Town Council
at 15:00 · recording 5 hr 35 min
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
8 findings- The Town adopted the Clearwater Specific Plan in January 2009 for a resort development on Old Mammoth Road Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- In December 2021 the Council approved DZA 21-001, setting standards for a smaller 'Amended Phase One' project Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- The approved Amended Phase One project began construction in April 2022 and was substantially completed in April 2025, with some landscaping bonded Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- DZA 24-001 adds condominium hotel uses to the Amended Phase One plan; the Council voted 4-0 to introduce the ordinance on March 19, 2025 Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- Tentative Tract Map 24-003 and Use Permit 24-004 were approved in March 2025; a final map application was filed in August 2025 Clearwater Specific Plan (Old Mammoth Road)
- An amended Phase One CSP for an Old Mammoth Road hotel site proposes 10 single-story resort cabins and 20 Villa units Downtown and Main Street
- Final Budget FY26-27 lists a $18,970,000 total budget for the MACC, compared with $16,800,000 in FY25-26 Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center (MACC) (CIP GF9)
- Staff recommended awarding the MACC construction contract to Spiess Construction at $15,862,000; General Fund / Measure U funding was listed at $5,820,000 Measure R and Measure U
Transcript
699 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:57 Hello, everyone. If you could take your seats, please. Come to the Town of Mammoth Lakes Council meeting. It's a regular meeting for Wednesday, March 19th, and we are starting at, looks like, 4 o'clock straight up. And so, Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Present. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Here. Mayor Bubzer? Here. Thank you very much. So, I would like...
4:38 I didn't warn them, but Jeff Posey, welcome to our meeting. Would you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? All you have to say is begin. We got you. Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
5:08 He's my neighbor. Uh-oh, I'm never going to get my burn plowed out again, am I? Okay, so I would like to start with public comments. Would anyone from the public wishing to address us on any matters not otherwise on the agenda like to approach the podium?
5:35 Good evening, Madam Mayor, Council, members of the public, Betsy Truax, Vice President of Community Engagement for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just wanted to mention a couple of things. Our next community coffee is next Thursday, March 27th at 8.30 a.m. And I'm very excited that State Assemblyman David Tangipa will be joining us. He was just elected in November as our District 8 representative.
5:59 And he has been working on legislation around wildfire mitigation, fire insurance, and affordable housing. So really excited working with his staff to have him come via Zoom to chat with some of his east side constituents. So please tune in for that. You can find all the Zoom link and all the information about that community coffee at visitmammoth.com forward slash community.
6:22 And the next community skate night will be the last one of the season before the ice goes out. And that will be on Wednesday, April 2nd. We're actually going to start that at 6 o'clock. And so we'll have complimentary ice skating, ice skate rentals, and hot chocolate, courtesy of Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Really have enjoyed that program, getting to speak to some residents over this ice season.
6:45 Finally, as you know, winter air service still in full swing, and we do have local discounts available at that visitmammoth.com slash flylocal link.
6:56 And I also wanted to mention that summer air service is available to book for United. We'll soon have the schedule up for advanced airlines as well. And the United service is actually extending through the first weekend of October. You can find all the details on that link. But we're really excited with our endurance season after Labor Day to be able to continue to offer that service four days a week. So that's it. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else who would like to make public comment? Mr. Posey.
7:28 Madam Mayor, neighbor, council members, Jeff Posey. First, I want to pump your tires for the rink. I think it's awesome. You guys haven't seen me in a long time since I was up here complaining about not having a rink, but the new facility is great. It's kind of kicking my butt, but it's really good. I hear rumors that it might go to NHL instead of Olympic, which is kind of cool for us elder statesmen already where you are.
7:54 That would be great. It would also open up more opportunities for higher-end hockey teams to come here because most teams won't play on an Olympic versus NHL. Also, since we built the facility, I would like to see it completed on the inside with all the plans that Stu and his staff and Betsy have planned for years. It would be nice to have a little warm area, even though it is a nice rink, I get it, but a nice warm area to put your skates on and whatnot and go out to the surface would be cool.
8:21 So if that ever comes up on someone's grand plan, I support that as well. And the main reason I'm here is because of the traffic in and out of there. The Tesla cars, they drive way too fast. They're very quiet. And it's a recreation facility with a lot of kids. And in the summer, it's going to be probably even busier with the park and all the kids running around between cars. They don't really think. We do live in a small town, and no one really thinks about traffic.
8:51 He's going to get hurt, dare I say killed, but we also had one of our hockey guys came out one night and he almost got hit and said something to the Tesla guy and he got out and pumped his eyes shut and he didn't fill out a police report because it's kind of embarrassing and he's not going to do it. But traffic just drives way too fast. I don't know what you're going to do to slow people down and I will say I have been guilty of it being late for a game. I've come in there a little hot.
9:19 So if there's something that can be done just to slow the cars down and keep the kids safe, that'd be great. Thank you very much. Great job, Uncle Greg. Thank you so much. All right. Any other? Oh, here we are. Kim. Hello, Council. Kim Anaclario, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Quick updates for you. Yesterday we had a joint meeting with the Parks and Recreation Commission to discuss strategic priorities and how MLR can help implement these.
9:51 The MLR Board also voted to bring forward some recommendations to you for expenditures of Measure R and U, some Measure U programming grants to our local organizations, and Measure R funds for a climbing boulder at Mammoth Creek Park, and some new equipment to enhance the programming at the CRC. So yeah, next couple weeks those will be brought forward to you I imagine.
10:20 Last but not least, we finished the 23-24 Annual Report, so I wanted to share that with you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Yes. I don't have a dog. Is there anyone else who would like to make public comment? Here she comes.
10:49 Hi, Brianna Goyko, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. We have a lot going on at the Chamber, a lot of changes and programs and some things I'll mention in a couple weeks. But the main thing I wanted to highlight tonight is that we just announced our Grand Marshals for this year's parade. We'll be Crispin Chetler and Kemi Fasani, so we're so excited that they have accepted this opportunity to honor them, to bring in all our floats for this year's Fourth of July parade.
11:15 Which is on Friday, July 4th at 11 a.m. And then to build on these being our grand marshals this year, our theme will center around for all of our floats and the theme for the parade will center around arts and nature, very much looping in the passions of both Kimmy and Chris. So very excited to announce that to the community. There will be a press release to follow and some information in the papers coming soon. Thank you. Thank you. Bruce Woodward.
11:50 I'm a retired architect, long-time resident. I have two things. One is I learned years ago that Christmas decorations shouldn't stay up too long. I think it's really a shame that the town's entry monuments still have Christmas decorations on them. I think it really doesn't show well for the town of Mammoth Lakes to be that sort of sloppy about something as grand as those.
12:21 Those monuments and welcome signs. And I'd like to just suggest that town council get town staff to do a better job of taking care of those. For a while, a year and a half, the north side lantern on the top was the glass. It's not really glass, it's plastic. It was knocked out of place, and yet nobody fixed it.
12:50 It took me quite a while to get somebody from the town to fix it. So that's the first thing, or first two things, I guess. The other is the, and it's going to come up, I guess, later in this meeting, the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center. The plans that are on the town's website are the plans that I produced. And that project died back in 2020. And yet,
13:20 There's another proposal, I guess, or something out there, but it seems as if this project that's been dead for five years now should be in the archive of Boulder. I've asked to have that done. It hasn't been done. It hasn't been moved. I think it's deceitful that it's still posted as a current project on the town's website.
13:46 And that needs to get fixed. And I think there's probably other things there that should be fixed, too. I think that should be looked into and dealt with. All right. That's it. Thank you very much. Thank you. Jamie, is there anyone online who wants to make public comment? No. Is there anyone else in the room who wants to make public comment? All right. Then with that, we will proceed.
14:18 Rob, are there any additions to the agenda? Yes, Mayor Bobser. There is one urgency item that we are seeking to add. It's a closed session item for this evening. I'll have Andy read off some of the parameters for this closed session. Thank you, Rob. So as the council is aware, the Brown Act generally requires you to only take action on things that are on the published agenda, but it does allow you to add items to the agenda if there's a need to take immediate action on those items and if the need to take action came to your attention after the agenda was published.
14:48 And you can then, with a four-fifths vote, make a finding that those conditions exist, and you can add something to the agenda. Tonight, I would like to suggest to you that there is a need to take immediate action on a piece of potential litigation, and it did come to our attention after the agenda was published. The Brown Act requires that we explain a little bit about what the potential litigation is, and in this case, it is a letter that Town received from an attorney representing
15:18 The children of the man who died in the police shooting. The letter does threaten litigation against the town. So I think that we do need to have a closed session to discuss that item of potential litigation. And as I said, you can add that to the agenda with a four-fifths vote. Thank you. Do we have a motion? I move that we add that to the agenda. I'll second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Jamie, will you please call the roll?
15:44 Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. Thank you. And again, that will be a closed session discussion occurring after the open session tonight. Thank you. All right. Moving into item six, we have some introductions. So first, we'll introduce our new finance director, Megan Chapman. So I just want to start off by I can't tell you how excited I am to have...
16:23 I have been doing this dual role for town manager and finance director for more than a year now. And Megan was a certainly well-qualified candidate. We did two recruitments, and she applied for her on the second recruitment, I think, because you were too busy doing your other job in the first recruitment. That makes a lot of sense. So Megan has just started Monday, so she's been here.
16:50 Very short amount of time, but she does bring with her 10 years of municipal experience working for Mono County as well as prior background in accounting, local nonprofits. And the finance department, really a wonderful department. They are already, you know, gelling. They probably love the fact that they have someone right there that they can get work from or get help from instead of somebody who's so busy and so far away.
17:15 But loves the energy, loves the synergy of that group, and she's really a tremendous fit for at least the first three days. So welcome, Megan. I think she's got a few things to say as well. Thank you. Thank you, Rob. It's an honor to serve the town as the finance director. I'm very excited for my new role here, and I'm looking forward to facilitating and moving things forward. My team is great. I've got a few here today, and one that is going to be introduced.
17:43 So I just wanted to say thank you and we look forward to doing great things. Thank you. Welcome. Who's doing it? All right. All right. Absolutely. So the next introduction is Marcy Castro and for a revenue specialist position. As you know, we've got a really good team in the revenue specialist world that does all of our opening of businesses and collection of TOT and interaction with businesses and so forth.
18:31 And Marcy comes to us from previously at the Chamber, so real good connection with those businesses is a nice aspect of that. So Marcy is a dedicated member of Mammoth Lakes Community, committed to public and service education and workforce development. Originally from Compton, California, she moved to Mammoth Lakes in April of 2016. So your first winner was 2016-17 like mine. That was bad.
18:57 She's married, a mother of four, and a grandmother of two. Very exciting. Marcy began her career in Northrop Grumman as an electrical technician. After starting a family, she transitioned through education at Los Angeles Unified School District and later moved to Mammoth Lakes to work for the Mammoth Unified School District. You're going to say something here. As a Mammoth Unified School District board member, she advocates for students and family supporting initiatives that enhance education and community engagement.
19:26 Previously as member manager for Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce, Marcy played a key role in supporting Latino-owned businesses, promoting workforce development and connecting businesses with valuable resources. She worked to strengthen the local economy by creating opportunities for entrepreneurs, job seekers and young professionals exploring careers in Mammoth Lakes. With a strong background in bilingual communications and community engagement, Marcy remains dedicated to helping the community grow and thrive.
19:54 I will attest, I went to the Chamber's Hispanic evening, and it was really well done. You were mainly doing the communication, and Lapita was there presenting on behalf of the town, all of our key areas, but such an important outreach to that. So, really grateful to have Marcy on the team, and I think, Megan, do you have something to add? Or, Marcy, you guys can...
20:18 I just want to, Marcy started the same day I did, which was this last Monday, and what I've seen is fantastic by way of the training that's going on, the retention from Marcy, and so I just wanted to take an opportunity to say what a great job I see being done at the front counter, and what a great asset Marcy is for the town already.
20:39 And thank you for the opportunity. I know that I know most of the people. I appreciate working with the town. Not only am I part of the community, I have four kids, so we have connection with a lot of the parents, so I'm definitely here to serve. Thank you.
21:12 Moving along to item seven, reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Are any of these going to be, they are, there's one live presentation, correct? Or two? 7.1 is going to be a discussion and 7.2 as well. Okay, great. Thank you. That's your update. There's a question. I'll go through that. There's a lot of moving parts to today, so we've got a little coordination to do. I understand. So typically the Office of Outer Recreation update is
21:46 A written update only, but I think there were some questions with regard to the Sharps Trails first item and wanting to talk, you know, just a little bit about that item in particular about capacity and whether that we think we can actually hit these initiatives and as well as the funding aspect in that. Lawson, if you want to add a little bit of components on that. Yes, Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation.
22:14 I believe there were some questions regarding the budget as well that we have from SNC related to our grant. Again, whenever I bring this up, always big shout out to Kim and MLR as it relates to that. But currently we have 183,000 left of those planning dollars. Right now, just to give you an idea of what the project is going to look like moving forward.
22:37 It will be divided into two parts based on the level of NEPA that will be required to move these forward. Currently, about 12 or 13 miles of the trails are about to be entering public comment, which is one of the final stages related to the NEPA process and is subsequent to having a decision. Those 12 miles of trails are primarily the trails
23:06 From roughly Sherwin Creek Campground, more or less over to Snow Creek. Other sections of the trails, roughly eight miles of trail, will need to go through further consultation with both Fish and Wildlife Service for Whitebark Pine, as well as archaeological resources. We need to...
23:28 Dig some test pits, things like that, identify archaeological resources, and potentially mitigate. So we felt with our forest partners that the best course of action to move forward was to more or less divide up the project into sections that we do believe, pending public comment, that we will be able to implement next summer. That would be the roughly-
23:54 That would be the roughly 12 to 13 miles, kind of between Sherwin Creek Campground and Snow Creek, with the final, let's say, roughly eight miles that will need to go through more environmental consultation. And we will continue to work through that process. And again, the $183,000 that we have left in those planning dollars will help facilitate that. Kimberly Cook.
24:24 I did want to provide one more update. We did speak last time as well that the federal lands were required to provide information on the 13th regarding more rifts, reduction in force. I reached out to the forest yesterday. There is still no word on the results of that. So as soon as I know what will be occurring in that space, I will let all of you know. Okay, great. So first of all,
24:53 Nope, all good. Any questions? Yeah, any questions on this item? Yeah, I have questions. So is the NEPA team, as far as you know, with the Inyo still intact? Yes, they are down a wildlife biologist, but there are...
25:13 Not wildlife concerns for the section we are going to move forward currently. So yes, the ID team, the interdisciplinary team is still intact. In my conversations with the Union National Forest, they are still committed to moving this project forward with us. And district Ranger Wong would be making the decision, he'd be signing the decision memo. He would be the one deciding, pardon me, he would be the one signing the decision memo. Yes, that is correct.
25:42 Next summer, are you talking about this summer for construction? Sorry, I apologize for that. Yes, this coming summer. This coming summer. Yeah, we're hoping to have a decision in the next few months. And once that decision is there, that will give us the ability to do work on the ground. Obviously, assuming all positive things out of the public comment process. Okay, would it be possible to provide the various trail segments by their IDs?
26:11 Yep. Which will track back to the sharp documents so we know which ones are being implemented and which ones are going on for further review. That would be helpful. Yes, not a problem at all. I do believe Trails Program Manager Andrew Mulford already has that information, so I will be sure to provide that to all of you. And so the public comment, this is a NEPA process, this will be coming, the notification will be coming from the Forest Service. That is correct, yes, and it will be coming, yes. We're not quite there yet.
26:40 We're in some kind of preliminary outreach, but yes, that will be coming sooner rather than later. Okay, and there was a Mammoth Trails meeting, I think, that was scheduled around that or? Yes, which had to be tentatively postponed, but we will reboot that when we know when an appropriate time to have that will be. Good, so it'll be good community outreach, good community engagement? Correct, I agree completely. Okay, great, thank you. Any other questions? And were you lost in just going over those items or do you have more?
27:09 I think that was the only one that there was questions that I received in our one-to-ones. Okay, great. So I don't believe there's anything else that we wanted to cover. I just want to make sure that no questions from this side of the dais bill. No questions. No, I'm good. Thank you. And I will take public comment then if there's any. Yeah, I just was going to add one more component to this. Okay. So as you'll see later in the agenda, we're going to talk a little bit about staff updates for this particular department.
27:36 I think that's going to allow for sort of a bifurcation of duties a little bit more. And so on the updates, we'll look to modify this in such a way that it has those compartmentalized sections more highlighted on the work plans that are there because it's a very diverse group of work plans that we have. And this is a lot of focus on just the current stuff that we have going on. And we'll expect more in that in the future. So we'll kind of push into that space a little bit more. But Lawson and I can handle that for next time.
28:04 Okay, thank you. Are there any other comments from the public? No? Okay, great. If I could. Sure. Just, Rob, I appreciate you making the point about that because it is in a future agenda item that there's going to be, I guess, maybe some reorganization in the department. But I think for the council, for the public, it's going to be very important to start breaking.
28:29 This report into the sections by what plan is authorizing the work, what the funding sources are, because part of our council priorities, wildlife, wildfires, a lot of things, it's very good, important work is happening in, but in order for us and the public to keep track of everything that's going on, as you mentioned, Rob, I think I'd certainly fully support that, so thank you. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you. Stu, did you have a report? Yes, thank you. Appreciate that.
29:01 Council, staff, any members of the community, summer is right around the corner, right? March 31st, officially, is our summer recreation expo. So in advance of the summer recreation expo, I know you're all, our families are out there paying attention. So we've had some ads running, we've got some information out there about how it's going to kind of roll this year for our summer camp registration. So again, it's in person.
29:28 Beginning March 31st, that's Monday, at the Community Recreation Centre from 4 to 7. So our approach this year is to kind of pre-register to register, right? So kind of what we're calling pick a time, skip the line, which is kind of our program this year. So you're going to actually go into DaySmart, register for your appointment, and we'll have staff available. You'll have kind of a 15-minute window to kind of go through your one.
29:57 Camp registration per family. That's how that's going to go on that first night. Per child or per family? Per child, but you only need to make one reservation per family. Thank you. We almost scripted that. That's good. So that's how that's going to go on that Monday. So you get one camp registration. Only one family needs to make that registration. And then for the remainder of that week, you can come along and make your remainder of those registrations for that one camp. Beginning on that Monday, April 7th,
30:28 That's when we open up our full camp registration online. So that's when everybody needs to be on their computers at 9 o'clock in the morning ready to go. And then they'll have a maximum of two additional camps to sign up for. So each child has a total of three camps they can participate in. And really the goal there is just to kind of make it as equitable and as fair as possible just based on the demand of our camps because they do sell out really quickly.
30:58 Moving forward this year. Information again will come out in the paper on the 28th or the 27th, whatever that weekend is. So do look for that in the sheet. Again, it's online on our website and there's flyers in the back of the room. For those people virtually, please visit our website and look on recreation this week. That is all I had. Hopefully that's helpful for everybody. Any questions? Questions? We'll see you all there. Thank you. Okay. No other.
31:28 Thank you. No, I was just looking to see if anyone had a question. And with that, if there's no one else, then I think Rob, we will move on to the Wildfire Team program update. Hello again. Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. Give me a moment to share my screen. Okay.
32:09 Good evening. Tonight I would like to have a discussion with you all regarding the newly created Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Team that we are standing up here with Town of Mammoth Lakes and numerous initial partners. Those would be Mammoth Lakes Fire Department, the Whitebark Institute, Mammoth Disposal, and the Mammoth Community Water District. Now with that said...
32:33 We see a very large space moving forward for adding additional partners to this. Of course, entities like the Forest Service, Cal Fire, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and others. But these are the initial group that we are working with to establish what we are calling the Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Team. Now, you may be wondering why we are standing up the Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Team, and I think that's multifaceted. Obviously, we've all seen
33:01 What happened down in L.A.? I think we all understand based on the science of wildfire the need to address
33:08 Not only the adjacent wildland, but also individual parcels within the town of Mammoth Lakes. We do all know the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project going on around the town of Mammoth Lakes, and the next logical step to ensuring resiliency of this community is to be working within the town. So that is what we are attempting to do.
33:32 Through the Mammoth Lakes Wildfire Team, with goals and objectives being parcel level defensible space evaluations, parcel level on the ground work, supporting further resiliency of this community through the building code, support in the software realm, public outreach, and of course funding opportunities for this program as a whole. Again,
33:58 We feel this parcel level work is obviously essential to hardening the community of Mammoth Lakes, working in collaboration with the ESCCRP, which will be handling a lot of the wildland urban interface outside of town. Firstly, our goal and objective here as it relates to this parcel level defensible space evaluations is to evaluate every single parcel within the town of Mammoth Lakes in the next two to three years. What does that mean? That means
34:28 Looking from the street, unless we are invited onto people's properties, to see how people can further harden their homes and their yards to create more defensible space and resiliency. And we want to do this in mass. Obviously, if...
34:48 If an individual, for instance, were to do a great job kind of hardening their yard, but their neighbors around them did not, those efforts may be in vain. But in order to do that, we need to figure out what this all looks like, evaluate these individual parcels, and establish what can be done at these individual parcels. There are roughly 13,000 of those here in town. We hope to evaluate those within the next two.
35:17 Two to three years utilizing the newly formed wildland unit within Mammoth Lakes Fire Department. So obviously that will be a process that will take some time and we will begin those evaluations with the highest risk areas in town highlighted in the community wildfire protection plan, which we will talk about here briefly. We also want to provide those homeowners after these evaluations.
35:42 With definitive steps they can take to harden their properties. What can you do to make the situation better on your particular property? And we want to utilize that data collected to help populate some of the software programs that we are looking at, which we will talk about later. So taking a look at this map, I just wanted to provide this. This kind of highlights the hazard zones within the CWPP and most likely where we would start.
36:13 with our evaluation process. Starting with those areas of greatest concern, as you can imagine, we've talked about this a lot, fires coming in from the lakes basin, coming down Old Mammoth, so many of the areas we would start with would be in that area. The evaluation process itself, again, from the street, unless people invite us onto their properties to...
36:39 Take a look at what's there, what these folks can do, how they can continue to harden their properties, and then obviously establish eventually re-inspection frequencies. This work I think is never done. This will be a continued effort by this community as long as community resiliency remains a priority.
37:05 But the goal of this is not to simply evaluate and have charts and maps and things of that nature. We want to do work on the ground, find ways to both empower people, residents, to clean their own properties and find ways to incentivize that as well as support that through the various entities that will be partnering in these efforts.
