will not be able to give a report out until August. And I don't, again, you know, our reliance on what's happening with tourism, what's going, that's not an ideal situation. So I'll work with Pat Foster and John Urdi to get updates back to all of us. And Rob, you got whatever the TOT numbers you're getting out of them so we can be informed as to what's happening. It's kind of an unfortunate scheduling thing that popped up.
3:18:00 Also, Nolan, you may be aware that the Governor's Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation is just, is kicking off a comprehensive update of the state's general plan, specific plan, tribal consultation guidelines. I'm sure you know about that, but that's, that will be interesting. That's it, thank you. Well, I attended Kitapalooza with my children. Nice. At Mammoth Creek Park. And fun was had by all. So that was a good event. And I'm enjoying the summer.
3:18:31 Excellent. And that's it. Beautiful. Great. Would you like to go next? I attended the LAFCO meeting this week. We've been working a response back to the grand jury report to reiterate what the LAFCO is required to do and what it's not required to do and making sure that everybody's in alignment. We also spent time reviewing some of the spheres of influence that exist in some of the existing districts to see if they need to be updated.
3:18:58 So, I attended my daughter's graduation, but as part of the pre-graduation, and it was interesting, there's an awards night, and I don't know if everybody's aware that, I don't know what the total number was, but I think about $250,000 was issued to students leaving Mammoth High School, and it was awarded to them for a future education. So, you know, to me, that's a great support by the community and what they do and how they support the next.
3:19:22 Thank you so much. Thank you.
3:19:50 Answer the phone call, help you show up, figure out what you needed, and work your way through it. I was going to pick up a little bit because part of public comment, though, they're trying to change a quart to be pickleball for one area, and the local residents in one area complained that it's 80 decibels whenever you hit the pickleball, so they don't want it to pickleball close to them because it's too loud. So, you know, for all the things that we challenge with, I thought I'd have a smile that if that's all we have to deal with in this town, we're doing great.
3:20:19 Attended a session where we honored Al Davis for what he did for this community and the benefits that he did over the years, both in participation with many different things in this community. And again, I salute Al and I hope in every world he's doing much better and thank him for all he did in this town. Went down to the opening for the public swim at Woodmore Pool.
3:20:45 Water looked nice and warm. I did not go in. I did watch other people swim. They had a good time. So it was all good. And then the last one, I don't know how to express it, but there's issues where concern that ice was in this community, and it caused a pretty big turmoil. I know this is going to happen, but I'm trying to figure out how we can better communicate within the town and try to verify when possible because it just...
3:21:15 It creates a lot of tension and tension we don't need in this town and just trying to figure out how we can handle those and maybe there is no better solution, but it's just tough. It's not a good thing. That's it. Thank you. Bill? You know, unfortunately, and I have to apologize due to being ill, I missed a trails committee meeting and the LTC meeting. So someone else would have to give reports on this. Okay.
3:21:47 And I don't think there is anybody to, is there anything that was in the LTC, Rob, that was necessary? Because I can't report on it either, so. No, I don't think there wasn't anything of reportable action on that for tonight. Okay, great. So I would just add to the LAFCO meeting.
3:22:15 That Councilmember Truax talked about. You know, the grand jury finding was that some of the spheres of influence and different entities covered by LAFCO were not reviewed in a timely manner. There's some question about that because the law doesn't seem to require a schedule. But I think we had a robust discussion about the fact that some of the
3:22:45 Entities under LAFCO haven't been looked at for a long, long time. So I think the intention now is to go back and, you know, Chair Cage and Vice Chair McFarland seem to have good agreement with the committee that we'll be meeting more often until those are a little bit caught up. So I'm the alternate, but because it's during the day, I'll make myself available so that we can get caught up.
3:23:15 And then, let's see, I attended the first Trashy Thursday. I highly recommend it. It is really fun to be outside. And, you know, it's fun to see what we find. I found a car part, a big old piece of metal that I dragged out because we were out at a shady rest. That was great fun. Oh, and a bullet. I found a bullet that was intact. It had not been fired. I don't know why that was out there. So anyway, it's fun. You get to see what you find.
3:23:42 I think I won. I think those were the two coolest things, I'm just saying. I attended at Snarl. I don't know how many people go to the lectures at Snarl throughout the month. It's usually the month of May, but it was bookended with, should we reintroduce grizzlies in the Sierra, the first lecture, and then the last one was about black bears. And it was the same naturalist from CDFW, a bear expert, who talked about
3:24:12 And then, last but not least,
3:24:41 I was lucky enough to attend Eastern Sierra Pride up at Canyon Lodge and I got to welcome all the folks who had come to join us and it was and then I stayed for the evening event and also went back on Sunday to do the same thing with the family friendly drag show which was really cute. It was just you know kids dancing and the gratitude by the folks from Eastern Sierra Pride and all the visitors was
3:25:10 Palpable. There was just so much joy and it was just a lovely, lovely evening and I met folks from as far away as Sacramento and LA and San Francisco who had just heard that Eastern Sierra Pride is super fun and that Mammoth is a great place and so I think our town was well represented and I'm really glad we did that. So thank you to the Mountain for making that possible. I think that was great. And with that we can adjourn.
3:25:39 Although we are going to adjourn into closed session. So this is item 10.1, pursuant to government code section 54957, we are having a conference with labor negotiators and the council will meet with its representatives, Town Manager Rob Patterson, Community and Economic Development Director Nolan Bobroff, and Human Resources Manager Amanda Pelham. And this will be about
3:26:06 The following employee organizations, the Mammoth Lakes Police Officers Association and the Mammoth Lakes Supervisory Association. And with that, thank you all. Have a good evening. It is, but that's only because it's well into summer.