37:30 We have looked very, very closely at what other communities who have been successful in this space have done, whether that's Truckee, Tahoe, Marin, all of those have very, very high-level kind of prevention plans, things of that nature for their communities. So when taking a look at those, obviously the evaluation process is a part of that, but once again, on-the-ground, parcel-level work at the neighborhood level.
37:59 And we want to host events in these neighborhoods to both empower people to clean and to help them using the resources that we have, whether that is the wildland crew, potential efforts from our hosts or trail crews, utilizing Cal Fire crews, or just neighbors helping neighbors.
38:20 In their communities. Mammoth Disposal, we've worked closely with them, would be able to provide those large open dumpsters for green waste to once again make the process much, much easier for people. If the fire department as well as potentially our forest partners needed to bring a chipper to help support these operations, we could do that as well. The goal would then be to establish a neighborhood where we want to start working with Mammoth Fire.
38:49 Develop a test plot within that community. So engage those members of the community, ask those members if we would be able to come on, kind of help them clean up their particular area and use that as an example for the rest of the people within that small neighborhood or street to accomplish work.
39:08 We think that'll be really effective to provide kind of that on the ground example, really just show people visually what a great example looks like out there on the landscape. Again, we want to prioritize those highest risk areas within the community wildfire protection plan, start with those, move forward from there. We want to advertise in these neighborhoods heavily for when these programs or particular, let's say, weekend events may start.
39:37 Possibly the week before to say, hey, this Saturday and Sunday we'll have crews in the area, we'll have Mammoth Fire, we'll have town staff working to help you create defensible space around your property. And again, that's where I think other entities could come in that we could bring in, whether that's MLT, obviously they have a massive reach to kind of help support these efforts.
39:59 We also want to utilize recommendations in the California Joint Strategy for Sustainable Outdoor Recreation and Wildfire Resilience to leverage any recreation infrastructure as fire breaks as well. Now I know that some of that is outside of the parcel level, but a lot of our multi-use pathways and things like that go through these neighborhoods and utilizing those as part of this process as well. So again, just giving an idea how all of these things tie together.
40:28 And how can we also leverage existing events to, once again, empower people or help people to do that parcel level work, whether that's town cleanup day or other green waste events? Truckee, again, I think has been really, really successful in these endeavors. Just photos here from Truckee of what this looks like with folks kind of piling their green waste, things of that nature. I think our partnership from...
40:56 With Mammoth Disposal as well will be super, super helpful. And not just leave these piles on the side of the street, but be able to put them into the dumpsters where Mammoth Disposal can then pick them up and really help support these operations and just make everything more efficient. But again, at kind of the community level, I want to give you an idea of what this might look like in a community, what the streets might look like after an event such as this.
41:21 Again, I want to tie in with the California Joint Strategy that I mentioned before. Tying in with all of this is using our recreation infrastructure. As fuel breaks, you will see a map on here highlighting the green, yellow, and red in particular with MUPS infrastructure. And we have mastication plans with Mammoth Fire to either masticate or mow.
41:45 To create some defensible space around these pieces of recreation infrastructure. So again, all of these different avenues tying in together from the parcel level to the recreation infrastructure to the ESCCRP in the WUI or the wildland urban interface surrounding town. We also want to look into ways to support resiliency through existing building code or improvements or additions to the existing building code.
42:15 We want to, first of all, tabulate anything related to resiliency and wildfire and make it simple for people to understand what the existing code says as it relates to this. So if there are existing noncompliant facilities, we can work with them to become compliant. Also, what...
42:33 What can we do to incentivize compliance? Thinking outside of the box or thinking of ways to help incentivize compliance? Definitely things that we're thinking about. And again, explore avenues to edit kind of the existing building code to further support community resiliency. So I think these are just things that we can look into. Is there a way, for instance, to eliminate?
42:58 Permit fees associated with fire prevention and home hardening. And again, these are just some ideas. What about the homeowner services companies who could have a very, very large role in this process in order for the community to kind of clean itself up? They will be, I think, essential.
43:17 In a lot of these endeavors. So can we incentivize homeowner service companies some way, either through codes or establishment of new businesses, to be able to go into this space and react to community needs? Software support. This is another avenue that some really cool developments have been made over the last number of years in terms of leveraging modern technology to really help us both assess
43:48 And communicate as it relates to our community's resiliency. In particular, two pieces of software that we've had a lot of conversations about recently are Fireside and Vibrant Planet. These both can provide invaluable information related to both our risks, updates in real time, providing information on what areas to quote unquote attack first.
44:14 As it relates to our resiliency efforts, and we'll talk about these in subsequent slides. It also provides avenues for homeowners to update their properties after they do home hardening efforts, and then being able to see, for instance, on a heat map, that update in real time. If, for instance, Rob were to...
44:34 Thank you so much.
45:04 We'll start here with Fireside. Think of Fireside as parcel level. It can provide structure scores as it relates to your resiliency, real-time updates, which I mentioned before, once defensible space work is completed, users can upload photos of completed work, and that really helps kind of create that database as well.
45:31 And also creates information on Embercast, considers weather conditions, prevailing winds, all of these different things while developing these risk-based models. And again, Truckee, I think, is a really good example of a town utilizing both of these to really help inform their decision-making in this space. And again, based on what we're seeing from a program like Fireside,
45:57 Be able to determine what are the areas that are most hazardous, where are our risks, and how can we diminish those risks. And this all integrates with another program called Vibrant Planet. Think of Vibrant Planet as more the wildland interface.
46:16 These two programs do speak with one another and, again, can help create that kind of comprehensive understanding of where the risks are and how to deal with those particular risks. So, again, for these programs, these are really helpful and I think where they really show their true colors is in the decision support tool space.
46:41 helping inform decision-making on how, again, we can create more resiliency as well as a communication tool, not only to communicate to entities such as town council, but to communicate to potential funding entities, communicate to potentially insurance companies about what our risks look like in a really quantifiable way, rather than just...
47:08 Us assuming these can provide that exact information that often those entities are looking for if it relates to funding decisions or even insurance-related items. Again, Vibrant Planet, looking at the landscape as a whole, usually the wildland landscape can show the likelihood of fire, intensity of that fire. Based on this, it can recommend areas to once again attack first. You can also...
47:36 Populate something like this with resource data and information. So again, if your goal is, for instance, to protect recreation and hydrological resources, you can basically enter that and this program will then be able to highlight areas that you should go after first to achieve those goals. So again, really neat system and kind of think of the vibrant planet stuff at the wildland landscape, fireside stuff at the parcel level.
48:03 Both of those two communicating with one another to create this holistic picture of what we're facing in terms of risk, where our resiliency is good and where we could improve. Obviously, another big part of this is public outreach. We need to engage the public. We obviously need to engage basically every single parcel and every single homeowner within the town of Mammoth Lakes, as well as condo owners.
48:32 Relay our goals. Relay our objectives. Talk about the community events that we are trying to do out there on the landscape. Let people know that there will be evaluations. And hey, if you see these kind folks out in front of your yard, invite them in. Then they might be able to take a look at your backyard and make recommendations there. But highly sensitive to the private property nature of some of this.
48:56 Utilizing mailers, potentially TOT data, MCWD accounts to get a real comprehensive list so these things can actually reach homeowners so they know what's going on so that they can take the steps necessary to, once again, continually harden our community. Other outreach, we'd love to create kind of a how-to video series with Mammoth Fire.
49:21 Highlighting some of these ways to achieve these defensible space goals, talking about the levels of effort that people should be putting in to protect our community, and really just providing some overall education of why we're doing this, why it matters, and how we can prevent a catastrophe here in our community.
49:41 Again, English and Spanish educational materials, I think that's absolutely paramount. Again, we're not trying to engage certain segments of the community, we are trying to engage the community as a whole. And also engaging other existing entities, whether it's the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance, Whitebark's obviously doing a ton of great work on the landscape, and working through those entities so that we're not duplicating efforts and reinventing the wheel. We really want to see consistency.
50:10 With a lot of this stuff, we want the look and feel to be the same, and there are many groups already doing excellent work in this space. So how can we leverage that to create consistency in our messaging? Of course, the development of checklists and materials that make it easy for folks to take a look at things and see what they can do on their landscape. And lastly, engagement of those homeowner services companies. I think this will be a big one, and those homeowner servants...
50:36 Companies, once we engage them, can potentially engage their pre-existing clients, come up with a very simple, let's say one pager to say, hey, here's the efforts by the town. These are the things that they want done. We can perform this work for you at X cost. And maybe many of these things could be handled.
50:57 Without maybe us doing it on the landscape or maybe without a community event in a particular area. So thinking about ways to engage already existing entities as well to help us in these efforts. Lastly, of course, funding opportunities. How can we support these efforts, whether it's through grants, things of that nature, whether it's Sierra Nevada Conservancy, Cal Fire, Prop 4, all of these different things to help fund some of the efforts in this space.
51:27 Take a look at existing funding that already exists for programs such as the SCE Wood Pile Cover Grants for which an application has been submitted, roof sprinkler systems, and other wildfire mitigation measures from programs that might be already existing, and as well utilizing our current grants contractor, California Consulting, to really look into what might be available in this space. Because again, this is not...
51:54 Hey, we're going to do this over one summer and we're good. This is an ongoing effort to continually keep our community resilient, keep our community safe. Because again, we all need to work together, obviously, to become a fire adapted community, a wildfire resilient community, and it starts with us. And I think...
52:16 We have seen what has happened in other areas. We are obviously taking this extremely seriously. And through the plan that we have now, I think we're really taking some effective first steps with the understanding, of course, we're going to learn along the way. I'm sure some things we try work. Maybe some things that we try don't work. And we will learn from those things. We will continually engage other communities that have also been successful in this space.
52:46 So I would like to open it up to any questions, comments or suggestions. We have the fire chief here as well to be able to answer any questions that maybe I am outside of my depth on. I'd like to add just a couple of things before we go to that, if it's okay. So first and foremost, I really want to express my gratitude for the efforts that have been made thus far with our partnerships with Fire Protection District, with Whitebark, with Water District, with
53:13 Mammoth Disposal and Lawson sort of leading us all through this. It's been some six weeks to now that we've started this process to get this thing stood up. That was a really excellent presentation on the depth and breadth of what we're doing here. But the key is this is a community project, right? We need homeowners to engage in this space. The town is not able to do all of the work ourselves. So I wanted that kind of call to action for the community.
53:42 That we're all sort of reeling from what we saw down south. We've got an opportunity. We are presenting the opportunity. We need your engagement and support. And I'm, you know, super proud of Lawson and team for saying, you know, here's an opportunity we can stand up these businesses in town, too, to provide those services. But we've got to have community engagement here. So, thank you. Thank you. Questions? I do have one. A statement and a question. Can I go there? Go for it. Okay. One, my fear, every time we've done something like this in Bama,
54:14 We look at taking the branches 15 feet off the ground or 20 feet off the ground or 45 or whatever. And my fear isn't from... Turn your microphone on. Your mic is on. Good catch. My fear is from a forest fire coming into town. So if you've ever seen a treetop fire, what I have on the ground is completely inconsequential. The fact that it's going to sweep through my yard because I have a...
54:41 100 plus trees on a half acre lot is huge. So are we going to be looking at density and how far apart the trees on lots should be and providing help to homeowners that maybe don't have the resources to thin those tree stands rather than look at the fact that there's a two by four laying within 20 feet of my propane tank. Is that the whole question? Alex Tamire, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. So great points. If you, you know,
55:11 What Rob hit on is we need to provide the tools and the understanding to the community so they can get the work done. And it obviously is a multifaceted problem that's going to involve all of us here, including our, you know, NGO partners and everything. What you're alluding to is the fact that most of these homes that catch on fire are due to ember cast. And most of the time that ember cast might be coming from up to half a mile, a mile away.
55:37 So it can feel very daunting in that aspect, right? And so what we need to do is tackle all of this. We need to make sure that we're doing a perimeter around the town and we're also working within the town. Lawson kind of alluded to that. A really good way of working with these two companies to look at is there's almost two knobs that you have to churn.
55:58 One is kind of your exposure. And that's the fact that we live in a forest. If you look up at the lakes basin, you've got an exposure risk. There's ember that's going to be coming towards your neighborhood. So you have to do everything you can to churn down that dial. The other dial is basically your susceptibility of your structure, right? And if I'm living on juniper right up from the lakes basin and I have a wood shake roof, guess what? My susceptibility is probably on the high side.
56:28 I'm not going to go to your house, Bill, and tell you that you have to re-side it, you know, because the reality is we can't all do that today. We'll probably give you what we're calling a windshield evaluation. We'll come in from the street and be like, you know, we want you to do the low-hanging fruits, the zero to five. If you can get your sweep from kind of the side of your house, five feet out, that's the best bang for your buck. Things like that that you can do. And then if you want a little more information, we'll give you an option to have somebody walk your property with you and give you some other things if you're looking at, you know.
56:56 Downside, when I'm residing, can I go non-combustible or whatever that is? So you're right in the sense that we have to turn on the exposure side, which is really what White Bark's been taking the lead on, frankly, and making sure that we're trying to reduce that risk kind of at the landscape. But we also have to make sure that everybody in this community realizes they've got some ownership in this game, right? And give them the tool so that they can take that susceptibility side of their parcel and try to reduce that as well. Neither one by itself is going to do the job.
57:22 Does that answer your question? To a point. Our forestry is horrendously overgrown, including on my own private lot, even though I've removed 25 trees in the last several years. Are we going to deal with that and have that as part of our education process as we go and look at houses? Or are we going to be just looking at the duff and how high the dead branches are off the ground? Because to me, that's where we're susceptible, that treetop fire.
57:47 We don't have the same fire community that L.A. did. We're not Mesquite and other low-lying brushes that burn like crazy when they get. Our fires move a little slower than that and are easier to fight. And in this are we going to have a political arm as well that is going to look at the policies of our federal partners and the let burn policies when fires start that never used to be there that create so much danger in the current forest environment.
58:16 Great point. You did mention that earlier. The answer is absolutely yes. So we're already doing a lot of that work with our federal partners, again, kind of white bar taking the lead on a lot of that. We want to make sure we're supporting that as a community and as individual organizations. Within the town, we absolutely have something to do. I think we start with the lowest hanging fruits again. There's quite a few trees that you can take down without permits.
58:43 That are simpler and those are the ones that some homeowners may feel come more comfortable doing. We want to provide resources to start to work on some larger trees. That gets more complicated obviously for a significant number of reasons. So at this point we're really trying to give people the tools to start with some of the simpler things. Part of what Mammoth Fire is committed to with some support from the town as well is that we help those.
59:08 People that just can't do the work themselves. There's going to have to be a process for that, so we're going to have to look at what is the risk, you know, do you look at certain communities first, are there certain populations access functional needs, senior citizens, people within certain AMIs that we would help first, but we absolutely want to make sure you can't do this as an individual parcel, that if there's parcels out there that frankly need the work, that we support them to get through that work. Thanks, Alish. Yep. Questions? I'm good.
59:38 Questions? I just have a little question for you. I guess I feel like the town's role is to sort of facilitate homeowners to harden their homes. Would we, you know, like thinking about my house, I don't have a super high ladder to be able to trim branches, you know, like the fire department having a ladder that they rent out and drop off at your house and pick up or something, like things like that that make it so that you...
1:00:04 Make it easier for everyone to do the work without everyone having to go out and buy a big ladder or things like that or, you know, waiving the fees year-round to dump green waste and then, like, having all of the wood piles covered with fireproof tarps. So, great question. I think there's a couple different things you're bringing up here. The first piece is education because some of these things actually already exist. We can get the green waste fees if you can come by the fire district and get a coupon. I think some of this is just
1:00:33 Educating our public. The other piece is, you're absolutely right, we have to provide the tools. I think we're certainly open to ideas. We did similar work with the Fire Safe Council a few years back. I hesitate, you know, we're obviously not going to hand chainsaws to our public and put them to work. And those may be roles that the fire district can support. We're in a unique position because we need to have a workforce that can respond on the fire, but fires fortunately don't happen every day. So the goal is to have a
1:01:02 Seasonal work crew that is doing exactly what you're referring to. You have a neighbor who is a senior citizen who had some work that she needed around her that we assisted on. And the goal would be that we prioritize based off certain needs because we obviously can't hit the town at one point to create a fair environment on how we do that. But that we absolutely help with the things that are difficult for homeowners. I will say even with that, you know, we're going to have some challenges once you start to get to larger mature trees. Those are very difficult.
1:01:30 The positive is those really aren't where your biggest risk is. So if we can get rid of a lot of your smaller trees, you know, create some breaks in the fuel sources, we're going to be in a much better spot than we are today. Thank you. Questions? Yeah, I've got a couple questions. Go ahead. A couple of these are just administrative ones. So in the presentation, we refer to the Mammoth Lakes Fire Department.
1:01:57 As far as I know, we don't have a fire department. We have a Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. As we go into this, make sure the semantics are clear. You're the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, right? We are, but it says Mammoth Lakes Fire Department on our front door. So this has been a problem for us for a long time. But I agree. It's important that we have a proper understanding of roles and responsibilities. Okay. And the naming conventions are important.
1:02:24 This follow-up question to that. We all went through when Southern California Edison showed up in town and started arbitrarily just showing up in our front yards and our backyards and just going. These were contractors. We all had a lot of unfortunate interactions with that. The people that are going around doing this windshield viewing, will they be from your department? Will they be in uniform? How will they be identifying themselves? So great question.
1:02:53 Certainly be Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District individuals in uniform. The town may decide to have some other inspectors. And I see this as kind of a tiered process. So there's a home evaluation that's kind of done from the windshield. And we didn't invent this. CAL FIRE uses this process where we're not being intrusive. We might go knock on the door if somebody wants to walk with us. We will. Otherwise, we're just going to do it from the right from the road. And it's essentially just a, hey, took a look at your property. These are some ways you might want to try to mitigate your risk.
1:03:22 There's also a true inspection, which usually has to have something that triggers that. Generally, those can be a certain real estate transaction. It can be you're doing an addition or you're actually building a house that then gives an opportunity to both the building department and the fire department to go out and do a full inspection. Or you can just request one, say, hey, I want to mitigate my risk. Can you come over and give me a chat and do that? Okay, so a couple of questions for that. We went through the town with doing a very ambitious housing program and we didn't have a coherent name for it.
1:03:50 It took a while. We finally got to housing now. So the community has an idea now what housing now means. I would suggest perhaps with this group, branding yourselves this whole effort as the wildfire, you know, the wildfire team or the Mammoth Lakes wildfire team. So that becomes a thing that it gets in people's brains. They understand what that is. That might be helpful. These windshield reports, how does that information get communicated to a homeowner? So another good question.
1:04:19 So a lot of this isn't necessarily new to us or other places, so that's kind of an important point. Mammoth Fire has done some of this in the past, and I think we just didn't have the capacity, so now we're growing the program. The goal is to have 12 people on this team this summer, so quite ambitious. And a little bit of a tangent, but what we found in the past is just by going out and doing this windshield inspection, a lot of people were 60-70% second homeowners. The reality is that goes to
1:04:49 And it would go to the homeowner. They would then pass it on to whoever is their company. How would it get to the homeowner? Great. And then generally for a second homeowners, it would just get the work done. So we've got some kind of low hanging fruits. How does it get to the homeowner? This is where Fireside fits in. What they do is they pull the information from county assessor records. It goes directly to...
1:05:13 A database that we then use. Ideally, as we're working through this process, we're sending out mailers, and we're actually trying to capture a little more information. Mailing addresses are great, but really what you want is email contacts. Ideally, we're probably going to try to capture phone numbers for additional reasons as well. But ultimately, you know, an email connection is going to be the best way to go, but initially it's going to be a mailer. Okay, because that's a huge database issue to deal with. I would suggest...
1:05:40 That if you're going around in neighborhoods and people are present, maybe a very simple kind of a sticky note thing you could put on someone's door that says, hi, the wildfire team has come by, we've taken a look at your house, we'd love to follow up with you so that locals can, you know, they can make that. And they make little door tags, they have like a QR code that you can go to that works really well. The company that we're working with, Fireside, they're frankly kind of best of breed at doing this. So they run a lot of data analysis to see.
1:06:08 What's the most effective way to reach people? And then what's the most effective way to get them to actually do some work as opposed to just checking? Have they worked in communities that don't have postal delivery to homes? They are the lead in Tahoe. Okay. And there's no home mail delivery in Tahoe? I'm not sure if there's home mail delivery in Tahoe. Yeah. So, I mean, again, we're a very idiosyncratic place. It's like there's no...
1:06:34 It's all through PO boxes, as we all know. So that's something to think about. So that's good. But I think that's something to follow up on. A couple other things. With the town, I mean, perhaps you guys, in terms of the relationship, which is a very productive one between you guys and WhiteBark.
1:06:53 The extent of your district, of the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, and the degree to which that interfaces with federal public lands. Have you guys started having any discussions around maybe sort of a LAFCO type discussion or something to ensure that your service area and the work that, say, Whitebark is doing in the federal lands is, at the end of the day, going to do the kind of work that we need to do? It's maybe something to talk about at some point, but...
1:07:22 I think that to answer that question directly, that's why those two teams are together. Now, as far as the Forest Service and your LAFCO questions, that's a little bit broader. I mean, we have connections with the Forest Service, and I have regular one-to-one meetings with our district ranger. But that was part of this dialogue of, you know, the work that's going on slightly outside of town, and then Alice's work.
1:07:47 Primarily works right around the town and then we're engaging sort of in the parcel level interior of that. So all three of those are designed to work together. Later on the agenda we have got additional resources requested through the budget process that are going to augment his wildfire team this year and add more bodies to that space hopefully and that would
1:08:08 Assist in that. But I think there's really good coordination between the two entities that are doing work in those spaces. Yeah, I just want to make sure that the authorities, as we all kind of work together on this thing, it's all going to be covered, especially with the challenges we're getting with federal grants and stuff like that, that it's going to be able to work. I would agree that some of our challenges, frankly, right now are, you know, for example, we are working on those fuel breaks that you saw on an earlier slide. The easy ones have been the town property, and then we just reached out. We're working with Chuck Landy to do work around Snow Creek.
1:08:38 The more difficult ones are the ones that are on federal lands because we don't have just direct jurisdiction. Even through a LAVCO process, we already have parts of our district that are on federal land. That's always going to be a challenge. I mean, having good partners that can help bridge those gaps is going to be fundamental. I think we're making good segue to get there, but it's an ongoing process and it's a challenge. Okay. All right. I would also point out, Lawson, that, I mean, the work that you and this team is doing is really
1:09:07 Providing some great leadership for the region in this space. I know that the ESCOG is applying for some similar grants. They're looking for you and your expertise to help inform the region around these things. ESCOG also adopted the joint strategy for sustainable outdoor recreation and wildfire resilience. The Towns and Trails alignment, which is being finalized, that could be a key piece of regional infrastructure. So we've got a lot of great opportunities to kind of scale this up. So again, thank you all for your leadership on that.
1:09:36 And I guess that's fine. I think the final thing I have is I'm now the chair of the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. So I would love to be able to bring things to that agenda that you guys, the Fire Protection District and Whitebark, the things you're working on, if there's any kind of mitigation stuff or policy measures that need to be brought up by the Air District Board that will help.
1:10:05 With controlled fires or controlled burns and doing that kind of stuff, please reach out to me and I can get those things on the agenda. It's been through a bit of a transition, but we've got excellent capacity now. And again, with the challenges with our federal partners, I think this is something to go to the Air District with to say, look, we're going to need some help for be able to do controlled burns and things like that. So those are my questions. Thank you. And I guess I would add one more thing kind of in light of your comments.
1:10:32 We are looking at this. This should be a landscape regional solution. So we had meetings today with all partners to how do we take some of these lessons and really apply them to a regional CWPP to where we have a dynamic understanding of what our whole landscape is doing and frankly do some of the legwork that makes it easier for some of these smaller communities to follow suit. The mayor and I serve on the SGOG board, so I would encourage you to reach out to Alain Cabal if you haven't already because we can start coordinating some of these things region one.
1:11:02 Very briefly as well to address Councilmember Wentworth and Councilmember Sauser's comments related to some of our forest partners. It kind of lands immediately adjacent to town. Obviously much of that is covered in the ESTCRP, but the forests do have something called the Good Neighbor Policy, which is meant to address these exact things. That interface right up to communities and trying to find ways for either streamline NEPA or to partner with state entities to...
1:11:29 Deal with those plots of lands as it relates to forest health and resiliency. So I just wanted to mention that. Because I would just add to that, the advocacy work, I know Rob, you've been leading this, talking with our congressional delegation, Congressman Kiley. We've got something on the agenda later to sort of get in common cause with Truckee. But I think that all the work that you're doing, come to your electeds, come to the staff, let's get this upstairs. Because there's some very sort of sophisticated
1:11:57 Legislative tactics that are on board in the federal agenda whereby all of this could get rolled up into one big piece of legislation. And if we don't get our ass in there, we don't get those things taken care of in that big piece of legislation, we're going to be kind of, I'm not going to use an expletive, but you know, out of luck. So we need to be really coordinating all this stuff to make it all work effectively. So thank you. Thank you. Just a couple of questions.
1:12:27 I was lucky enough to go to the Civic Well meeting, which is a meeting for policymakers, local elected officials, so town councils and county supervisors, and there were several wonderful presentations, which I'd be happy to share with you. I'm sure you're aware of a lot of this, but it just really helped us think about how you use your elected officials to advance these things. A couple of questions. So the first is,
1:12:55 The CWPP that we have, I believe, is getting updated. Can you talk a little bit about the timeline for that? Sure. So originally, there's actually multiple CWPPs in the region. There was one done by the fire district, and then there was one that was done as a sub-portion to the multi-hazard mitigation plan, which is currently going through the review process. There was a decision made that the multi-hazard mitigation plan really has to get finalized so we have some grant opportunities, because ultimately, these plans do two things.
1:13:24 They kind of set a path as a community, but they also give us those grant opportunities that, you know, Mr. Wentworth was referring to.
1:13:32 We felt that it would be too much of a rush to try to do a quality CWPP in the multi-hazard mitigation plan. So the multi-hazard mitigation plan is moving forward and it'll reference a CWPP. Right now we're working with getting all the stakeholders together to really look at doing a proper CWPP and then ideally one that's, that I mentioned this earlier, dynamic that's really taking a look at both our landscape as well as our community and say, okay.
1:13:58 Here's kind of where our risks are. And as we work these projects, you know, White Barb does something up in the lake space. And how does that change our risk? As people start to work in their communities, what's changing and where should we put our efforts now? And that's where we want to be. And ideally, frankly, we're doing a regional one for multiple reasons, but also because grants. When you look at Mammoth Lakes, you have a hard time getting grants when you're trying to be competitive, when there's areas that have, you know, people that have significantly under median income that are going to be picked before us.
1:14:25 It benefits everyone if we can get all the stakeholders and do a collaborative one. That process is currently in the works and it's in a planning phase. And I think what's going to make the most sense for us is that because the old ones are so antiquated, we add some of the old projects. For example, the ESCCRP is not even in the CWPP. So we need to get a stopgap CWPP that includes the important projects in there and then start that process of building a good dynamic one that has all the parties involved.
1:14:53 Long, it's going to take a little bit of time. I'm hoping, you know, within six months, we can have a new CIPLP that's just a quick update to the existing one, and then we work on a better one long term. Does that answer? It does. Thank you. And I just want to remind everybody that, or I should ask, I know that the Prop 4 funds are going to start being given out. That's the climate bond for anybody who doesn't know. And so...
1:15:20 My understanding is you have to have an active CWP. Is ours good enough to be able to write grants for these funds because they're coming now? It's a good question. It depends on the grant. Sometimes they want them within five years or current ones from 2019, I believe. So it would depend. And that's why there's really pressure to update the current one quickly because, frankly, redoing a full one is going to take a longer period of time.
1:15:49 I'd say it depends on the grant. Some are as good as 10 years, and I don't know what that one is going to be asking for. Well, if you run into a roadblock, this team, just come back to us and tell us what you need to get it done, because that $10 billion sounds like a lot, but it'll be gone before we know it, and we want to get, you know, our fair share. So thank you.
1:16:13 The other thing is you mentioned our Fire Safe Council, and I was wondering if it would be possible for maybe you to bring back at a future council meeting Fire Safe Councils, FireWise Communities. I know they're at different levels of engagement right now, and FireWise Communities is something that's really just starting to grow, but I think it would be really important for the public and for us to understand, you know, the differences, how they work together, and what we can do to really help those two
1:16:43 Different types of entities be more successful in our community. Yes, and so I'll put out there the Fire Safe Council essentially disbanded a few years ago. That's what I thought. We have a standing Fire Safe Council. Okay, good. I thought that, but you said Fire Safe, and I was like, I can't find one. Because they had some projects that they did historically here that were helpful to the community. Got it. Thank you. Fire Wise is, yeah, there's probably some version of a staff report that should come to explain what the...
1:17:11 FireWise are kind of growing organically and starting to form within the community, but there's still a need for a FireSafe Council. That's something we would probably add to the list of things that we need to help support. Generally, they should be just a kind of a community effort, but they need that administrative support that needs to come from an organization that has the capacity to do that. Otherwise, they fall apart, which is what happened to the last FireSafe Council. They're 501c3s, right? Generally, yes. So do we still have like an infrastructure or would we have to start from scratch?
1:17:39 That portion you'd have to start from scratch, but that's not a huge lift. The huge lift is sustaining that effort over multiple years. You can get that initial interest, you'll get a CPA that'll help you build the 501c3, but what you find is keeping that engine going for a long period after a couple years, and especially when our Fire Safety Council is incredibly successful. I think they've got a $400,000 grant to work in the lakes basin.
1:18:07 But the administrative work to fulfill that grant just became, so really that's where those partnerships work out and they become a partner that comes in on grants, but they really probably shouldn't be the one that wants to do all the legwork afterwards when you get that grant. So building that properly, kind of like Mr. Wentworth was mentioning, as far as roles and responsibilities, we need to stand one up and we shouldn't overburden them. Absolutely. When they got that SNC grant, that grant basically sunk the Fire Safe Council. The administrative burden.
1:18:36 Yeah, that's a consistent problem. There's one other question I forgot to ask, but I wanted, I know Kim Cook is here, but at some point it would be good to get, as you start working on this work, the CEPAW, the information that came out of the CEPAW grant, you were mentioning about whatever code adjustments or things like that that may need to be added. That was a really good effort. It was specifically addressed at building codes and things like that, and I just, it would be good to get Kim at some point to get an update on what that looks like. Sorry. Oh, no, you're fine.
1:19:05 A couple of other things. So let's see. Oh, Janet, when you showed me your big scary maps on the wall of the White Bark Institute that showed where the fires would come and in different wind conditions, what could happen, was that using Vibrant Planet or did you use a different? No, good question.
1:19:30 This stuff's complex, and I will applaud the wildfire team to do so much in such a short period. But what you need to understand is underneath the Vibrant Planet platform is a fire modeling tool called Pyrologix. Pyrologix is the scientific sort of modeling engine underneath that, and then it has a very sort of sexy front of...
1:19:54 User, graphical user interface that allows the public to visualize and quantify the progress that you're making and where the risks lie. The modeling that we used in 2022 or three, the years blend a little, was just before Pyrologic was launched and it's a different fire model called Behave. It's the industry standard. It's been used for decades. So very much grounded in
1:20:24 The fuel model, weather, fire, weather, topography, those type of inputs that generate those modeling outputs where the risk lies. So very similar process, but the tools are recently in the last five years, there's been a huge effort to upgrade them because what we're seeing is the old models are drastically under predicting what we're seeing happen on the landscape. And that's because we're in a sort of a new scenario where the fuels are accumulating.
1:20:53 The weather is intensifying and we're not able to be successful suppressing fires like we used to be no matter how much money or water or people that you throw at it because the odds are being turned in our favor or against our favor. So if that helps. Yes, that's great. Thank you so much. And yeah, I mean, I encourage everyone to look into White Bark Institute and learn what they do and ask Janet if you can see the big maps. They will.
1:21:20 Make you much more interested in hardening your home. Yeah, and just a quick comment on the Fire Safe Council, just really briefly. I think it is time to sort of question whether or not that burden should be placed on volunteer community members, and we're discussing that in the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance, really at a regional scale. There are many places in California where Fire Safe Councils are organized at the county.
1:21:48 Or regional scale with paid staff to do sort of the grant burden and then that'll frees up the community members to do the good neighborly work. That's a little more fun, also very important, but we've burned out, we're going on four regionally and Mammoth being one, but it's just not a sustainable model. If you've ever administered one of these government grants, you will know why, but just
1:22:14 Huge hats off to Mammoth Lakes Fire Safe Council for the work that they did. But yeah, it's just a lot to ask volunteer folks who have normal day jobs. And I've been hearing that that's why Firewise communities are becoming much more popular because there's much less burden and they're very community focused. And it's sort of the fun community level work that builds camaraderie and rapport and things like that. That's really important.
1:22:40 Taking on government grants, totally different beast. Yeah, and it's also, you know, been quite effective. So, okay, thank you. And then, let's see. Oh, one other thing I just wanted to mention. And by the way, I'm...
1:22:58 So impressed by the amount of work that you've all done together. I was really surprised to see how far you got in six weeks. So the good news is I know you're all individually working really hard on these things. And I think, you know, forming this working group has made such a big difference. The last thing I just want to mention is I would love to see you talk more about what happens when the fire comes. So a little bit more about evacuations.
1:23:25 I know that we have communication tools, but I know in down south people used watch duty and I heard a lot about that this weekend and it seems to me like there are more and more tools that we could implement that would make it easier for us to reach our community because, you know, we are still at significant risk. Yeah, I'll say, Chris, part of that is, you know, we have zone haven for our evacuation routes and so forth.
1:23:52 And while we did some testing initially, when we rolled that out, we want to start to get really consistent testing and processes so that people, not only the first responders are used to it, but the community reacts well to that. So we're looking at doing something maybe on a quarterly basis around town where we execute some evacuation test drills just to make sure that we're functioning those really well. Remember during this snow emergency,
1:24:18 We had a lot of things to learn about that process in our many late nights trying to figure that out with our help from Mono County. But that's definitely a part of the program. And just remind me, I'm sorry, I remember when we approved Zone Haven, but is that, does that push out to all the phones? So is there an opportunity, does that communicate with something like Watch Duty where people who just happen to have that app would always, I just want to make sure we
1:24:47 You know, have suspenders and a belt for reaching people, because we get a lot of people in town who aren't always here, and I just, I want to make, I just would love to see that demonstrated. Yeah, those are really, they're geofencing, so they interact with cell phones when you cross a particular geofenced line, so regardless of whether you're signed up for it or something along those lines, it's going to pop up.
1:25:09 I'm certainly familiar with watch duty, and we use that, I think, for a lot of information, but I don't know how that interacts, but we can look into that. Please, because we have a lot of places in town where cell coverage is still pretty lousy, so, you know, people might not get it, and at least if they knew there wasn't a situation, they might be able to proactively look themselves, so I think that would be advisable. Terrific. So...
1:25:34 Oh, the last thing is I just wanted to let you know that I know you're looking at the Marin model Lawson had shared. I heard about that one of the best local community responses is the Santa Barbara Bucket Brigade. They're supposed to be amazing. And it's very much community driven. So not as much for you all. Maybe that's something for...
1:25:55 Some of us to take more leadership on. So thank you so much. I'm really feeling so good about all the work you're doing and super grateful. So that was our questions. Any public comment on? Here comes John Urdi. Just a quick question, and I don't know who to direct it to, but all of this proactive mitigation is amazing. How does it correlate to
1:26:24 I mean, it's obviously, it's a huge effort to save the town, which is great, but...
1:26:42 Well, we don't sell insurance. I buy insurance. Sometimes you should like to do it. Yeah. Go ahead, Alish. And then I actually have a response as well, but go ahead. Yeah, and I guess I think the first part is this. There's an unfortunate truth, which is there is a significant disconnect between true risk understanding and assessment and what your rates are. So we can't fix that today. It's getting worked on at multiple levels. But the reality is...
1:27:11 We still need to mitigate the risk, and over time that will start to close that gap. As these models get better, as Janet was mentioning, they start to look at them because you create markets, right? There is a disconnect between what they're charging and maybe for certain homes, that's not the correct rate. I think there's very few places that are frankly going to go down, but there's some that should stop going up. And regardless of how much we can directly impact the insurance, if we do this work over a period, we will.
1:27:40 And it's a really good question. So Betsy and John, I know some folks at the state who are working on these insurance issues who might want to come to a community coffee and educate us on where things are and where they're headed. Like Fire Chief Demeyer said, it's not one-to-one, but there are things we can do. And the more we harden our community, the better.
1:28:12 So no other public comment? Oh, an online public comment. Thank you, Jamie. Guest with the 760. Oh, area code, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Sandy Hogan. And I would like to speak to you about Firewise somewhat because we have been in the midst, you know, everything north of Forest Trail and east of 203.
1:28:50 Which is the Knowles and the Holidays. We have, well, we're in the process of forming the Holiday Knowles Firewise Community. We started last year and we're working with Bob Rooks in the fire department and also, I think it's Bill Anderson, I'm sorry, with Caltrans and they came to a joint meeting when we were forming this.
1:29:18 And actually, when you get designated as a FireWise community, you actually will, I think, qualify, depending whatever, but qualify for the Fair Plan discount, which is important because a lot of people have been getting dropped. But we are in, you know, we've been almost a year doing this.
1:29:46 Cal Fire has the outline. What I hear is a lot of duplication and questions that could be answered by, you know, the Firewise coordinators or Crystal Medhurst is working with us from Whitebark and she and Beth Burnham give us the guidance. They're members of our committee. We have been working on the three-year action plan, which is a Cal Fire action plan.
1:30:16 And you can get that. And it is really hard to get people, you know, the holiday mills are smaller, or, you know, the holiday part of it is much smaller than ours, but the grand total of our community is 226 units, you know, structures, not lots, but structures. And so, actually, our draft three-year plan is
1:30:45 Almost okay, you know, reviewed by everybody. And once you get that, and you have to be, it's pretty specific, and it's not easy to get everyone, I have to tell you, especially, you know, I'm the president of the Knowles Group, and I mean, we're two-thirds second homeowners. So you have to work with the property managers, yes.
1:31:11 But you've got to work with the individuals also. And so it is a real task, getting people signed up. But then, you know, it's a three-year plan. Cal Fire can give that to you. If you're not working with Cal Fire, you're making a mistake. Because the Firewise plan, I mean, you don't have to reinvent that. It's really a good one. And I mean, their Firewise, Beth is working with us.
1:31:41 And we're hopefully going to submit that, you know, by the beginning of the summer. And once you're designated, then the individuals may be, you know, eligible for insurance discounts. But getting out the information is really tough. And I've lived here long enough and Bill has to, well, we remember when the fire department did come.
1:32:08 And, you know, the action plan,
1:32:38 It's pretty well spelled out with advice from a regional coordinator. Beth Burnham is ours. She's also forming the Firewise community south of us where she has had a house for probably 30 years or something like that. And she has helped form, I think, two or three along the eastern Sierra. They're designated now. So as I say, don't reinvent the wheel when you've got, you know, the whole
1:33:07 The plan is laid out how to do it. It's not easy, you know, as I say with 226 people, you know, structures, that's not easy. So when you talk about a whole town, I think using this model will at least not duplicate stuff and maybe you can, if you need a grant, you know, Firewise is involved with this.
1:33:34 I'm sorry, the White Bark Institute is involved. So, anyway, I don't want to take up too much of your time, but, you know, it is important, and that's why we're taking it on, you know, but it's not an easy process. As I say, for 226 structures, we're in year one, year zero still. Year one starts when we're designated, and then, you know, you have that three-year action plan,
1:34:04 And each year, you do, you know, some, we did a windshield surgery with Caltrans and actually with Caltrans and our fire protection district, Val Brooks, last, well, last fall. Sandy, could you wrap up? Because your time is up. So if you could just wrap up, I would be so grateful. Okay, no, no. I'm here for questions if you have them. Thank you so much.
1:34:35 Are there any other, anyone else online, Jamie, for public comment? Okay, then with that, thank you so much for all your time and thank you everyone for being here and answering all of our questions. Really appreciate it. Next, we have the Summer 2025 Construction Projects and Capital Improvement Plan update. Good afternoon. Give me a second here to get situated. So this evening I'd like to share some updates on our summer
1:35:34 2025 work program and a quick CIP update. I was informed by my team yesterday that we now only have two seasons in engineering, snow removal and construction. And since we started triaging the summer construction season last month, we've declared winter to be over as far as we're concerned. I'd like to go over some projects that are carried over from 2024.
1:36:00 Particularly the road work and mutt project that we're proposing for 2025 that Rob will be introducing later today. Some new projects, some design work and planning and some private utility work that you should expect later this summer. My intent here is not to go through the full battery of CIP projects. We don't have that kind of time. I really want to highlight some stuff that's going to be ongoing. The public should be aware of and some projects we haven't talked about in some time and that are moving very quickly.
1:36:31 So carryover from 2024, we've got the town hall. I'll talk a little bit more about that. Some improvements at Mammoth Creek Park, shade structure, a railing that we are going out to get proposals for, for a piece of public art to do a kind of custom railing. We'll bring that forward once we get some proposals and you guys can decide whether or not to move forward with that. A climbing and bouldering area.
1:36:54 We continue to work on Phase 2 of the CRC. We have some additional improvements that will be proposed later this evening. Our park signage, this was approved a year or so ago. These are monument signs at three of our parks. We kicked off a Safe Streets for All grant.
1:37:14 With Kimley Horn, this would be a town-wide analysis for safety improvements, which will create a prioritized list of projects, so more work for us to do. And I'd be remiss if I didn't mention Reds Meadow Road, and I'm going to talk a little bit about what the public can expect as far as closures. Fortunately, Federal Highways manages all aspects of this project. I have checked. There's no risk.
1:37:39 With their funding, there's no risk with the oversight. Everything's taken care of. Project will continue as usual. This is a $30 million project that is being taken care of by our federal partners. So Town Hall, we plan to remobilize weather permitting here in a couple weeks. So security fencing and contract crews will be on site here shortly. We are anticipating delivery of the structural steel very early on in, well, maybe as late, late April, early May.
1:38:07 We've been talking to our partners in the neighborhood about a closure of Tavern Road for the delivery and the crane that will be set there for some time to erect the structure. The hospital informed us that they're going to kick off their project on April 7th. So we're going to be spending a lot of time coordinating construction vehicles and activity, but the partners are meeting regularly. We just met a couple hours ago. A lot of great communication and plans coming together so that we're
1:38:37 Working together to minimize our impact to each other and the community. Kim mentioned that there was a recommendation for funding for a boulder. Here it is. We're already spending that money. This is a project we've been trying to get finalized for some time and we plan to construct this summer as long as the Town Council approves the funding.
1:39:02 The project includes a 36 foot by 16 foot by 14 foot tall boulder. This is a huge climbing structure that would be placed in Mammoth Creek Park. And if you're worried, all the existing boulders will remain. I know that's probably the most popular feature of the park. This is to supplement those existing climbing boulders and create a space for, you know, all ages to climb. And it will be programmed by...
1:39:27 The Parks Department and get a lot of opportunities and we're pretty excited about this project. So there will be some impacts to Mammoth Creek Park once we start doing the concrete work and kind of prepping the site. We don't anticipate having to close the entire park like we did last year, just a section of it. So the public should be anticipating some closures at the park.
1:39:47 And I mentioned Reds Meadow. So the contractor and the federal highways, they work together. We don't really have a lot of skin in the game when it comes to making decisions as to what's going to happen with the road. They are planning to keep it closed to the contractor until July 2nd, which then it will open to the public for the 4th of July weekend.
1:40:09 Then after July 6th, it will be open Thursdays through Sundays. On Thursdays, there is the possibility of up to one hour traffic delays as they work. So they'll be working while it's open. That will continue up until Labor Day. They will open it through Labor Day. And then after Labor Day, it'll be open Thursdays through Sundays again.
1:40:30 And as we get later in the season, there'll be some decisions made with how ESTA operates, but they'll be keeping it open pretty much on weekends, and then after October 6th, it'll be closed. We are hopeful that they will be substantially complete with this project this year, and maybe next year just doing some punch list items, and that there will be minimal impact to the public and access to the valley next year. So the catalyst for this whole presentation was really the road work and MUPS project.
1:41:01 You guys see in the CIP updates I provide the larger ones in May with the budget process, a single line item that says road work. And we've been actively working on a very large road work project. We had a bit of a twist. The Golden Connect project is going to have significant impact on our streets and roads. We do not fully understand what that looks like yet.
1:41:28 We know that every street will get some level of fiber. They're talking about doing directional bore, but there's the potential for trenching. And so we don't want to spend literally millions of dollars on road work just to have it cut up. So we took a step back and said, what can we do to really provide some improvements to our streets and roads, but not do something that's going to get cut up later? So we came up with three projects to bid, an asphalt reconstruction project,
1:41:56 A slurry and fog seal project, and a miscellaneous concrete work project. And that's broken down a little bit differently in Rob's presentation to kind of associate the dollar amounts. So about $1.5 million going into asphalt concrete, about $1 million into seals, $500,000 into reconstructing some parking areas, and $500,000 in targeted repairs, and about $250,000 down at the town yard. That gets broken up into different bid packages.
1:42:25 But ultimately about $3.75 million worth of road work. So what we're looking at reconstructing are the remaining MUPs in our system. So the Shady Rest MUP, the section of MUP that starts at Joaquin and goes all the way up to Eagle, around Eagle, back down to Waterford, complete reconstruction of that. And the section we did not complete behind the college from the overlook towards Mammoth Creek Park.
1:42:54 We're proposing as an alternate the section behind the offices here that connects the library down to Mammoth Creek. We don't bid to the full dollar amount we're proposing. We leave a pretty fat cushion in there, and we have alternates so that we can scale the projects accordingly depending on how the numbers come in. If we were able to complete that alternate, pretty much every muck in town will have been reconstructed, slurried, or sealed within the last 10 years.
1:43:23 And we'd say that every month is probably at an A or A minus rating at that point. Our targeted construction projects for asphalt are really looking at a couple of key areas where there's problems, like on Lakeview at the end, there's a bunch of wagon rutting. Out here by Carlos Jr. on two corners, there's some pretty torn up asphalt that needs to be reconstructed. And then there's a number of intersections in town that are just
1:43:47 A number of them on Forest Trail where there's just steep grades, big gutters that need to be reconstructed and smoothed out. These are a problem for our snow removal crews. They're constantly hooking asphalt and digging up chunks and they're just not good grades and so they need to be reconstructed. So we felt this was a good time to target them. We're also looking at doing a large section of Shady Rest Park, reconstructing not just the parking lot but all the mups inside of the park.
1:44:18 The path from 203 all the way through the park and then everything in the park would get reconstructed. So a pretty large project for the parks. And then, like I said, a section of the town yard. So the town yard has not been touched in probably 30 years plus and we've got some pretty bad asphalt down there that we need to replace. I mentioned we have about a million dollars in seal projects. So last year was kind of a test. We did a lot of the arterials and collectors.
1:44:49 It held up quite well and was very well received. So we took a look at what it would take to slurry seal every street in this town on a revolving kind of pattern. And we've come up with five parts of town, introduced the first section, but on a five-year basis, if the budget allows, we could slurry every street in town for about a half a million dollars a year. And so that would protect our streets and roads and would...
1:45:18 Really increase the longevity of those streets. And I think it's pretty well received, makes them look nice, you know, nice smooth service. The lowest PCI pavement condition index, so the lowest quality neighborhood right now is the Knolls and what we call the Allen Tract around Pinecrest. That would be our first area that we would take care of and then probably the slopes after that.
1:45:41 We would also incorporate arterials and collectors into that program. So annually we're kind of getting the higher use areas and treating those. We would also contract for all the striping, all the linear striping in town. We had really good success working with the contractor last year and it freed up our crews to do other work like the dog park and working at Mammoth Creek Park. So that was great. We're also going to fog seal or proposing to fog seal.
1:46:10 The streets that were repaved last year. Again, that puts a seal code on it and increases the useful life. And as alternates to that seal project, we have the lake basin path in its entirety, the scenic loop, and then slurry ceiling, lake view, and a section of Old Mammoth Road. And again, these are alternates if the budget allows. I'll stop right there and see if there's any questions. Go ahead. I have some questions.
1:46:41 Thank you. I want to first start off by commending your crew, whoever's on that caseloader that takes care of the new Sherwin's trailhead. That person does a really excellent job, and I really appreciate the work they're doing out there. It's a great amenity, and thanks for doing that. A question on the SS4A study. How does that tie in with Towns and Trails? And this is something, you know, we put in as a strategy to re-reviewing plans we've got on the books and that kind of thing.
1:47:10 Yeah, they're kind of different. So really the intent of the SS4A program is to evaluate existing safety issues. So it's not really planning for future projects. It's really looking at existing infrastructure, looking for issues. It's a real data-driven program. They look at crash history. They do some traffic studies, and they're looking for problem spots to propose, you know, crosswalks, beacons.
1:47:36 Different signage, things of that nature. It's not really a planning exercise, so they don't really tie together because they're really focused on existing infrastructure. But they could inform each other. They could inform each other if there's overlap, but they're just slightly different focuses. Will they be looking at e-bikes? We did talk about e-bikes, and we talked about bicycle safety as a whole, and so that will be a component in this study. Where it lands in the priority.
1:48:02 To be seen, this is kind of a, there's a format the federal government has kind of put out for us to do this work. In order to receive capital funding for construction, you have to kind of follow a format, and it results in a, I might get this wrong, but a safety action plan, and that we're also doing a local safe roads plan, so that we're eligible for not just the federal pot of money, but
1:48:29 Highway Safety Improvement Funds. So we're kind of combining these efforts so that we're eligible for additional funding. Because obviously e-bikes, I mean, that's a consistent issue that keeps popping up and this would be a good thing to see if we can, I mean, that's unique to us, but to have that in there. Yeah. The park signage that you mentioned, how does that relate to Section 600? Is that...
1:48:48 Is it consistent with those kinds of standards? Obviously it doesn't have to be the same, but is it the same? It actually lands in the municipal side. So it's section 800, I believe. And that was part of that whole design process we went through with merge, oh man, 12 years ago. And so we finally have kind of...
1:49:06 We identified the funding to get those first three parks monument signs. So the design, the look and feel of those things is consistent with the vehicular wayfinding program? It's right out of the vehicular wayfinding program. They were designed as part of that exercise, so there'll be a cohesive feel between our pedestrian sidewalk signage, vehicle signage, and the monument signs.
1:49:26 Okay, a general observation, and I think for my fellow council members, as we start getting into challenges with wildfire, recreation capacities with the Forest Service, our federal partners, I think, Rob, at some point, however you think it's appropriate to do this, is to start looking at R&U with along the lines of our council objectives, our priorities.
1:49:50 Around public safety, around recreation that compels visitation. To maybe start thinking about how we start prioritizing that a little bit. Because this also ties in with Mammoth Lakes Tourism.
1:50:03 And the story that we can be telling to our entire audience, the town and community of Mammoth Lakes is ahead of the curve in all this. Our bathrooms are clean, fire safety is happening, trails that otherwise may have been managed by the federal government, we have opportunities to maintain all that. So the expectation, the experience you have up here is going to exceed your expectations. And we may need to start thinking about tapping R&U a little bit to start doing some of those things. So that's a down the road thing, but I think it's something we need to start thinking about.
1:50:33 The Golden Connect team, do they have the authority to show up and start digging up our streets? Not yet. So we've seen some preliminary plans, some schematic designs. They will have to get a permit from us. They know that. We're working with that team. But we haven't seen any programming, any scheduling. So we don't know what that looks like yet. So that's why we're fearful to make commitments to do significant road work without knowing that.
1:51:02 And knowing that this could be a two to three year project, we wanted to look at kind of alternate ways of making improvements to the street network, but not, you know, making a bad financial decision on doing road work and then having it immediately cut out. I mean, it's very wise because I think we all remember Lake Mary Road when, was, who did, who showed up and started digging up Lake Mary Road and then remember they didn't? Who hasn't? Well, but remember it was a brand new road.
1:51:28 And they showed up and they said, oh, we got to put, it was, I don't know, it was Edison or someone showed up and said, we got to start. And they dug it up. They didn't patch it properly and the road got compromised. It was a mess. So that's good that we're keeping an eye on that. And any update on the Electrify America charging station up by the west in the parking lot up there? Yeah. We heard that they've identified a contractor and are looking to move forward this summer.
1:51:56 And I think that was the hurdle last year is they couldn't identify a contractor. So we got wind recently that that is probably moving forward. I will update you when I have more information. Obviously, it's a private project. We've already permitted it. They're kind of just obligated to let us know when they're going to start. It'd be good to know that. Also, for those who may be interested, you can now buy an adapter.
1:52:20 For like a non Tesla vehicle, like a General Motors vehicle or Ford vehicle, they can use Tesla charging stations. I've used it, it works well, that might be something to just kind of keep in mind as we go forward. And on the roads, lower Lake Mary Road, like right past the limelight is pretty beat up, is that? I'm going to touch on that last. Okay, good, thank you. Any other questions? Questions? Yeah.
1:52:49 Excuse me. Do we have plans? I know I've seen a lot of pedestrian crosswalks around town that have flashing lights, those beacons that you're talking about. Do we have plans to install those sorts of things in all crosswalks, like specifically the one that's closest to the school? Yeah. So a couple things here. So the only one we have a plan for right now is Mountain Boulevard, and that's part of that highway safety improvement grant we just received.
1:53:19 The SS4A program is to help us identify where we can place those. And it's tricky. You're not permitted to put them at intersections where there's any type of controls. So you can't put them at a stop sign. They're mid-block connectors. There's a lot of rules the state has set for use of those crosswalks. And so we receive a lot of requests for those types of improvements. And most of the time, they're not eligible for those types of improvements because of the standards the state has set.
1:53:48 We're hopeful that, well, we expect through the exercise we're going through with Kim Lee Horn and this SS4A that we will identify where we can make those improvements and prioritize them because we do believe they're very effective and successful. So just to clarify, that's something that we couldn't use grant money for or that's something that we could never install there because? We would not be permitted to install that at that signalized intersection where there's a stop sign that's signalized. Okay.
1:54:19 On that particular intersection, we have met with the schools and we have some ideas on the future. I don't want to get too far ahead because there's a lot that we have to discuss internally before we could daylight something, but we are very much aware of the hazards there and the concerns and are working with the schools to try to make that safer. Okay, thank you. Any questions? I just have two quick ones.
1:54:45 This was a question from a member of the public, and it seems to go with this agenda item. So a teacher from the school, Michelle Corosfield, wrote to us and said that right now, you know, I know it's winter, so we haven't striped and marked all of the different safety elements that we usually have on the roads around the schools. And, you know, the...
1:55:07 Some of the new signage is pointing people towards Eagle Lodge to come through town that way instead of we used to encourage them to just stay on 203 and then come to Old Mammoth Road. So it's become a safety issue for our children. So I want to make sure we do something about mitigation as soon as we can there. Yeah, and that's why we striped in the middle of winter the stop bars, which is a challenge to put paint down, freezing.
1:55:35 We, as soon as the snowstorm was over, we put the stop signs back out, the folding signs. Like I said, we're keenly aware and share the concerns and are doing what we can. Absolutely. We just need to slow people down. Why do they have to drive so fast? And then the last thing, you know, I think Council Member Wentworth brought this up too. Boy, if there's any opportunity that someone's going to come and start digging ditches in our town and we don't talk to Southern California Edison about burying.
1:56:04 Power lines at the same time, then we've missed an opportunity. So if that really is a potential, I would strongly encourage us to have a conversation sooner rather than later. Noted. Okay. Anyone else? All right. Public comment. I'm only halfway through. Oh, jeez. I wanted to stop at the road work because we had, like I said, we only had one line in the CIP and I wanted to make sure you guys were, had an opportunity to digest $4 million worth of work. Thank you.
1:56:33 Keep going. So we also are proposing to do a number of improvements to concrete around town. So there's a number of truncated domes on Main Street, some broken concrete on Old Mammoth Road and some domes that need to be replaced. The underpasses on Main Street by the courthouse and then down by Mammoth Community Water District, we want to replace that asphalt underneath there with concrete and make it a better surface.
1:57:02 There's a retaining wall out here by the schools that we would like to replace. It does belong to the schools, but they're happy to let us fix that for them, and it's kind of an eyesore. A fair amount of concrete and gutter repair on Meridian Boulevard, and then some drainage improvements at our building at 210 Commerce, the ESTA and Parks Building. And that will get wrapped up into those bid packages and as part of that.
1:57:31 So, new projects. Again, this list is not everything. I'm just trying to get some of the big picture stuff we haven't talked about in a while. The MAC. So, the MAC is back on track. I'm not going to rhyme through this. We had some challenges when we started.
1:57:58 Taking over this project with our partners from the foundation has kind of been a slow transition on how we have worked together and now we're in a place where we're going to purchase the land, be responsible for the project, construction of the project, and own the project in the future, which has kind of changed some things. And just recently we received the letters we needed from KCCD regarding DSA. That information has been sent to DSA, positive.
1:58:24 Response, we've already kind of kicked off the work with our consultants, back in plan check, trying to get this project out to bid within about 60 to 90 days. And you'll see a request later this evening to provide the funds for our architects to continue that work, carry us through construction, and get this project moving. We are hopeful that if we're out to bid within 60 to 90 days, we would break ground late summer.
1:58:49 Do some groundwork, some foundations, and then hopefully go vertical in 2026. It's a single line item on here, but it represents a significant amount of work for the engineering team. But we're excited to get working on that. We've got two projects down at the airport. So the engineering team has started to help the airport team managing projects, parking lot reconstruction, and then we just had a pre-construction meeting on some phase one.
1:59:19 Improvements for the multi-use building and whether or not that gets funded through the FAA, we'll see, but we're prepared to do that work. Also pushing forward a contract for maintenance at Volcom Skate Park, multi-year, start making some improvements. There's some concrete work that is in desperate need of reconstruction down there. We need to replace our waste oil tank down at the town yard, so the engineering team has been working with the fleet department, the mechanics.
1:59:47 to identify a new location for that and make those improvements. The town parks and road work team are going to make improvements to Ball Field III. There's an ask for some financial assistance with buying those materials, but doing all this contract work frees up the parks and road staff to do these special projects, so we'll be taking that on ourselves. We also haven't talked about the TBID projects. This is still somewhat in development, but we will be proposing
2:00:16 Construction of kiosks along the same lines of the municipal signage and wayfinding. There were kiosks designed for information for tourists and residents. I should have put a picture up here, but it's a three-sided kind of structure with maps, information. I think it'll be a great addition and kind of supports not only tourism but our local residents with information and mapping. And then Old Mammoth Road seating.
2:00:46 The larger Old Mammoth Road project for beautification, we've kind of taken a step back. We had a couple years ago a bid that was let, and we didn't receive any bids back. We didn't get any contractors who wanted to do that work. We took a step back and realized that that concrete is now over 20 years old. And so we need to take a look at the whole, you know, infrastructure program.
2:01:11 But we want to do something to beautify now, so we're going to hydro seed all the areas and do some watering and try to get some, you know, some wildflower growth and some plant growth just to kind of make it look a little bit better. You couple that with some of the concrete work that we're trying to do this summer to kind of fix some of the broken concrete should help, but it's not the full package. We have plans to do a lot more and that's still in development.
2:01:37 We have a significant amount of design and planning work that we are working on in parallel with all the construction work. We're making some changes in how we complete phase three of the parcel. The town engineering and planning team is going to take a much stronger role in the development of the infrastructure. It's always been planned that the town would take on the infrastructure component, but...
2:02:05 Immediately, we're going to start really pushing on the construction plans. This is something we want to get started this season. So we've engaged a consultant and we're working forward with that. And our hope is to be working, taking down trees and doing hopefully some masquerading by this fall. And we'll have further follow-ups on how we plan to bring forward the actual construction of the buildings and how that development will unfold. But that deserves its own moment, its own item in a future meeting.
2:02:36 We do a lot of planning work. I beat this drum pretty much every time we talk about big CIP as we do project study reports, we do design work to be prepared for any amount of STIP money that comes forward. That's why we've been so successful in getting some of these larger projects done is because we're constantly planning ahead. So we're working on project study reports and these are technical documents, engineered stamp documents that talk about the feasibility of these projects.
2:03:05 So we have slated an old Mammoth road map that we've kind of talked about this before, but it's really starting to take shape. And we're looking at Chateau Road, Lakeview Road, and Meridian Road for a number of different reasons. So we're looking at Chateau because we have drainage issues. The road is in bad shape, needs reconstruction, and also needs some pedestrian infrastructure. Lakeview needs reconstruction, but it's also challenged by all the parking. So we're looking at how we can reconfigure the road to provide pedestrian infrastructure, but also
2:03:34 Better parking configuration because we're always challenged with snow removal competing with the parking for Canyon Lodge. And it's the same story with Meridian. Many, many years ago, there was a plan to do the entire length of Meridian Boulevard on a road diet. We accomplished the first phase under a Safe Routes to School project. We are now moving forward with plans for the roundabout, which I'll talk about in a second.
2:03:57 But the upper part of Meridian was planned for a road diet as well with improved parking and pedestrian infrastructure. So we're taking another look at that because, again, we're having conflicts with the activity at the end of Meridian with the lodge and snow removal of pedestrians, and I think we can do better. We did a PSR for the Minaret Meridian Roundabout a couple years ago, which got us in line for funding from STIP to do the design phase, and now we're...
2:04:25 Going to be asking for some additional funds this evening in Rob's presentation so that we can get this project prepared for construction funds. This project, again, was planned, I think it was 2007, those original plans were created, and has been on the mobility plan for a number of years as an improvement. The manual on uniform traffic control devices now says if you're going to consider any intersection improvements, you must first consider a roundabout.
2:04:53 And a roundabout works for this intersection. So that would be the guidance to move forward with that. And we think this is the proper fit for that intersection. We've talked about the South Main MUP. We did secure some funding. And so we're moving forward with a consultant to do that design. I mentioned the HSIP grant. We're excited to receive that. That will be designed in tandem with the South Main MUP. So all that infrastructure works together, the crosswalk, the
2:05:21 The pedestrian infrastructure on the corners and so forth will seamlessly kind of blend together. I mentioned Old Mammoth Road beautification, something we continue to work on. The Shady Rest Restroom. So we've talked about bathroom plans. I think we identified a total of 13 restrooms that we are currently responsible for that we own, not including the Forest Service stuff. Only two of those are winterized. So to have a conversation about
2:05:49 Winterizing restrooms and providing restrooms in the winter, it's going to be a pretty big conversation. It also has a pretty big staff impact. The cost estimate for the Shady Rest restroom was $475,000 just for the prefabricated structure. So this is a big ask. And I think we've only allocated $200,000 for design. So we're going to complete the design work with a conversation about a restroom plan and how we move forward with winterizing.
2:06:18 Will be another meeting and a much larger conversation. I put the Davison gate on here. So for the same reasons we're seeing all this traffic up Meridian going to Eagle Lodge, we believe it's the same issue with Davison. We've seen such an incredible uptick in traffic on Davison. It's always been a challenge. Don't get me wrong. We've known that. But we had to take some pretty drastic actions this winter season with...
2:06:47 Putting up a huge berm and a lot of signage. We felt that was pretty well received and it did its job. So we're going to bring forward a proposal to probably put a permanent gate up there with some flip signs so we can close it quicker, open it when it's dry, and do a better job of informing the public with some flip signs and some flashing beacons and so forth.
2:07:10 And then we're going to continue to work on the SCE undergrounding of Laurel Mountain. You mentioned working with our partners. That's something we've been working on for some time and continue to work on. Those are just some of the planning projects we have going on that I wanted to highlight. Can we grab questions for those? Yeah, totally. Does anybody have any? Could you go back a couple slides? I have one question. TBIT projects. Yeah. I serve as our...
2:07:40 Council's representative with the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, my dear friends. We've got good relationships, working on good things. We have to do these projects. And whether we have to kick tail on the MLT side, on the town side, this is critical. The council went through an enormous amount of angst and difficulty and very complex negotiations to really start to cement this partnership between MLT and the town.
2:08:10 So enough said for the moment, but let's get some projects identified. Let's get those things on the books. Let's move those things forward. Yeah, I appreciate that. We have some, like I said, some projects identified. It's not the MLT side. It's definitely the engineering side. You might be getting a picture here that we've got a lot going on. Things are definitely delayed. That's no fault of MLT. That's just us not having opportunity and time to work on these projects. We do believe they're important. They're part of what we're working on.
2:08:39 But be patient. No, I see some characters in the back of the room taking notes, so that's good. But we have a lot of really important work to do together, especially as this whole thing about the leadership that this town and this community is showing as a mountain town, losing federal resources, the things that we're doing, that's messaging that MLT, I'm hoping, is going to help to provide. So the degree to which we're working together. That's important. I have a question.
2:09:08 I have a quick question. Since you bring up TBID, the TBID project, would that be... I just remember the business community was very vocal in that they wanted public restrooms. Would public restrooms be able to qualify as a TBID project as well? I'm not an expert on that, but it would be part of our larger conversation about restrooms that we need to bring forward as part of a policy item and something that we need to program because it's...
2:09:37 It's a heavy lift. Okay. And then I had a couple other questions. Go ahead. I had questions about the roundabout. If Eagle Lodge, I mean, this is not in the works or anything, but say the bell-shaped parcel is developed and Eagle Lodge is developed further, like, could an increase in traffic present a problem to a roundabout? Is that the best traffic pattern? Yeah, great question.
2:10:06 So we've tasked our engineering team with looking at that. And we are well, well under roadway capacity right now. Initial studies going, you know, back to 2007 when we were looking at this indicated that we could handle all the improvements in the neighborhood, no problem with the capacity of a roundabout. And then I just, I mean, I know like in Europe roundabouts work great.
2:10:32 I think New Jersey has a bunch of them, but they're maybe like changing away from roundabouts. New Jersey. But I grew up in Southern California and roundabouts are terrifying to a lot of people down there and they don't know what to do. So how are we going to account for driver error or, you know, let people know who maybe are not very familiar with them?
2:10:56 How to get through them. You may be surprised at this, but I'm going to let Andy Morris answer this. Okay, so I don't know if anyone knows this, but I live in Truckee, and we have 12 roundabouts. We have big two-lane roundabouts on state highways. We have little tiny roundabouts on neighborhood arterials. We've got every conceivable shape and size. We have weird ones that are on a slope. We have ones with offset entry and exit lanes. And we get visitors. From Southern California?
2:11:24 From the Bay Area, and the Bay Area ones are probably not any better out than the Southern California ones. But people figure them out. Because what happens is people come into them, and if they don't know how they work, they slow down. Once in a great while, someone will try to go into one and then go the wrong way. It doesn't happen very often. And once in a while, they get somebody who's drunk who just flies right through and ends up stranded on the island in the middle. But most of the time, people either figure it out quickly or they just slow down, and then they figure it out.
2:11:53 So based on Truckee's experience with 12 roundabouts, I think that Mammoth's visitors will figure things out. You think with just one, I mean, 12 roundabouts, if you are going through them in a row, you'd figure them out by the end, but just having one roundabout in our town. People will figure it out. And the other thing about roundabouts that our public works director in Truckee has pointed out is it's not possible for a car to destroy one.
2:12:18 To destroy a roundabout? Yeah. A car, you know, an errant driver can plow into a traffic signal and that's $350,000 to replace, but you can't break a roundabout with a car. The other thing that's important is you don't have perpendicular collisions. So even if people have a little oopsie, they're sideswiping each other and it's much safer for the public. And then do we...
2:12:44 Like, does the center of the roundabout have to be cleared of snow during the winter so you can see traffic? You actually don't want to see across. You don't. You don't want to see across it. So the ones in Truckee mostly have raised islands because you don't want, as Hayes said, you don't want to see headlights coming at you because that would make you think it's a regular intersection. You want to have some visual shielding so that you're not getting more confused about where the traffic is coming from. You only want to see the entryway into the roundabout and you want to see cars.
2:13:14 Coming around it or exiting the roundabout. You don't want to see them coming. And we know how to plow these? Yeah. So we're actually planning a field trip, and we were just talking to the fleet department about this earlier today to go up and meet with Truckee staff and see, because they have a couple different configurations, and we've tasked our architects and engineers, excuse me, with looking at their designs to make sure what they have will work for us, and we're going to involve our road department or fleet department in those designs.
2:13:45 So that we have something that functions for Mammoth because we believe it. And you're not planning one of those extra credit roundabouts like they have at Highway 15, Road 88, and Myers? No, this is a very simple... It's just a... It's not through lane, go around, all that nonsense, right? Why is that extra credit? Have you... Yeah, I did it two days ago. Okay, I failed that test. They're hard to get through times, John.
2:14:09 Well, no. If you have options, it's like, wait, do I go this lane to go through or that lane to go around? But we're going to get the intermediate version. If they're properly designed, they're okay to plow. I will tell you that Placer County, several years ago, designed two roundabouts on Route 28, which is the circum Tahoe Highway in Kings Beach, and they designed them poorly.
2:14:35 And so they were catching plow blades. They couldn't effectively plow them, so they had to go back and redo them. But Truckee's not had those issues. So again, if you do it right, they work really well. So it's important to remember the turning radius of a plow truck, which we use on that road, versus the turning radius of a loader. And Bill, you're spot on. That was one of our first pieces of analysis was to make sure that our turning templates for
2:15:05 Our loaders, our blowers, our plow trucks, and the giant Cisco food truck can navigate the roundabout. Obviously there's a lot of interest in what's going on here. How about I commit when we get a little bit further down this process and have something to report, I will bring my experts to a later meeting and they can walk through their design standards, their concepts, answer any questions, and we can make that a separate item and really dial.
2:15:33 Dive into roundabouts because it sounds like there's a lot of interest in what we've got going on. Yeah, and I'd add to that because I would like to see that because I share concerns about a roundabout in that location and particularly if you visit Jackson in the wintertime and see what happens when one crash closes a roundabout. I worry about some of these other things that we're thinking about. I just want to make sure that we understand the full implications as well as is that the right place for a roundabout in this community. All right. Any other questions on? I did two slides up.
2:16:03 About Davidson? Yeah. We got a letter from some full-time residents who live at Timber Ridge, and they expressed concern about fire ingress and egress at certain times of year when there's a closed gate, and it has to do with that connector to John Muir Road, and I just wanted to make sure we brought that up as you're thinking about.
2:16:28 Changing traffic patterns at Davison. Is that something that's possible to be discussed? So that gate is private. That road is private. This conversation happens often. We don't have any control over that decision-making. We don't have any power to compel them to do anything different. It's all private property. It's HOAs. All of Bridges Lane is private. And that gate is private. So we can talk offline if we need to get into some more details.
2:17:01 There's a storied history. I imagine so. Yeah, I'd love to have more of a conversation because that's a public safety issue. And since you brought up Davidson, I just want to say I think it's been much, much better this year having to be someone who might live in that general facility because usually during the winter storms there's 20 to 30 cars piled up in that hill and once people kind of learned that it reduced dramatically. I think it was a good public safety effort to work in that direction. Thank you. But now what do you do for fun when it's...
2:17:30 You know? I can't sit out there and have a beer and watch people crash. Exactly. Okay. Thank you. So my last slide. Again, just some big project stuff we're not in charge of, but we're kind of keeping an eye on, and oftentimes we're kind of responsible for reporting back to council on what's going on, especially with like phase two of the parcel. We do expect that to go vertical early in the summer. All modulars have been built. Foundations will go in.
2:17:58 And then that thing will take shape in over the course of just a few weeks. And so we kind of keep an eye on that. We talked about Golden Connect, huge project, excited about that. Frontier has reached out and said that they plan to do connections fiber to 400 properties in town. Haven't seen any plans, but that could be a very impactful project. We expect 6060 Rock Spring, that's up in the village area. That project is going to go vertical. We'll have some impacts.
2:18:26 Lake Mary Road, you mentioned, John, that being torn up. So Limelight is planning to make a number of improvements on Lake Mary Road as part of their conditions of approval. So there's some patchwork, a sidewalk, and some other infrastructure that goes in. We expect that to happen early this summer, hopefully late spring, so that's not too impactful. There was also some discussion, I think, in the conditions of approval about connections to the lake space and path.
2:18:55 Correct. There's an intersection improvement. Yeah. Yeah. And so all that's going to get reconstructed. They're going to have to redo a fair amount of the curb, gutter, and sidewalk along Canyon Boulevard. So that all happened hopefully early in the season, like I said, because we don't want to see additional impacts to the public and the trolley and all the use there because it is a heavily utilized area. We have been told that they are planning to be substantially complete and done with that project in August.
2:19:22 And then last is Snow Creek 8. That's got a lot of infrastructure improvements. We've seen plans for improvements along Old Mammoth Road to the water retention basins and some of the road work and infrastructure. That's what we've seen as an initial kind of phase, and we'll see how they progress this season. So with that, you guys have already asked a lot of questions, but I'm happy to take it any more. But I will say in closing,
2:19:51 All this work is being handled by a staff of five people. And so I ask just patience on their behalf. They are working very, very hard, but the work program is substantial. And like I said, this is not everything. This is the Reader's Digest version, just to keep you aware of the big ticket items. There's a lot of other things happening in the background. So if there is something that rises to the occasion that you want us to prioritize over than others, we're going to have a very robust conversation about CIP with the budget.
2:20:21 Kind of lands in May, June. And at that time, I would be happy to entertain any ideas on how we may prioritize differently. But right now, like I said, we are already triaging this summer's work program. So is this too much? No, we're just, no, we can do way more. It has to be asked. You know, speaking on behalf of my team, we'll never say no. These are important projects for the community. We believe that they should be done.
2:20:51 We're going to work diligently to get them done. So we're not going to say no. It's almost impossible. But is it too much? It can be frustrating at times. But if you've, you know, we have a battery of consultants. We've probably got over 13 consultants on our bench that help us to do this work. And you mentioned triage. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I'd just like to add a little bit to that. I mean, Hayes said this earlier, but
2:21:19 One of the successes of the Town of Mammoth Lakes approach has been to do the work to be prepared for opportunities that will arise. So you are ready to go. And we've been very successful in that space. And I'll give all the credit to Hayes and his team in that. But that's an example of then you are set with the expectation you're going to be able to deliver that stuff. And that's where the team is kind of setting themselves up to get things done with the opportunities that come in.
2:21:48 And as a community, we should appreciate that greatly, but I do appreciate the question because we do worry about burnout. We are a thin group and just going very, very quickly in that space. So, Hayes, I have one question. Yeah. You mentioned long ago about the striping project, and I know we had, through the SEAL work that was done last year, there was a professional striping crew that had
2:22:17 Phenomenal pieces of equipment. They did a great job. But the paint seemed to come off pretty quickly. I think it's obviously something we do seasonally. We had a gentleman come to council and talk about the challenges with that. I know we had one of our council members nearly get into a car accident recently based upon no things being there. So opportunity to maybe stripe twice a year coming out of winter and going into winter.
2:22:45 I don't know if that's even a possibility based upon their, you know, mobilization of work that they're doing, but just something, I think, to consider. So, yeah, appreciate that. We are contracting for all linear striping as part of our seal coat project. That is our plan. We'll get an understanding at that point of what it costs to do that type of work, and then we can have a conversation about programming that multiple times a year if that's the desire.
2:23:11 There are challenges putting down paint in the winter or late season, so we are constrained there. But we have been looking and talking to our partners at Truckee about inlaid thermoplastic. It is not cheap, but it's basically a recess grind and a heat kind of plastic, heated plastic that gets melted into the grooves. Something else that we're going to talk about on our field trip to Truckee and see how that lasts, we've had some conversations and kind of got
2:23:40 Some baseline facts and figures about what it would cost per mile, how it works with snow removal. And so we are looking at other options as opposed to just striping because we understand the concern. We're just working through some seasonal challenges with making that kind of work happen. Okay. Any other questions? Any other questions? All right. Then we are moving on to the consent agenda, but I would like to ask for
2:24:15 Yes, thank you so much. A five-minute break, so we'll be back at 625. If everyone could take their seats. I've just been reprimanded by Councilmember Wentworth. He's scary, so everyone please take your seats. Yeah. He thinks he's the only one who wants to conduct business tonight. Thank you. It had a tone. It had a tone.
2:36:05 Wow. You know, some people interpret tone the wrong way. All right. It's the mix. There's cocaine in this stuff. Nice. After we're here for another two hours, we're meeting. All right. I mean, Bill's mix, so we're kind of calm over here. Jamie, I have a point of procedure. If items are going to be pulled, do I read the whole consent agenda or do I? Yeah, you can say the whole thing.
2:36:36 Thank you. I wasn't sure. All right. Thank you so much. We are now moving on to the consent agenda. There are 16 items for me to read, so you can all take a nap. So first, we need to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of March 5, 2025.
2:37:04 9.2. Schedule interviews on April 2, 2025 for the Planning and Economic Development Commission vacancy. 9.3. Adopt the Town of Mammoth Lake snow management policy. 9.4. Authorize the First Amendment to the Professional Services Agreement with Lisa Wise Consulting Incorporated for the Mammoth Main Base Redevelopment Project Management to extend the term of the agreement and to update the billing rates.
2:37:32 9.5, waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 6.20, Feeding of Wildlife Prohibited, 8.12, Solid Waste Management, and 8.13, Construction and Demolition Waste. 9.6, approve the resolution extending the authority of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to continue work on economic development initiatives for the town for the catalyst phase of California Jobs First.
2:37:58 9.7. Authorize the Town Manager to execute an agreement with Zoom Recreation, Inc. for the purchase and installation of two shade structures at Mammoth Creek Park West in the amount of $93,381.22. 9.8. Adopt the resolution initiating proceedings to levy assessment, resolution of intention to levy and collect annual assessments within Assessment District 93.1.
2:38:27 for the fiscal year 2025-26 and resolution approving the annual report and setting the time in place for the public hearing on April 16th, 2025. 9.9, adopt the resolution of intention to levy and collect annual assessments within assessment district 93-4, maintenance district one for the fiscal year 2025-26, approving the annual report and setting the time in place for the public hearing on April 16th, 2025. 9.10.
2:38:56 Adopt the resolution of intention to levy and collect annual assessments within the Benefit Assessment District 2002-01 for the fiscal year 2024-25, approving the annual report and setting the time in place for the public hearing on April 16, 2025. 9.11. Adopt the resolution of intention to levy and collect assessments.
2:39:17 Within Benefit Assessment District 2002-02 for the fiscal year 25-26, approving the annual report and setting the time in place for the public hearing on April 16, 2025. And finally, 9.12 on this one, adopt the resolution of intention to levy and collect annual assessments within assessment district 2014-1 for the fiscal year 25-26, approving the annual report and setting the time in place for the public hearing.
2:39:43 On April 16th, 2025. 9.13, accept the project closeout report for the Dog Park Project. 9.14, approve settlement agreement with Village Lodge Phase 1 HOA. 9.15, award architectural and consulting design services contract for the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center to HMC Architects. 9.16, accept register 2-12-25 in the amount of $542,601.53.
2:40:13 Accept check register 219 in the amount of $1,103,774.38. Accept check register 22625 in the amount of $58,357.45. Accept check register 3625 in the amount of $491,724.35. Are there any items that anyone wishes to pull from the consent agenda? Yes.
2:40:42 Madam Mayor, I'd like to pull item 9.4, 9.7, thank you. I'll repeat myself, I'm sorry. I'd like to pull item 9.4, 9.7, and 9.15. Madam Mayor, I'd always like to pull 9.2. Oh, that's a surprise. Okay, so do we have to vote on that or we just pull them?
2:41:10 I'll defer to Jamie on the policies and procedures, but generally any council member can pull any one thing. Okay, great. You don't have to approve it. All right, good. So then we are pulling 9.2, 9.4, 9.7, 9.10, and 9.15. Who said 9.7? Oh, sorry, sorry, sorry. That was a mistake. I apologize. And 9.15, and then... I have a point of order question for Andy. Turn your microphone on.
2:41:40 Microphone on. Or a question of Andy on 9.14 because it's pulled separately. I need to recuse myself from that. Do I need to step out of the room or how do you want me to handle that? No. The Brown Act says that for recusal on the consent calendar, you can stay here. Okay. Well, it's pulled. Yeah, I suppose you could leave the room. It's done. It's never been entirely clear what happens if it gets pulled from the consent calendar, but maybe you should. Don't engage in conversation.
2:42:15 Well, maybe you should leave the room. Okay. We get that. Okay. Madam Mayor, I would make a motion to approve consent, except 9497-92915. I'll second. Okay. Jamie, if you could please call the roll. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. I mean. It's okay. I got you. I said yes. I love it. Councilmember Sauser? Yes.
2:42:46 Councilmember Truax? Yes, but I need to recuse myself on 9.10. 9.10, okay. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes, but I would like to recuse on 9.10 and 9.12. I think, and then the other one I'd like to recuse on is Scott Polt. Okay. Now, we will go back to the beginning and discuss item 9.2. So this is the...
2:43:18 Plan to schedule interviews on April 2nd for the Planning and Economic Development Commission vacancy. And I just got a question on there because are both parties available to be there that day because I'm not sure both can be there that day. So I don't ask the applicants until the council approves when we're going to hold the interviews and then I'll call the applicants tomorrow. And what happens if the applicant is not available for that date? Then they miss the interview. And they cannot be on?
2:43:46 Planning Commissioner for this interview. They could be on the, you guys can do whatever you want for appointments. They don't have to be in person for the interview. We've done phone interviews, we've done in-person interviews, or they haven't shown up, and they can still be considered by you. And one applicant will be out of the country on April 2nd, one of the two applicants. They would also have the option of meeting with each of us individually as long as they don't tell us what they said or what the other person said.
2:44:19 Yeah, so I would like to modify 9-2 to the standpoint of allowing, make sure if we have two applicants that we have the opportunity to have interaction with both applicants, however that transpires. What date are you suggesting? I don't know these people, so I don't call them ahead of time until you guys agree on a date, so. 16. I don't know their schedule either, but can we just make it open in terms of? I'm concerned about your guys' schedule, not their schedule.
2:44:49 Can we do it from the standpoint of either the second or our following meeting and provide two different dates? So, Jamie, to clarify, this should occur on a day of a normally scheduled council meeting. Is that easier or doesn't have to? It does not have to, but it's easier usually for the council schedule. That's why I just try and do it before a regular council meeting. If it happens on a day that is not a normal council meeting, then we have to call a special meeting. Yeah, correct. It's a meeting, for sure. What about just the following meeting? Yeah, that's what I'm asking. Can we just do the following meeting?
2:45:17 Provide times at the two following meetings to? MLT meets before your guys' second meeting of the month in here, but we could probably work it out. So I believe we think that they may be available on that second meeting. From what I've heard. From what Nolan knows at the moment, they will both be available in that second meeting. So we can make that modification if that's your wish. And then I work with MLT on.
2:45:47 Having them finish in time for 9-15, or 3-15 meeting. Whoa. 3-15 meeting. So we'll look at moving to April 16th. Yes. I would process, I'd like to make a motion to amend this to the scheduled interviews on April 16th, 2025 for the Planning and Economic Development Commission vacancy. I'll second. Thank you. Jamie, please call the roll.
2:46:18 Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. All right, so next we have 9.4. This was to authorize the first amendment to the professional services agreement with these, what, is it Lisa? I can't see. Wise Consulting, Inc., for the Mammoth Main Base Redevelopment Project. So, Councilmember Wentworth, you asked to pull that.
2:46:47 Thank you. I wanted to get an update from, I guess, Nolan or staff. A couple of questions. One is, we've heard, or I have heard, perhaps we've heard, about some major rethinking of what that main base project might look like. You don't need to go to an exhaustive detail, but maybe some highlights of that. And also to give us some understanding of U.S. Forest Service involvement as part of that environmental team that Ascent has assembled.
2:47:15 Are they participating? Are they showing up? Are they saying, I'm sorry, we can't, we don't have the capacity to participate. So those two things. Sure. So we did meet with the ski area, the applicant team, I would say about four weeks ago or so at this point. They did indicate they are looking at some major revisions to the project, the overall design. We have not seen those revised plans yet.
2:47:43 Or gotten any more detail than that. They're considering some major revisions to the project design. When we did get that notice, all the teams working on it essentially went on pause since there's no sense to continue on the environmental review at that point if you don't know what the project is or on our internal review of the project if we don't know what the project is.
2:48:08 Upon that meeting, everyone went on pause, and we have not had the regular meetings while we await for their resubmittal as to what they're moving forward on. Up to that point, the Forest Service has been engaged in all of the CEQA meetings and the meetings with the applicant team. Going forward, it will be to be determined on how engaged the Forest Service staff will be, but it's our understanding that they do plan to still...
2:48:37 Participate in those meetings. Are any members of the Forest Service Team being paid for by the applicant? I do not believe that, at least to our knowledge, the applicant team is funding the joint NEPA-SEQUA document, so they are paying for a sense time on that document. As far as whether they're paying the Forest Service staff, we do not have that information. Okay, so if everything is on pause, then they're going to do a significant re...
2:49:07 Conceptualizing, which I would imagine new conceptual drawings, another presentation back to us. Oh, we're going to do look something like this. That could take a while. Is it staff's recommendation to put this contract in place and approve it now? Does it make more sense to wait until it actually looks like things are moving forward? I don't really have a problem one way or the other, but if it's going to be six months or something before anybody starts working on this thing again, maybe we would wait, but I don't know.
2:49:36 It's our desire to keep the contract in place. Speaking with Jen Daugherty, who's our contact at Lisa Wise Consulting assigned to this project, she's ready to jump back in as soon as we get what it is they want to move forward with, whether that be next week or in six months. We didn't really get a clear timeline from the ski area on when that will be. So I do think it makes sense to keep the contract in place. My direction to her was to not...
2:50:05 She asked if we wanted the regularly quarterly updates, which would have been, I think, at this meeting. I said to let's put that on hold until we actually know what it is they're moving forward with so we have something to report on. Okay, and the applicant's not going to have a problem.
2:50:19 If we're, I mean, they're paying for this. If we reauthorize this agreement, they're not going to have an objection. Well, why are we, why are you making us pay for something when we're just off redesigning the project? No, because it's the time and materials contracts. So if she's not doing any work on it while it's on pause, then there's no cost being paid to her. Okay. All right. My questions have been satisfied. I'm willing to make a motion, but I defer to you, Madam Mayor. Any other questions? No. Okay, go ahead. Okay. Assuming there's no public comment on this.
2:50:48 Good question. Thank you. Okay, so I would move that the Council authorize the First Amendment to the Professional Services Agreement with Lisa Wise Consulting, Inc. for the Mammoth Main Base Redevelopment Project Management to extend the terms of the agreement and to update the billing rates. I'll second. Great. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubso? Yes. All right.
2:51:18 Moving along to 9.7. I think I need to recuse. I have a business across the street. You have a business across the street? I mean, I rent a, like, in my paper that somebody printed out. Do you think that the shade structures presence or absence would have any impact on your business? This is a serious question. I'm not being sarcastic. No, I don't think so. I would tend to agree. I think you can probably participate. I don't think this is going to drive any business for you. Okay. Thank you. So,
2:51:52 Who was it that wanted to pull this one? That was me. Okay. Council Member Wentworth. Thank you. Could you ask your question? Yeah. Just a simple question. It wasn't clear in the agenda item the source of the funding for this project. Can you just advise as to where the money is coming from to pay for this? Yeah. So these funds were appropriated, I think it was fourth quarter 23-24, 22-23.
2:52:21 The reason that this is on here, so it's in the, what happens is when it's appropriate, it goes to a capital project, it's given an activity code, it's assigned to this specific item. The issue with this is the size of the invoice, so my signing authority goes up to $50,000 without, you know, consultation, but this is just saying, you authorize me to go ahead and move forward with it. So is it general fund, is it measure R, measure U, what's the color of the money? General fund on this one. It's general fund, okay, good.
2:52:51 That was my question. Thank you. Any other questions? I would entertain a motion. Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council authorize the Town Manager to execute an agreement with Zoom Research, Inc. for the purchase and installation of two shade structures in Mammoth Creek Park West in the amount of $93,381.22.
2:53:14 I will second that. Great. We have a motion and a second. Can you call the roll, please, Jamie? Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Potem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubser? Yes. All right. Now we have, I think we're up to 9.15, if I'm correct. Yeah, that's me also. Okay. And I need to recuse. Okay. Okay. Okay. Question on this one, which, Hayes, you kind of partially answered.
2:53:56 But I'm not sure that the full council and the public is aware of the negotiations the town had with the state's architecture office, you know, that that is settled, I guess, to a degree such that it's appropriate now to be authorizing a contract with a design firm to start doing things. I just wanted to see if you could just articulate, share where everything stands and that it is indeed appropriate to start investing money in this project now.
2:54:25 Yeah, thank you, John. So the short answer, yes, we do believe it's appropriate to start investing in this project. As far as the history, when, you know, there was, again, like I said in my previous presentation, there has been a transition period where, you know, the foundations project, foundations land, they were working on it. We became a partner, started helping them out, and over time we have slowly taken over the project and soon will own the land, own the building.
2:54:51 Own the project, maintain, operate, so forth, which has changed the nature of our relationship with the planning effort. We learned that there may be an issue with Division of State Architect and a desire for that to be a school building. We had to go through a process to work with the state.
2:55:08 Worked with KCCD and a number of partners to ensure that if that was the case, we were doing the appropriate things, or if it was not the case, that we had the appropriate letters and information in front of us so we didn't get in trouble for not doing something that we should have. We've received the letters, we've received the communication, we believe we're in a good spot, everything has been shored up, and we feel like we're in a good spot to move forward and get this project back on track and get it ready for construction.
2:55:38 There's a number of parallel tracks that are occurring, but this effort secures the architectural team to work on our behalf to finish up the design, to prepare the bid documents, and to shepherd us through construction. So you're satisfied, the town is satisfied, all that bureaucratic stuff with the Office of Art, all that stuff is settled, it's in writing, we're good to go? I think we're close on that, right? We've got some things moving back and forth.
2:56:05 Yeah, so we've received confirmation from KCCD that was sent to DSA. We received an initial response from DSA saying, looks good. They're going to send us a formal letter, but we have a level of comfort. We've been meeting with them regularly, so we know we're comfortable moving forward. Okay. I just wanted to add one thing to this space. So the creativity of coming up with this solution and this process by which we've been able to get these approvals was...
2:56:30 Was all internal with Hayes and team just kind of saying, how do we solve this problem? Because the entities that, you know, had them were sort of waiting for someone to step in and provide that guidance and direction. And so outlining the entire plan, executed it. And so we're in a good space because of that effort. So I think we all look forward to you bringing forward and celebrating the genius and the creativity of your staff. We do that every day. Okay. So that was my question. So I'm prepared to make a motion.
2:56:59 I would move that the Town Council authorize the Town Manager to finalize scope and fee negotiations and execute an agreement with HMC Architects for architectural consultant design and construction administration services for the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center and to execute amendments to the contract as necessary to advance project developments as authorized by the Town Council. Second. All right, Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Salzer? Yep.
2:57:26 Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubser? Yes. We need to go get Councilmember Truax. Thank you, Madam Mayor for indulging me in those. Certainly. Thank you. Absolutely. So, let's see. When he arrives, come on, Councilmember Truax. Yeah. All right. Item 10.1.
2:57:57 We are going to hold a public hearing. Madam Mayor, I have an existing conflict with this item, and I need to recuse myself from this conversation. All right. Enjoy your time in the penalty box. We weren't thinking. Okay. So this item, 10.1, is to consider approval of District Zoning Amendment 24001, Use Permit 24004, Intentative Track Map.
2:58:28 24-03 for a subsequent amendment to the amended Phase 1 Clearwater Specific Plan located at 164 Old Mammoth Road to modify the permitted uses for the amendment Phase 1 CSP by adding condominium hotel uses subjected to a use permit and subdivision map approval. The application includes a tentative track map for the subdivision of 20 units within the five four-plex structures into condominium hotel units that may be sold individually.
2:58:56 The project was previously analyzed pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA, in the 2021 addendum to the Clearwater Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report. So first I will open the public hearing and then we will have presentation by staff. Thank you, Mayor Busber.
2:59:17 And council members, so the public hearing before you today is for the outbound hotel villas project. The entitlement application includes three different application types. We have a district zoning amendment, a use permit, and tentative track map. The project site encompasses approximately six acres and is located within the Clearwater Specific Plan zoning district. The Clearwater Specific Plan
2:59:46 establishes land use guidelines and development standards for the area covered within the CSP. And the CSP document in its vision and goal section, it includes a statement that the Clearwater specific plan is intended to allow for a pedestrian oriented mixed use corridor along Old Mammoth Road.
3:00:10 The plan provides for a blend of retail, condominium, hotel, and conference uses, in addition to plaza area that provides a venue for a variety of community activities and events. So to kind of go through the background on the entitlements for this property, the Clearwater specific plan was adopted, was first adopted by town council in January 2009, and this was for the development of a new pedestrian-oriented mixed-use
3:00:40 Resort destination development located in the North Old Mammoth Road District, and adoption of the CSP included approval of the final Clearwater Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report. Then later on in March of 2010, the Planning and Economic Development Commission approved a vesting tentative track map, use permit, and design review for a mixed-use project called Old Mammoth Place.
3:01:09 The Old Mammoth Place project entitlement approved up to 340 residential units with up to 488 lodging rooms. It included eight on-site workforce housing units, multiple outdoor public events plazas, approximately 20,000 square feet of commercial and retail space, 17,000 square feet of restaurant, about 9,500 square feet of conference space.
3:01:37 Additional spa and wellness center, an ice rink, a pool, and an underground parking garage that would cover the entire footprint of the site. So as part of the Old Mammoth Place project, the town approved a subsequent district zoning amendment in April of 2010 to clarify how building height was to be measured because all of the structures would be sitting on top of a parking garage.
3:02:05 Also to provide clarification on how fees would be charged for the entitled project. Then over approximately six years following the Old Mammoth Place project approval, the property owner was unable to obtain financing to construct the project. So in August of 2016, the owner obtained approval for amendments to the Clearwater Specific Plan, which included a 10-foot increase in building height.
3:02:34 An increase in net residential square footage and elimination of an on-site workforce housing requirement. At that point, a CEQA addendum to the CSP EIR was prepared and concluded that the proposed modifications were consistent with what was analyzed in the final EIR document. So continuing on the background, after approximately five years later,
3:03:04 In 2021, after the property was under new ownership, a new application was submitted to amend the CSP to establish interim development standards to serve as zoning for a phase one project within the CSP. The interim development standards accommodated a less intensive expansion and upgrade of the existing hotel, restaurant, and public spaces than was originally envisioned in the 2016 CSP.
3:03:34 The 2016 Old Mammoth Place project entitlement, while still allowing for the future development consistent with the, sorry, this was, this project in 2021 still allowed for the Old Mammoth Place project to occur subsequent to that approval. But shortly after that approval,
3:04:03 In 2021, the Planning and Economic Development Commission approved a major design review and use permit application on February 9, 2022 for the amended Phase 1 CSP project. This consisted of interior and exterior improvements to the existing 149-unit hotel and rafters restaurant, as well as construction of 30 new resort cabin units.
3:04:29 Including five four-plex villa structures and expanded event space and additional pedestrian-oriented amenities. The project also included seven on-site affordable housing units that were going to be located within the existing spa building. And that entitlement included a parking management plan.
3:04:53 Which included a valet program, and that was to allow a 15% reduction in the required number of parking spaces on the site. Construction of that approved project began in April of 2022, and it is nearing completion with several final requirements and conditions of approval that are required to be satisfied before a final certificate of occupancy can be issued. 2023 to present.
3:05:24 A temporary certificate of occupancy was issued in 2023, subject to a compliance agreement. In 2024, the construction of the Phase I CSP, like I said, was nearing completion. The final item here is that these outstanding items include the landscape installation and site improvements, including
3:05:52 Parking lot resurfacing and restriping and installation of permanent signage, all of which will be bonded for to ensure completion prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy and prior to scheduling a second reading with Town Council if Town Council approves this application.
3:06:14 So the proposed project is to convert 20 of the existing hotel accommodation units located within the five fourplex structures referred to as villas into condominium hotel units which may be sold individually. The required applications to accomplish the proposed project include the district zoning amendment.
3:06:34 And this is to modify the permitted uses by adding condominium hotel uses subject to a use permit and subdivision map approval. The proposed DZA language includes a definition for condominium hotel uses, adds development and operating standards applicable to condominium hotels, and removes language that previously excluded condominium hotel uses from the amended Phase 1 CSP.
3:07:04 There were additional minor text revisions that were intended to provide clarity for the reader. A use permit is included with this entitlement application to allow the proposed condominium hotel use, which aligns with the 2016 CSP land use permit requirements and allows the town to require conditions of approval for the use, such as minimum operating standards.
3:07:29 Finally, a tentative track map is included for this proposed subdivision. The proposed lot configuration shown here on the right-hand side of the page, it creates a separate condominium owner's lot labeled lot one. This is for the condominium hotel component of the site and the remainder resort owner lot.
3:07:55 Includes required easements that are noted for shared access, parking, snow storage, trash enclosure, utilities, and other shared facilities. The final easement language and configuration will be completed through a reciprocal easement agreement, which is subject to review and approval by town staff prior to final map approval.
3:08:21 Because there wasn't any additional development proposed with this project, the primary analysis that was done was to ensure that the improvements would be consistent with the Clearwater Specific Plan and the General Plan. So the 2021 amended Phase 1 CSP document specifies that the standards
3:08:47 Shall only apply to the amended phase one project and any future redevelopment of the site following completion of the amended phase one project will be subject to the standards in the 2016 Clearwater Specific Plan regulatory document. Since the district zoning amendment application is only applicable to the amended phase one CSP document, staff considered the location of the proposed condominium hotel use in the context of the 2016 CSP document.
3:09:15 As well to ensure that the location of the land use was consistent with the designations that will apply to this property in the future. So there are three land use designations applicable to the CSP depicted in this figure. The proposed villa subdivision is located in land use area two, which is designated for condominium hotel. So it is consistent with that location that will apply in the future to the site.
3:09:48 And this figure is just showing the existing development, the location of the villa structures on the left-hand side, and the location of land use area 2 within the CSP document. So the required findings for approval have been drafted by staff, which is required for approval of the application. I did want to touch on the proposed
3:10:21 Well, the consistency analysis with CEQA. The CEQA process for this application did include SB18 tribal consultation. The SB18 law requires local governments to initiate consultation with California Native American tribes when a project creates or amends a general or specific plan.
3:10:46 And since this project amends a specific plan, we did follow the SB18 tribal consultation process by sending letters inviting tribal consultation and project review to all tribes that are included on the contact list, which is provided by the Native American Heritage Commission.
3:11:07 There is a required 90-day period for Native American tribes to request consultation, and this period ended November 29, 2024, and staff did not receive any requests for consultation. So that concluded the consultation process. The scope of the outbound villas project is also within the scope of the amended Phase 1 CSP project, which was analyzed in the 2021 addendum to the final CSPCA.
3:11:37 And the revised project was found not to result in any additional land use impacts that were not previously considered and addressed in the 2021 addendum. The project was routed to other agencies within the town, including the Mammoth Community Water District and the Mammoth Lakes Fire District.
3:12:05 We did include one condition of approval in response to a comment from the Mammoth Community Water District which was to require all of the units to be independently metered for water service. Staff also received two written comment letters prior to the PEDC public hearing and the PEDC considered those comments prior to making their decision to recommend approval to the
3:12:35 So we did hold two public hearings with the Planning and Economic Development Commission. The first public hearing resulted in a no action vote. That was a two to one vote in favor to move the project forward. So we had to hold another notice public hearing, which we held on February 12, 2025. And that hearing concluded in a three one vote to recommend approval of the project to town council.
3:13:10 Staff's recommendation now is that Town Council waive the first reading and introduce by title only an ordinance making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving District Zoning Amendment 24-001 and adopt the attached resolution making the required CEQA, Subdivision Map Act and Municipal Code findings.
3:13:35 Approving tentative track map and use permit with conditions as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission. And that concludes my presentation. I know that the applicant's representatives are here. If you have any questions for the applicant, I will stop. I would like to clarify one aspect of the recommendation. I would suggest that the council's approval of the resolution be contingent upon the ordinance taking effect.
3:14:02 Because there is a period of time between now and the second reading and a period of time between the second reading and the effective date of the ordinance. And for procedural reasons, the resolution should not take effect until the ordinance has taken effect. So if you could just consider that as part of the recommendation. Thank you. It does say in my workflow that
3:14:28 If the owner or applicant wants to make a statement, they're able to do so now before questions. So is that something that was planned or should we just go ahead of questions? I would ask the applicant if they want to make a statement. Well, yeah. Whatever. Good evening. Good evening. My name is Matt Merring. I'm a principal with Waterton who's the owner of the outbound Mammoth property.
3:14:55 Thanks, Kim, for providing some context. I just wanted to highlight a couple things, and I'll keep it brief because I'm reading the room a little bit here. But what we're proposing here doesn't change the vision or the end product of what was built. We're simply asking to adjust the financial structure, and this adjustment really puts us on equal footing with many of our competitors who have incorporated condo hotel structures into their developments. We've also ensured that we maintain the flexibility for larger
3:15:25 Future development, which led us to amend the Clearwater Specific Plan so we could preserve that option. The 20 units only take up about two acres of the site, so there's still over four acres down the road. Either us or someone else could develop, which under the Clearwater Plan would allow for almost 340 units. So there's still, you know, we're not shutting the door on a larger development down the road by, you know, going down this path.
3:15:54 Kim alluded to, you know, the scope of what we've done in the project, but we've made a, you know, very significant investment in this property, as you all know. You know, we renovated all 150 existing rooms. We had 30 additional rooms. We built a new pool, spa area, built workforce housing, and did a pretty comprehensive, you know, reimagining of the site plan, including a gathering space on Old Mammoth.
3:16:23 Got rid of the famous mini golf course that I'm sure everyone misses in town. But, you know, we feel this investment has been a win for everyone involved. You know, it's not only revitalized and activated to keep property at an important intersection of Mammoth, but it's also generating increased, you know, TOT revenue for the town. In fact, we project once the property stabilizes in 2027, 2028.
3:16:50 The repositioned property will increase taxable room revenues by almost $8 million over, you know, 2019, which is kind of the year before we took over ownership. So, you know, when we originally, you know, built these, designed, built these 20 units, you know, the thought was we wanted to offer larger residential style spaces, kind of creating a unique product that could compete with the short-term rental market in town.
3:17:17 As the units started coming online, a lot of locals started driving up and asking us when we were going to sell the units, which really wasn't something we had contemplated initially. After it happened four or five times, I felt the universe was speaking to us a little bit. So we went and we consulted some local appropriate firms and basically wanted to gauge demand for if we did decide to sell these as condo hotels, what that would look like.
3:17:45 And the feedback was really clear. You know, the feedback was these units would be highly sought after, especially because they're a new product with resort style amenities. It's an approachable price point. They'll be averaged somewhere around $700,000 a unit. So we decided at that point to shift gears. You know, but ultimately, you know, why are we here today with this ask? You know, simply put,
3:18:09 You know, we've encountered some pretty significant, you know, unforeseen cost overruns through the development. The major factor of this was the winter of 2022-2023, which brought 800 inches of snow to the mountain, which was, you know, great for the ski hill, not great for development, right? So it pushed our timeline back, our construction timeline back by six months. As anyone who's familiar with construction knows, delays equal added costs. It also pushed back our opening.
3:18:38 Which is pretty material in a market like Mammoth where, you know, it's a seasonal and they have limited amounts to generate revenue. So, and I will add, you know, we're no strangers to resort development in mountain towns. We have properties in Sedona, Stowe, Vermont, Jackson. We've got a development going out at the south gate of Yosemite. But I will say Mammoth, the winter of 2022, 2023, Mammoth is something that no one, you know, could have underwritten or predicted.
3:19:07 But that was the main driver of some of the cost overruns that we've encountered. But just to conclude things, this condo-hotel model we're proposing puts us on track to achieve long-term stability, ensure we remain competitive in the market. The structure won't have a material impact on transient revenue or the associated TOT taxes that go with that because units will be in the rental pool when they're not being occupied by owners.
3:19:37 And, you know, I think moreover the end use of the property remains unchanged. You know, the clear water specific land still allows for potential for larger development, you know, someday in the future. So with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions. Thank you. Questions? I have questions for staff. Okay, go ahead. I think it's questions for anyone at this point, right? Okay, so this recommendation came to us from the Planning Commission, correct? Correct.
3:20:08 And do you know what the final vote tally was at the Planning Commission? It was 3-1, and we had one commissioner recused from that meeting. Okay. So my questions really have to do with the legacy, and Kimi did a very nice job of, like, articulating the various phases that this particular property's been through. The...
3:20:32 The original proposal by Mr. Demetriatus and that project was quite controversial in the community. That was happening during the height. I think we had 21 major development projects happening. This is 2007 in that era. So if we move forward with approving what's being proposed this evening, what happens to the development agreement and what happens to all of the
3:21:02 You know, modifications were made to the specific plan to allow for height, to allow, is all that stuff still in place and still in effect? So the Old Mammoth Place entitlement was revoked when the amended Phase 1 project was approved in 2021. So the resolution for approval included revocation of the vesting tentative track map.
3:21:26 The use permit and the design review. So the old Mammoth Place project is no longer entitled. Okay. But the Clearwater specific plan that was approved, the version that was approved in 2016, would be in effect for any future development projects proposed on the site. Okay. So if condominiums are built, meaning that now there's a variety of ownership parties involved in this.
3:21:55 If someone is a developer now in a position where they can only reasonably be thinking about developing the balance of the property without too much trouble as opposed to I'm thinking that having these ownership units is going to be an impediment to getting to what could be possible under that Clearwater specific plan. Could you speak to that a little bit?
3:22:23 Yeah, we did work with the applicant pretty extensively to make sure that the owners of the condominium units couldn't prevent a future redevelopment of the larger site. And so the language that was going to be included in the reciprocal easement agreement was going to ensure that the condominium property could function as its own sort of lot and that the
3:22:51 Reciprocal easement agreement would ensure that any reconfiguration of parking areas would always account for the required parking for those condominium units. So for instance, if they developed understructure parking in the future, they would have to provide the 21 units of parking that's required for these condominium units within that structure. So we did work on that, and I think working with Public Works on the language,
3:23:21 We came to a level where we were comfortable that the different ownership wasn't going to be an impediment to future redevelopment of the site. Okay, well, if these two nice young gentlemen, let's say they get a Powerball ticket and they have three or four hundred million dollars and they're going back and they're looking at this lot in this specific plan, could we find ourselves back in a position where we were back?
3:23:47 With the Demetriatus Project, even though that's been revoked, but we could theoretically get back into those types of conversations, and they would be a question for someone to buy out the condo owners and do, they could do all that kind of stuff, and we could be back kind of where we were a while ago. Is that fair to say? I think so. Can I ask a clarifying question? Because I thought that this took that six-acre parcel and subdivided it permanently, so there's only four acres left.
3:24:20 So I think John was saying that it would be possible in the future if a developer bought out the owners of the condominiums that the whole site could potentially. That's theoretical. It probably won't happen. It probably would be a redevelopment of the balance. But it's possible.
3:24:38 If they won the lottery. Well, it's, and we all buy tickets, you know, but what the point is, is that that Clearwater, the specific plan is still in place. Exactly, yeah. But all those amendments that were made as part of the entitlements to Mr. Demetriatus, those have been rescinded and those are no longer there. No, those are still in place because the 2016 Clearwater Specific Plan reflected those amendments.
3:25:06 That were intended to make the Old Mammoth Place project more feasible. So those still stand. Okay, so tell me, what was the thing that was rescinded? You mentioned something that was rescinded. So the, let me pull up, I think it was... It was the entitlements for that project. Yes. The map for that project. Okay. So that ghost of a project no longer has any entitlements, but the specific plan itself still contains provisions that were inserted.
3:25:34 to accommodate that project. And would Council have any authority, or the Planning Commission having any authority over that, or are those changes to the specific plan in there and we can't do anything about those? Well, the specific plan can always be amended. Okay. But I have a feeling that if the developers were to come at some point and say they wanted to scrape the site, except for the condos, it would probably require some amendments to the specific plan to reflect that new vision at the time, I think.
3:26:03 Okay, because I just, I want to make clear that that project, I don't know how familiar you guys are with that, but that was an extremely controversial and difficult project to work through, to process, and I think it is, I would, just speaking as one council member, is not the desire of the community to construct the type of thing that was being proposed. And it's not financial, I mean.
3:26:30 To be honest, it's not financeable. Okay, I'm just, I'm just like, whether, again, there is the Powerball, you know, big numbers. I'm just letting you know that that. If I win the Powerball, I'm head of the Caribbean and gonna. Okay, well, good. Oh, good, good to know. But just, you know, if something like that were to come back, that would not, I would not anticipate an easy, an easy stroll with that.
3:26:55 I think Councilmember Sauser had a clarifying question. Going on your line, I have my own line here in a minute. Sure. But with the Clearwater Specific Plan, if they scraped everything else but these 20 units, then the number of units allowed on the rest of that lot would be decreased by the 20. No, it would be by the two-acre entitlement because those acres are gone. Right? I would point out, so the Clearwater Specific Plan, that was a...
3:27:23 It's a specific plan. It was adopted through a district zoning amendment that didn't, the specific plan on its own doesn't create or allow a project. It just defined the framework for what could be developed on that site. So it established the density, the setbacks, the height, the parking requirements, all the other development standards that any future project would be subject to. Then the old Mammoth Place project was designed based on those development standards in that 2016 amendments. That was
3:27:50 The project that came out of that specific plan vision. The 2021 interim plan created, I might butcher the name, but the interim amended phase one plan, which created an additional set of development standards, which then the plan that was built with the villas and those was the project that came out of that, just out of those amendments to the specific plan. So the item B for you right now is a
3:28:19 Third Amendment or another amendment to the specific plan to add the allowance for condominium hotel uses, the project that then comes out of that amendment would be the tentative map and use permit to subdivide those units. Right. But even if you guys don't win the lottery, but you've got a project with certain entitlements, it could be sold to someone.
3:28:41 And what they would be looking at is what is in the Clearwater Specific Plan. And if they wanted to try to attempt to build some kind of a monstrosity, they would have the footprint within which to try to propose to do something like that. They would. And it would be correct that the density would be reduced by the 20 units because, again, that density was looked at for the entire site, which includes the remaining portion of the site plus this. But they could buy out the 20 units, scrape the whole thing.
3:29:10 They could go back. I just want to make sure we're all clear about that. The development, is there a development agreement in place? No. No, there's not. There's none of that? Okay. And then, and so the work that we all did on updating our nightly rental regulations, quality of life ordinances, and all that stuff, that's going to apply to all of these units in this project, correct?
3:29:39 It will. One of the requirements was that the units would be only occupied on a short-term basis. Okay. But there's no exemptions or anything. It's like point of contact. If they're going to be renting it, they've got to get a business permit and rob all the things we put together. All that stuff applies, right? Yes. Okay. All right. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Did I hear correctly that, and sorry, I want to make sure, but I want to clarify that.
3:30:11 It can only be short-term, so if someone wanted to buy this and then rent it out long-term, they couldn't do it? Correct. So only the owner, well, the owner can only occupy the unit short-term as well, so no longer than 30 days at a time. So that was written into one of the operation requirements that is proposed. 30 days at a time or 30 days in a year?
3:30:37 30 days at a time with no limitation on how many times they occupy their unit. That's an important distinction. It is. Yes. And I would clarify that the thought process behind that, you know, everything else we talk about is long-term housing and how to provide additional housing for the residents. However, in this project, it was a key component in providing hotbeds for the community, hotbed hotel rooms. Was it
3:31:08 A key factor of the Clearwater Specific Plan and just the vision and the zoning documents for the downtown area. So that was codified or proposed in the documents that they would have that stipulation. Okay. Thank you. Do you have any questions, Mayor Pro Tem? So I have several questions along the lines of occupancy.
3:31:34 Is there something in the, what the proposed new CC&Rs would be, because that's what it would be, it's a condo project stand-alone, is there something in there that requires them to rent on a short-term basis? Or is there just the, they can't occupy it for, you know, more than 350 days a year with two days in between each 30-day stay? There's not something in there that requires the units to be rented. We've had extensive conversations with the developers, very sophisticated legal team.
3:32:06 about the restrictions that we can and cannot require for the operation of the units. And we think that where we've ended up is kind of about what we can do. We can't force them to use a centralized reservation system. We can't force them to rent the units. What we've come up with is intended to maintain those hotbeds as much as possible. They're not really designed nor intended for permanent occupancy by the owners or really by anybody else on a long-term basis.
3:32:33 We're trying to strike a balance between allowing the owners to use them, but doing everything we can to encourage them to be short-term rented. I think that's how I would say that. If the developer or Mr. Kearney have any additional thoughts, certainly they can chime in. But ultimately, in a matter of years, each one of those 20 units could have a separate management company, be rented by the night or not.
3:32:58 One of the reasons that I really supported this project in the first place, and we talked about it back then, was that they would be hotbed units, which changes the marketing and everything else. If you lose the income from those 20 units, which you very well may do, then marketing those units becomes different. Your focus changes because you've lost that income, and that worries me some. We don't...
3:33:25 Have that guarantee that it's any longer going to be used as a hotel property. Yeah. And Chris, if you're on as well, if I misspeak, please jump in here. Sure. On that point, as far as transient hotbeds and whatnot, what we can do as far as state regulations in forcing people to list them as rental units, we can't do that, obviously. But what we can do is through the
3:33:56 Kind of the management agreement of the condominiums, we can buy within the CC&Rs, force them to basically think if you think expenses as far as maintenance, upkeep, anything on that lines, that goes to the hotel manager, which is the larger manager of the larger property. Now then on the rental management agreement, excuse me, think revenue there.
3:34:20 We can basically provide the path of lease resistance. The point you brought up earlier as far as all the work that you and the staff have done on kind of the standards of occupation that you have, we are the best in the path of lease resistance in order to do that. They can go by and rent them on their own. They can go find their own management company, sure. However, they still have to go through those same hoops and go by those same regulations in order to list these units. Chris, do you want to chime in? Yeah. Thank you.
3:34:51 Chris Payne. I'm a partner with the law firm of Ballard's Bar. I'm based in Denver, and my practice is almost entirely working with resort communities, both in Colorado and elsewhere. Mayor Pro Tem Rice, this is a very important question, and the way that we have addressed it is twofold. Yes, the CC&Rs...
3:35:18 Require both the short-term transient occupancy, both by owners and by their guests of under maximum 30 days. There is also a requirement that when the unit is not occupied, that it be made available for the use by the general public. That's sort of, again, trying to get to that point of can't force somebody to rent, but you have to make it available for use by the general public.
3:35:46 And then to the following point, we have a provision that requires all owners to use the property management as distinct from rental management, but must use a single property manager, meaning the hotel. So we maintain standards, we maintain check-in, we maintain security, and to that point, we remain at the incentive for the hotel to make sure that that property is managed like the rest of the hotel.
3:36:15 Yes, we can't stop a third-party rental manager from providing a better deal, but to the point we can make every path of least resistance in place to encourage those owners to use the hotel for rental opportunities, and we can require them to use the hotel for property management activities.
3:36:44 How does that work once all 20 units are sold? You've got a homeowners association who can vote to change management companies. How legally can you then force them not to change that? Do you maintain a majority vote on the HOA? And if so, how can you do that without actually owning any of the property? Chris? Yes. Understood. This is in the CC&Rs.
3:37:13 And the CC&Rs cannot be amended without the resort owner vote. And to recognize again that the resort owner is also party to the reciprocal easement agreement where there's a similar requirement. Andy, can you weigh in on that for me? Can the resort require these independently owned? I understand it's in the current CC&R, but once all the units are sold,
3:37:47 So the majority vote is then with that majority, with the owners. Could they then change management companies in total? No. As Mr. Payne was explaining, the CC&Rs have been set up in a very clever way to sharply restrict what the owners can do to amend the CC&Rs. There are some parts of it that simply cannot be amended without the involvement of the larger property owner, even if all the unit owners wanted to change management companies.
3:38:15 It would require an amendment to the CCNRs to do that, which they can't do without the hotel. We had extensive discussions and negotiations with the developer's team, and I was skeptical at first, but Mr. Payne and Mr. Carney convinced me that this can be done, and this really is a valid approach. They're very restrictive CCNRs. So a follow-up question to that, do these restrictions go with the property? So if the property is sold, then what happens?
3:38:46 The restrictions go with the property, as you say. They will go with the property. Yes. Okay. Any questions? I guess I just kind of wanted to understand, you know, like the employee housing requirements, like have they met those from previous, you know, like the Clearwater Pacific Plan, have they met those requirements and like would there have been a large cost difference if they had initially come to the town and
3:39:21 Submitted these plans or, you know, gotten it rezoned beforehand. Like ask for permission instead of asking for forgiveness. You did read the letter. I did. I can read, Bill. So I think the answer is no. The amended phase one project entitlement.
3:39:46 Approved the seven on-site affordable housing units for employees of the hotel. And so those have been constructed. And I don't think the final certificate of occupancy is issued yet. But that is one of the kind of final requirements that need to be completed for final certificate of occupancy. But there would not have been a difference in the
3:40:13 Number of units provided if these were considered hotel rooms versus condominium hotel units. It's the same number of accommodation rooms. And would you have, like, would we have had other requirements that they haven't fulfilled or, you know, like with parking or snow storage or, you know, like is this going to open the door for other developers to do this as well or I don't know, like what are we, what are some potential
3:40:43 So the parking requirement for condominium hotel units is specified within the 2016 Clearwater specific plan. It is one parking space per room, accommodation room, and then one guest space for every 20 accommodation rooms. So 21 spaces would be required for these units. That would have been the same if these were considered hotel accommodation units.
3:41:12 So I don't see an issue with parking other than the fact that any future developer, if they want to reconfigure the parking areas, need to provide for the parking for the condominium units. And snow storage, they have a recorded snow storage removal covenant for the property.
3:41:36 It applies to the entire property, including the areas around the villa units. And so that is recorded. And it's on the title. And I think that would probably be updated as part of the reciprocal easement agreement. Okay. Thank you. And I think just to follow up on that, that none of, you know, the second reading of this will not take place until the final conditions of the certificate of occupancy are met.
3:42:04 The COO is issued, so everything is clean and good, and that's only at that point will the second meeting come back for approval. Other questions? I'm good. I'm good. Other? Okay. Do you have questions for us? Not really. I feel like you all did such a good job of asking them. I guess really just for staff, we did get some public comment about the fact that it was very important for
3:42:39 These separate units to be maintained in a way that is in keeping with the public facing nature of the location. So you've addressed it, but is there anything else you want to add to really assuage those fears? Sure. So with the use permit, approving the condominium hotel use, we included
3:43:06 In the amendment to the CSP, the development standards that apply to condominium hotel uses that was included in the 2016 CSP that didn't carry over to this amended phase one CSP. So we added that, those development standards in this amendment and included them as a condition of approval within that use permit entitlement. So that would ensure that
3:43:34 You know, it's every condominium hotel unit, they're providing standardized room fixtures, and they have on-call, there's a list, it's a pretty long list of things that they have to be provided. So they have to have a central front desk lobby, telephone connections to all hotel rooms with staff available 24 hours a day, check-in spaces for arriving vehicles.
3:44:02 Standardized furniture fixtures and equipment in all rooms. So I think this speaks to the maintenance of those units to that hotel standard. Thank you. I just wanted to make sure we aired that. So with that, if there are no other questions. Just one, just one, just again to restate. All of this structure goes with the property. Yes, that's correct. Okay. Okay. So then,
3:44:32 I would take public comment if there's anyone in the room who would like to give comment now or anyone on the phone. Now, okay. All right, then we are closing the public hearing. And now, deliberation. I'm prepared to make a motion, but I don't want to do that. Okay, I would move, Madam Mayor, that the Town Council waive the first reading introduced by title only and ordinance.
3:45:01 Making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving District Zoning Amendment 24-001 and adopt the resolution making the required CEQA Subdivision Map Act and Municipal Code findings and approving tentative track map 24-003 and use permit 24-004 with conditions as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission. And just to clarify, this goes back to language you mentioned before that.
3:45:30 The second reading will not happen until terms and conditions of the certificate of occupancy have been satisfied and that COO has been issued. Correct. Okay. So that's the motion. And did that, Andy, did that cover your contingent upon the ordinance taking effect? It did not, but I was wondering if you might care to amend your motion to include having the adoption of the resolution, having the effectiveness of the resolution be contingent upon the effectiveness of the ordinance. So amended.
3:46:01 Jamie, is that okay? Yeah. Okay. I'll second. Great. Thank you. So, Jamie, if you could please call the roll. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Whiteworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubser? Yes. Thank you. All right. We will get Mr. Penalty Box back. Don't worry, Andy, I'll never leave you hanging. You go raid the refrigerator back there. There's drinks.
3:46:40 The one in the back where Bill always goes. All right. Moving right along, item 11.1, policy matters. This is a matter about staff adjustments for mid-year, fiscal year 24-25. Mayor Bobster, thank you. Yeah, so from time to time, as things adjust throughout the fiscal year, staffing changes are needed to address either circumstances that arise
3:47:13 Or more optimal staffing solutions that we think will satisfy, will help us deliver our core services. In this particular case, I've got a couple of areas to talk about, and I don't have anything to present. I just, I'm sorry, just don't have any presentation. I'm just going to talk through some of these key areas. I will say, in total, these recommended adjustments add two temporary positions.
3:47:42 For the rest of this calendar year, we'll have a total impact of 177,800 for year one, and then an annual ongoing of approximately 11,000. The reason for the steep difference is the temporary positions are about 161,000 of those amounts.
3:48:11 So I'll walk through that and kind of highlight those areas. First and foremost, the Public Works Fleet Organization. So we went through with Public Works a couple of years ago a reorganization of that and restructuring of that organization to really streamline the work efforts out there. Over the last, I'd say, 12 to 18 months, we've been doing a lot of work in the fleet, putting new systems in place, new inventory processes.
3:48:40 New documentation for work that's completed and that has been done. What we're faced with is we have a long-term 25-year employee, Lon Adams, who is planning on a retirement in December of 2025 and we would like to make a recommendation that we put the fleet in the same structure that it will have after his retirement and that we utilize Lon's time.
3:49:08 with us as a mentor for other mechanics on the floor as well as a transitional employee for new management that's going to go in and step into his place. So we basically put together the organization and the only extra time would be Lon Adams for the year and then we would have that full structure developed. A couple of other key aspects to this are
3:49:35 You know, right now we've had a little bit of a hybrid between the gentleman who will be taking the manager role in that space, spending some time in that capacity as well as turning wrenches as a mechanic. Probably the bulk of the time has been in more of the admin world. So when this promotion occurs, that will actually clear up an entire mechanic position and that will be filled by a normal recruitment process.
3:50:03 We also have a couple of mechanic trainees, and we would like to promote one of those mechanic trainees to a full-time mechanic. So we do have a net gain, not only in just a position that's going to be full-time mechanic and working in that space, but the elevation of duties and responsibilities of the trainee. That one in total, I have an estimate in the staff report of $150,000 for the calendar year of that cost.
3:50:31 But we really think it will do a great job of first and foremost recognizing the value of Lon and his capacity to teach and train and mentor folks that are sort of developing new in their career or new into the mechanics career with his experience of how things have been. We just don't have that capacity as busy as the crew is out there. They don't have a lot of training time. They really have a lot of doing time. And so this will free up that process.
3:51:01 It will also ensure a really smooth transition for us and I think really kind of honoring Lon for his commitment to the town for 25 years in a really good way to have a meaningful legacy impact on that organization. So I think it's a win all the way around and it's a good morale booster but it's also just a really effective way of transitioning something and so we're investing in that space to transition that appropriately. Office of Outdoor Recreation organizational updates.
3:51:31 This organization, as you know, has been stood up in 2022. And it's a bit of an evolution from the trails manager position, which was one position, with a whole lot of duties that we're adding on for things like you heard tonight from Lawson, right? Engagement with other areas like wildfire.
3:51:51 Convening groups, bringing people together, having these discussions, liaisoning with the Forest Service, liaisoning with third parties on collaborative projects, those types of things. So really an expansion of that process. We also have the trails program manager, which is right now sort of a hybrid modification of the original trails manager position, but it's been doing a little bit different work in that space.
3:52:19 And what has happened, as you know, we've taken on a lot more work. That has really been more in the implementation side. Andrew's doing a great job, but he's doing a whole lot more on the landscape than the previous roles have, right? He leads the maintenance crews on the summertime, a ton of tree and vegetation clearing. We received a request just the other day from the Forest Service to...
3:52:47 Deal with trails that are even outside in the wilderness boundaries areas as part of the federal government challenges that we have. And just we have so much to do on that. We've got a grooming program that has been stood up and we really want to see those things grow and blossom. And so what has happened is in that space with all that work.
3:53:06 Lawson has sort of worked a lot in the background on the trail side of things to maintain that and make sure there's a continuity of that effort and it works really well. At the same time, we have an employee there who is an outdoor recreation coordinator position and she is doing a phenomenal job of managing the outreach, the host programs and all of those things. What I'm proposing here is to elevate
3:53:36 That position to a manager-level position and sort of bifurcate the trail system project into two. One of management of the contract with our contractors that provide services on the trail system, management of the maintenance programs, right? There's a whole system built for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System that has to be managed from a, I'm going to say, paper side.
3:54:03 Versus implementation side. And that's what we're bifurcating and separating those two pieces. She would retain the host program. In fact, we're augmenting that a little bit. This year, I have a supervisor position or a lead host position that's going to be more leadership on weekends and in spaces like that that will help the service delivery, help the experience for the visitors quite a bit. And I think it's just a right move to
3:54:32 Invest resources in that space to make sure that that system is working excellent. What we're also doing at the same time is in pushing Lawson out of that space, right? We want to elevate him to the work that needs to be done in the collaborative space. And so that's a lot of what you've been seeing in the last couple of months with those efforts. And so this is a little bit of an investment. It's probably
3:54:54 To the tune of around $7,000 a year, and that would be annual and ongoing as we go through that process as the delta between where it is now and what it would be. The other recommendation is with an admin coordinator position. We do have an assistant clerk with the town, and Angie, she does a phenomenal job in that space. She has capacity. She has drive.
3:55:24 She has a little sign on her wall that says, every day I'm hustling. And that's no doubt, she really, really does a great job. We also have a strong need for some project management support in the town manager's office. And right now, we have Pam Kobylarz, who's the assistant to the town manager, who is designated to be in that capacity, but has a lot of daily assignments that keep, kind of lower the availability of time.
3:55:53 And so with this elevation of Angie's position to an administrative coordinator broadens her scope. We've kind of tailored the job description and really matched her strengths to be a presence for the administrative organization to the town. And we think it will work really, really well to relieve some of that and add capacity for project management. That will help me personally because that's really where things kind of land. Ultimately, everything goes through the town manager's office to some degree.
3:56:23 When it's a special project. And so this is going to help quite a bit. This has a cost of about $5,000 a year, and that is annual and ongoing. And finally, as we've been talking about where the town can assist the federal partners in making sure the visitor experience is on par with expectations and what they have been in the past, that would be to fulfill what U.S. Forest Service recreation technician position would have been, which is cleaning restrooms, taking trash out, and monitoring that process.
3:56:53 This would be a temporary maintenance worker one position with the town of Mammoth Lakes, and we would then receive a work plan from the forest to execute those. So it would be our employee managed by Lawson and working on the forest services aspect. That's going to cost roughly $15,000 to $17,000. I only have it in for one year, and that's associated with the fact that we hope the
3:57:21 All challenges that we're facing sort of begin to resolve themselves by next summer. This is a seasonal position that works. There is a recreation technician on the INYO, which is a position that will still service areas outside of town, and this one will focus in town, lake space, and those types of things. So as I said earlier, you know, all told about $177,000 for year one. We do have salary savings, ironically, by not having a finance director.
3:57:49 For a year, that saves a little bit of money, as well as some other positions that are simply vacant. We have several vacant positions that are there. So cost-wise, really neutral. Annual ongoing, which is one of the questions out there, fairly minimal. But I think this will have a pretty good approach. And then just a little bit of a foresight into where I'm thinking for, you know, the coming budget.
3:58:14 We have invested quite a bit in the last year in employees. We are not, I will likely not have a strong request in the budget process to add any staff. As you know, we pride ourselves in being a very lean organization, and we will probably continue to do that and just be wary of the horizon, if you will, in that space. That's one of the areas we're concerned about when you add staff, you're adding those commitments for long term.
3:58:42 So happy to answer any questions that you may have. Go ahead. A couple different questions. I'll start reverse-wise. I believe the request that we got from the Forest Service was for two tech positions and I was suggesting one. Is there a reason why we're not advocating for two? I've only ever heard for one. Am I mistaken in the meeting? I thought we had just spoken in this meeting here that we said that they were looking for two. Am I wrong?
3:59:11 The only thing I would know about that is that I think in the past it was a pair of people that were cleaning the bathrooms in the Lakes Basin. But I don't know how that was structured and how that was put together. But I mean, I have a cautionary concern on that because, you know, what I'm hearing again anecdotally from Forest Service folks is forestry, no problem. The president wants to reestablish.
3:59:41 A lumber industry in the United States. So forest service staff, they're working the forestry side, not a problem. Rec, see you later. The forestry folks are saying, yeah, we're there, we have to clean our own toilets. I mean, that's, they're having to clean their own toilets. So I would, I mean, it's fine to start with the first season. Let's kind of see how this goes. But again, your goal that maintain level of service, we may have to make adjustments. We'll just have to see how it goes. Yeah, we're going to be dynamic. That's kind of my point is that.
4:00:11 You're talking about not potentially adding staff and budget, but I still want to maintain that flexibility because I'll start overall. I just want to make sure one, is enough to start with. Two, I like where you're headed in terms of, as our discussion here, in terms of your availability, Rob, to respond to things that are coming forward. I like the availability to take some of that and project management that may be in your plate and others to free you up because I still believe we are going to be tackling some things going forward. And I like that.
4:00:40 I want to be careful because, in my opinion, it's your staff to run to a certain degree. I want to make sure it makes sense from an overall organizational standpoint and cost standpoint, but I'm also trying to make sure we're doing enough. And that's kind of a dual standard because we've always been very tight in how we do our budgeting and how we do our staffing. But I also don't want to get caught down the road and not have the staff there to do what we need to have done.
4:01:08 Yeah, and I appreciate that because you're right. I mean, we can drive ourselves into the ground at some point. But with regard to the Forest Service, you know, we coordinate with the District Ranger on what they think they need. And as I said before, the two, one full is still available for them. So that position still exists within the Forest Service. So we're dynamic. We can react pretty quickly to things that may come up. But this is what we see as the needs for right now.
4:01:40 That's all I have. Question? No, I'm good. I'm good with the moves. I'm good. I think we are flexible and dynamic enough to meet any changing need. You know, we can always come back and do what's necessary when it's necessary. Yeah, and I think if I go through these things, I think the Public Works thing, that move makes sense. On the Office of Outdoor Recreation, I go back to working with Dan. I think, Bill, you may have been involved in those conversations as well. I think the vision always,
4:02:10 Was to have in place capacity for the town manager to address the kinds of things we're getting into now. They weren't in front of us, you know, six months ago. Here they are. I think it's a really good thing that we now have the ability to start with a department within the organization to start to reach out and address these things. So it's...
4:02:34 The circumstances are unfortunate, but I'm glad we got it, and I'm glad we can put that to good use. My question on the administrative side is that the individual you've identified also provide services under contract to the ESCOG and I think some other organizations, and I want to make sure that we're not going to be compromising that. The ESCOG, I think, in large degree to the
4:03:02 Support from the town and the other jurisdictions is taking on some pretty heavy lifting. Yeah. And they need that staff support. So I want to make sure that if there's a problem with that, let's address it. But let's not get jammed up with that situation. No, that's a great question. I'm glad you asked that. We are thinking about doubling the cost to those organizations. No, I'm kidding. We are going to maintain those efforts.
4:03:28 Do we get three times the service? Do we double the cost? You can get double the cost and half the service. Okay. Yeah. I am where I thought I was. Yeah. Thank you. Please. Town of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you. So no. So the one thing I will say will likely put a little bit more pressure on Jamie. Okay. On the clerk. But we don't have, we all work together on the development of that. And
4:03:53 And development of the expectations of that position is that that would be maintained. Because that's critical to have certainly not, if not the backup, but more pressure there. Yeah, because you know, Inyo County stepping into that in some ways I think you're probably aware of. So that's going to be a really critical thing as we go forward, especially start looking into an economic development district, which is going to be a critical part coming out of Jobs First.
4:04:20 And that's, so though, so as long as you're aware of that, take that as it comes, I think, similar conversation, I think, that Brent has is like, that's, and Bill mentioned, we're nimble, we can kind of deal with things, but again, that level of service and our ability to be a standout destination in California, and with all due respect, well, not, but just with the situation that Tom's going to have, all their campgrounds are going to be closed this summer. All those campgrounds are managed by the U.S. Forest Service, and the last I've heard is,
4:04:49 They will not be open. There are going to be a lot of perhaps unhappy disgruntled people that are going to be coming our way. And I think we want to make sure we're ready for that and we maintain our standards, our standard of excellence. And so we'll look forward to hearing from you and loss and others to make sure that we're meeting that burden. Any other questions? Any comment, public comment in the room or online?
4:05:16 Okay, you're just looking for consensus here. We don't have to vote, right? That's the way I read it in the, it didn't have a motion, it just said consensus. What? It says consensus in my packet. Yeah, so. Yeah, no, that's good. Thank you. So are we good? Is everyone good? You're good. I got a thumbs up. Did you get the feedback you need? I did. Did you hear that? We just gave the feedback. Are you good? We're not voting. I'm good. Okay. Great. I'm good. All right. Item 10, wait. Item 11.
4:05:46 Point two. Yes, thank you. Let me share my screen really quickly. Ms. Mahaffey's not going to give the presentation. What's that? The finance, the new finance director. No. Come on! Let's keep her for a few more days. Three whole days! You can do it!
4:06:10 Now you'd be shocked, John, if all of a sudden she walks up here and goes, I got this. Yeah. No, he wouldn't. I wouldn't be surprised. I know Megan. He would not be surprised. Yes. I'm not. No. So let's keep her around, okay? Let's not chase her out the door in day one. Okay. So budget presentations, you know, the good news, we talk about these quarterly.
4:06:34 Are pretty aggressive, I'm going to say, in the second quarter. As you know, when we adopt the budget, we are very, very conservative in our estimates in order to ensure that if calamity occurs, we are, you know, financially in a good position and our organization, as I said earlier, lean in this space. What that requires us to do is make very quick adjustments as the quarters end.
4:07:00 And so the second quarter adjustment has a couple of different aspects. I'll start with transient occupancy tax. And while it says in a lot of these spaces that it's through January 31, I want to clarify that the collection of tax occurs in the month subsequent to the actual stay. So what was collected in January is through the activity of December.
4:07:26 So this is very important to understand. I'll spend some time on transient occupancy tax for a second. The lodging measure L element takes effect January 1. We collected roughly $350,000 in January under that new tax. As you guys committed this in January, 100% of that is going to Housing Now initiatives.
4:07:52 And so it won't even go through the general fund and over there it just goes directly in that space. I am going to start to use terminology that says baseline TOT, which is the TOT that was generated from the original 13% charge and then the 2% is going to be the housing component. When I'm talking about this space, this is all baseline TOT.
4:08:13 And so it has, you know, the same allocations that we've always had for Measure A, which was, you know, 18% to tourism, 6.5% to housing, 6.5% to transit. So in the second quarter, I'm realizing $5 million. I think there will be capacity for two more allocations of TOT in the third and fourth quarter, probably rivaling between $4 and $5 million total for those two aspects.
4:08:43 You know, looking at somewhere in the range of $28 million if everything kind of holds through, right? That's the expectation. So I'm just realizing five at this point, and that will become sort of available to be used. I show on here the distribution I just talked about, which is tourism, transit, housing. Those allocations take about $1.557 million out of the available $5 million that we allocated.
4:09:10 We have some additional revenues that are in there. Interest, which interest we budget very, very low, but we've been achieving somewhere in the $1.3 million a year in revenue for interest because of the volume of money we have to invest as well as the interest rates we've had. They've been north of 5%. They've come down below that now.
4:09:34 But they're still very, very strong. But we don't want to rely on that, so I don't budget that very heavily. And then finally, Whitmore Pool reimbursement, as I mentioned in the staff report. We've got some final negotiations on the continued contract with the county in that. And so we're going to forgo about $300,000 in total across two years of charges that we are charging the county in that space. So I'm removing the expectation of the $175,000 we have budgeted for this year.
4:10:02 Because we won't be achieving that. So in total we have revenue of $5,325,000. The first, one of the things that we do through our expenditure, our review of the budget is to look at the expenditures and where they are year to date. Each of, I will say that each of these has a reason for that and typically, you know, at this time we were talking about snow removal costs in very heavy years.
4:10:28 We haven't really experienced that this year. I think we're going to be able to cover with it on our baseline allocations. But each of these items, there is either an event that occurred after we budgeted or other activity that we have decided to engage in that we knew was going to cost more. And so we're capturing that here and just making those good.
4:10:52 What this means is I'm taking away from the available revenue and allocating it towards these higher expenses than expected so that they're covered for the year. And I won't go through that in detail unless there are questions on any specific item. We had an Austrian cultural account set up for the running of the MAC and the execution of the purchase and sale agreement. That was all expected to happen.
4:11:19 In late summer, early fall, and with all the work that we talked about earlier with the due diligence on the DSA component, as well as some construction aspects with the Edison Theater, that is no longer a part of it. I do have, you know, some money set aside, about $25,000 for funding the endowment administration. As you know, we have an endowment associated with running the MAC, and that group has been stood up.
4:11:45 And I do expect to bring a contract back to council for approval on how that will run. We've already allocated money. We have grant-matching money to associate with that. But I'm just having some general administrative funds that we've set aside for that purpose. Can I ask you a quick question? Yeah. Just about, like, the police department, it looks like it's much more than expected. Will we be addressing that in the following year? Like, is this a one-time?
4:12:15 It's an interesting concept, right? So the police force, the bulk of that is in overtime. And what we encountered is people out on disability, temporary disability out for various things. We were kind of struck with that. If you remember, we've changed the schedule even to try to accommodate that. And so part of the schedule change adds to overtime.
4:12:42 But just the coverage itself, you know, if we have a very lean force where everything is dedicated and those shifts can't be not worked, right? You can't have two officers scheduled and then when someone's out sick, somebody else has to come and do that. And so we have just been hit with a plague of that for this year. And that's where that number has gone so high. Expected to be somewhere into $310,000. We are, if you remember, we've sent...
4:13:10 Okay, thank you.
4:13:43 You know, just generally going from the 5.325 that we allocated down to what's really available to be programmed, and that's the $3,260,400. That's taking out the allocations, taking out the expenditures that we pushed in there. And then what I bring forward to all of you is staff recommendations, right? So we have a balance of needs here that are across multiple areas of our organization and, you know, within the community addressing several things.
4:14:13 It's important to note that, you know, the vast majority of our revenue comes from visitation. That's what we do for a living. That's what happens. We are dependent upon that, and that's why we budget the way we do, and that's also why we invest in some of the recommendations that you see before you. First one that I have up there is Housing Now programs. That's Parcel Phase 3. You heard a lot about that from Hayes earlier today. Parcel Phase 3 also
4:14:42 Currently has $7 million allocated to it. This would be adding some more. That $7 million was intended to be all subsidy-based for the 42 units expected to be developed. In this case, we need to start to augment some infrastructure elements and some design elements that you'll see another design request elsewhere on this presentation. So we're just needing to put a little bit more money in there. I just want to note that, you know, while we have Measure L and that's contributing to, you know, an estimated
4:15:11 Four million dollars a year for housing. We still need to invest general fund in housing. And this is an example of that, right? A million dollars from this particular area, general fund dollars going to housing still. The other two elements that, there are two elements on here for the CRC project. One of them is sort of a phase two enhancement. That's all the interior structures, visitor and staff accommodations. We do have plans to have offices built in over there for the
4:15:40 Parks and Recreation employees for the bulk of them, as well as a really nice counter entry rental and setup for skates. It's really nice. The renderings are in the staff report. That's a $530,000, roughly $510,000. We've got a little bit of extra money in contingency there because the CRC is one of those things that every time you touch something, you find something you didn't want to find.
4:16:07 And we have to mitigate those as we dig into projects that we're working on. The roads, I'll kind of, I'll kind of trail to, for lack of a bit, I'm getting all tired. We will earmark that 500. I'll talk a little bit more about that later. That contains most of what Hayes was looking for earlier on the larger 3.75 million dollar project that he outlined for you earlier.
4:16:34 We don't have enough money in gas tax to cover that fully, so the $500,000 will augment that and get us to the number that we need to achieve, but I'll go through that in more detail later. We have master planning efforts for 2025. We've talked about this a lot. We're going to be doing master plans probably for the next 10 years.
4:16:53 Updates and those things. This is the first one we want to engage with, which is Parks and Recreation. Stu and team have done a great job of preparing for that space. This will sort of dictate where that goes. It's about a 12 to 18 month project, but we're setting aside $300,000 to accomplish that. The closeout on the current work being done on the CRC phase two, that would be the bleachers and some of the preparatory work for cleaning out the restrooms and things that were a challenge.
4:17:23 That's going pretty well. We've encountered a few things, as I said earlier, that, you know, you will in this particular building. So we have a $280,000 request on a closeout for that project. And that was just that phase two component. And so that would get us through with the work that we're currently doing and then the augmentation with the 530 above. I am, as I said earlier, when Lawson was giving the presentation on our fuels,
4:17:50 Production, Fuels Reduction Program. I'm recommending $200,000 to the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District for fuels mitigation work. They are planning to hire eight of these seasonal summer workers to do this, and we're funding for four more. So there'll be a total of 12. That's how some of those things that we talked about earlier are going to get accomplished. Whitebark, support for their finance director. This is something the council awarded two years ago.
4:18:20 And there was a delay in obtaining this position so that the funding was not expended in the year it was budgeted, and I didn't carry it over. I missed that particular thing. We can carry them over year over year. So what happens is when you don't carry it over, it falls to fund balance, and so I need to reallocate it. So that's why it's in here again. Those monies have already been spent. I executed that earlier this year, but it is in fiscal year 24-25, which is our current year.
4:18:49 And then I'm setting aside requesting $50,000 for the wildfire parcel level work that was part of the presentation earlier. This is miscellaneous expenses, maybe some of the software investments that were introduced to you today, but just having some money to be able to execute that program I think was really good to set aside. And then finally, capital project for the Whitmore Park ball field number three.
4:19:14 There's a nice write-up in there, the $30,000 in rehabilitation. We had really good success last year with field number two. It was performed by our staff, which is, I think, a great execution of giving them, you know, a project to complete, and they've done a great job on that. So this is a $30,000. So fully spending the money we have available to talk about in quarter two at that $3,260,000.
4:19:41 Before I go on to gas tax, are there any questions or thoughts around these staff recommendations on general fund, or do you want me to do it all at the end? I've had a couple thoughts. Go ahead. So, and Rob, I'm sorry I didn't bring this up with you this afternoon. We had kind of a quick meeting, but I have a couple concerns here. The first thing is, in our council's strategic priorities, one of the things we identified was the town-wide vision plans and services. And this evening, I've already heard
4:20:07 Two plans coming forward and we still have not had that discussion about the inventory of the plans that are needed and how those things need to be prioritized. So I'm, you know, I, you know, new municipal parks plan is really important, but I don't see how that fits in the context of the other things that we may have to be doing and I'm not comfortable moving forward, I'm not comfortable moving forward yet with that kind of an allocation until, at least I, for me, have a better understanding.
4:20:36 What are the other things that are out there? Do we have to reprioritize those kinds of things? The second thing is one of the things we added into our priorities is sustainable outdoor recreation. Those things are going to drive visitation. And I don't see anything in here that's going to support that. And I think just picking up what Brent was saying earlier, the needs that we may have for additional rec techs.
4:21:00 The host program is a great program. As you and I have discussed, I spend a fair amount of time at those places where I would expect to see the host presence and it's not there. I know how hard it is to retain those people and to hire those people. So I'm looking to start getting some funding that's available, that's starting to invest in those things that are going to be driving visitation. And I think the things you mentioned about the Forest Service requests to do work on...
4:21:28 You know, they're outside the municipal boundary, those kinds of things. I would really like to understand that we have enough resources to support all those things that are critical to the success of the destination before I'm going to be real comfortable moving forward with some of these recommendations. I mean, if you look at the CRC, it's a success.
4:21:48 Town staff did an unbelievable job under ridiculous circumstances to get that thing built. And it's a successful thing. We all appreciate that. But there's a million dollars, almost a million dollars in stuff that we're still putting into that thing. Okay, it's fine. Let's get that done. But in the environment we're in, things are moving around. You know, we want to get some money into the wildfire stuff, but we need to be investing. That's our relationship with MLT. That's our obligation. It's on us to deliver the product.
4:22:17 That then they're going to market and they're going to sell. And I'm not, I'm just not, I don't know where we're at with that at this point. So I've got a little bit of hesitance. What about the MUP rehabilitation? I mean, I would, I guess I would counter and say improvements to the CRC and MUP rehabilitation are for visitors. I don't, I don't buy that. You don't think those are. I don't think that's the whole thing. I think that when you start looking at the reasons why people come here, that's a whole.
4:22:44 Sort of a larger discussion, but I think there's a lot of things in addition to that, that especially look at the reduction of capacity coming out of the Forest Service, that we need to be prepared to backfill and to move in and to ensure that we can deliver the kinds of experiences that we can. The wildlife stuff, I mean, what...
4:23:03 Host programs, we've talked about that whole thing we went through with the, you know, we had a good, really nice discussion about the various components of the wildlife management program. I think we need to start having some resources being invested in that. Bill, certainly heard everything you said about how we're engaging with the animals themselves, how we're educating the visitors and those kinds of things. I think we need to be putting resources into all that stuff. So those are my thoughts at this moment. You know, John, that being said, I'm very comfortable with what's proposed here.
4:23:32 Because I believe, unless all heck breaks loose, that Rob is correct in the third quarter update, we are going to have some more unallocated funds that we can allocate to those specifically. But I see nothing here that I would want to cut in favor of putting that money somewhere else. Everything I see here to me is fairly important. I think that the MUPS and the CRC are a huge part.
4:24:00 of what keeps our guests entertained when they're here, and that's what keeps them coming back. It's not just, in fact, it is nowhere near as much backcountry trails that keeps them, which is what it used to be, as what I would call front country today, which is what we're working on here with our mubs and stuff. Well, but I've, yeah, I could maybe be willing to go along with that.
4:24:24 But I think this inventory of the planning of the various plans we have, plans we have on the shelf and all that, I would hope that we could see that by the time we get back to another reallocation of funds. But I think the investments, I mean, you know what it's like in the summertime, everything in the lake space is on federal land. You know, all those, the campgrounds, the people riding their bikes up there, that is all in the federal landscape. And CRC is a great project, you know, I've been there, I got,
4:24:54 The scars to prove it, all the way through that thing. Super beautiful, wonderful project. But we have to start looking at the things, and again, look at our friends at Mammoth Lake Tourism in the back. When they're promoting this place, they're not saying, hey, come up to Mammoth in the summertime and go indoors inside a building and play pickleball. That's not why they're coming up here. And I think we need to be real about the things, and you know this, that compels the visitation, and we need to make sure we have everything we need in that toolkit.
4:25:24 To be working that standard of excellence, I'm just not seeing anything in here about that. Is there something specific that you, you know what I mean? I would like to speak with Rob about how the Office of Outdoor Recreation is being reconfigured, making sure that that wildfire group has all the resources that they need. The wildlife engagement program, what does that look like? What does that need? The host program, what is that going to need? Come on.
4:25:54 Go with me. I agree. Okay. So if I could kind of meld this a little bit. These are all questions still, right? These are my, I think Robert, these are my comments on this. I'll phrase this in a question then. I still, we're going to be talking about it in a minute in terms of funding for some thinning of the forest.
4:26:22 And I'm struggling in my head in terms of thinking it really should be coming from this area of funding versus a tourism reserve and other things funded out. And where you're going, John, I'm not sure if I am in line with these funding expenditures at this time until I figure out where some of this comes from. I just think we're taking money from the wrong sources, in my opinion. Should we listen to his presentation, though, about that first? No, but my question is maybe we should hold until we see the whole thing. Sure.
4:26:51 Oh, fair enough. Okay. I think a lot of what John is talking about is going to be dealt with during this budget process, not what we're allocating here in our unallocated funds, but in the budget for the following year, and I would concur. We need to see how that's going to go, and we need to see what we're going to have to allocate budget-wise to achieve our general fund.
4:27:13 So I'll finish the presentation and we can get through more. Okay. Gas tax summary. So a couple things in gas tax to talk about. First and foremost, reimbursement from 22-23 since we had the potential to get some funds back from FEMA. The bulk of those estimated FEMA-related funds were held.
4:27:41 From the reimbursement from California State gas tax. That did come through this year. It was almost a million dollars in effort. And then if you remember when we did the budget last year or in all years going forward, I'm going to use a baseline revenue expectation and then we'll have things that are higher. In that case, we'll earn more. So we had 1.5 million expected for our
4:28:06 Revenue from gas tax in 24-25, we had just under $3 million. So that's the additional $1 million for $40. And then expenditure-wise, I had just a couple of things. The assessment district is a direct connection to the additional revenue. Those go out to the assessment districts that are engaged in the snow removal. And then we add a little bit of overtime and public utilities in street maintenance. But all in all, I have about an initial $1,267,000 in gas tax.
4:28:35 And with the recommendations, this goes in line with what Hayes talked about earlier, so I won't go through this in detail, but you can see the projects listed above. The $3,750,000 that he had on his sheet is what I have down here for staff recommendations. When you look at the revenue that we can have, we have available to spend, plus this expenditures, we have a deficit of $2,483,000.
4:29:01 What we do have in that space is other sources for funding. 210 has an available fund balance of $2,425,000. And then we have $580,000 in budgeted expenditures for road rehabilitation in the current fiscal year. And then I talked earlier about the $500,000 from general fund. That's going to leave a fund balance of just over $1 million. I wouldn't go below that for...
4:29:28 What we need to keep in gas tax. But again, all the recommendations in here are the work plans and programs that Hayes talked about earlier. And then finally, when you look at housing and tourism reserve funds, the allocations I talked about earlier of $903,800, that's directly from the $5 million that we are allocating from TOT for this quarter.
4:29:56 And what I'm recommending to that is two elements. One of them is to fund a particular section of treatments for parcels that have been a part of the plan for the calendar 2025. They were supposed to be funded by federal funds that are currently frozen and unavailable. This treatment area, the map is in.
4:30:22 The staff report, but it's right adjacent to the Knolls. And that's just one particular treatment area. As I said earlier, those areas have been bid out. They have favorable bids. We have a short period of time in which to execute on those bids. And if the funds aren't released, we'll lose that and potentially the vendors that are bidding in our space. The thing I'd like to talk about and why tourism reserve is recommended here.
4:30:48 Several years ago, I think maybe five years ago or so, Council decided to allocate all of the unallocated annual budget for tourism reserve to housing. That was supported by the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. They aligned with those expectations from Council and agreed to that. So what would happen is if we're generating a budget of $18 million, that
4:31:17 Uses the calculation I showed you earlier and how much is allocated to TOT. That would then say I have a bucket of say 3.5 million. We take out a contract for MLT, we take out a contract for the chamber, a few other ancillary things like the host program that's funded through that process and some other aspects that we have for marketing. And we have an excess amount of roughly a million dollars.
4:31:43 That was the automatic contribution to housing that we did during the budgeting process in addition to similar allocations from the housing reserve. What I was going to recommend is through 25 and 26 and beyond for probably three years is that we take those monies, every portion of them, and dedicate them to the wildfire efforts that we need to make.
4:32:05 The reason that we need to do that, or I'm recommending that, is because while we have invested a great deal in housing, we really need to do things that are going to protect those investments. Not only in housing, but even the infrastructure and amenities that we've talked about, the investments we have in elsewhere. We have to start to lean into that space. What I hope we would achieve with that is to get partnership of other people, other large entities within the community that have a similar interest in
4:32:33 Making sure we have good wildfire protection to also invest in that space and allow for really an acceleration of the efforts. And so my recommendation was going to be for 25 and 26 to take that and sort of reallocate it. So that's how we ended up with wildfire out of tourism to a degree. And I just wanted to kind of button those two up from that recommendation side. The other element in there is air subsidies. There'll be two.
4:33:01 There are two components to that. One of them is a total of $255,000, and this is an investment in air subsidies for commercial airline activities out of Bishop. As you know, most of my requests or all of my requests prior to this have been with regard to funding for
4:33:18 Advanced Air Flying into Mammoth. This will be associated with an MOU we want to execute with Inyo County MLT that talks about how each of those entities would fund some of the commercial service for winter. And then also included that is an extension of summer. You heard a recommendation earlier that we were, instead of having summer cut off in the first week of September, we're going to take it through the first week in October to capture those.
4:33:47 Really important endurance events that have been scheduled. So that $255,000, I'm pretty much allocating the bulk of what's in tourism reserve. But that is not the total that is in tourism reserve. That's just what we're allocating for this period of time. There's a fund balance in there that still exists. I don't have that number off the top of my head. But that kind of addresses some of the questions perhaps about why tourism is engaging in wildfire.
4:34:16 And then finally for housing, you know, the allocation for housing for that $5 million was $326,000. And there is a need for some design work to accomplish what Hayes was talking about earlier on parcel phase three. So there's a $250,000 recommendation for design of parcel phase three. I wanted to kind of highlight from these two funding sources, we're putting about $1.25 million into housing from this space.
4:34:43 And I think that's it. So I will stop there. That's the complete package. And I will address, John, your comments earlier about wanting to take that inventory. If we go back to the presentations we had for the strategic planning efforts in December, staff had on that list that we know we have recreation, parks and recreation, master plan edits that we wanted to lead with and do that process because of
4:35:15 Where that is and how fast moving that program is. There's other things that are in a similar space, but I would say nothing probably as critical as that one. So we had that one teed up a little bit and then we added this overarching discussion that happened in February timeframe. That's why I'm still having that recommendation as we have it today and I didn't miss the fact that we need to do that analysis. I just think we had already identified most critical in our efforts.
4:35:47 Now we've got the whole portion. I'm just trying to think of how to clarify this in a way that makes sense for everyone. I still struggle, and I don't believe it is correct to take the fire mitigation area of $610,000 out of the tourism reserve. We made a commitment in this community to fund workforce housing or affordable housing, whichever we've made a commitment that we are going to make that a number one priority. It's still, to me, the number one priority.
4:36:14 The amount of work that's going to be done here will reduce some mitigation for the town, but it's not going to make us 100%. We may get 2, 3, 4% of it. I'm not a big fan that we have to take up the spending for what the other people, and I say other federal partners and other partners that were going to fund this, and disappointed that those funds have reduced down. But I still feel these funds should be taken out of the unallocated funds.
4:36:43 That you've outlined for other areas versus taking out of the tourism reserve. Maybe it's semantics, but I just don't feel that that comes out of that fund. If we move forward, too, with this, I would, in particular with the forest mitigation efforts and wildfire mitigation, I would like to see something whereby if the funding gets- Wait, is this a question? Aren't we still- I just want to make sure we go through the- we follow the process.
4:37:12 Questions? The question is can we move the funding to start with from being a tourism reserve to being the unallocated resources from the additional TOT. Okay. And then I'll go back to another question. Yeah, that can definitely be done, but we'd have to look at what's in the general fund recommendations and decide what we're not doing there. I understand. And the second part of the question is if
4:37:41 No matter whether that's funded from the wildfire mitigation, can we put a clause in there whereby if it gets refunded in some ways that we can adjust our amount of funding? So we talked a little bit about that, right, to consider this as a loan for these frozen funds that, you know, frankly, we do expect, I don't have, I can't even fathom a guess on, it should be released, right? I mean, they're doing some.
4:38:09 Shenanigans to confirm contents of language before they release those funds. But the concern is that the funds are likely not designated as a reimbursement, but simply as for treatments. And so the ability to reimburse the town for this loan will probably not happen. We're still analyzing that. But to be fully transparent to all of you, I would consider it to be fully sunk into that space.
4:38:38 And if the money does come through, then additional treatments would be achieved with the monies that come through. And my last question, going back to reason, asking for the change. Is this body here willing to say that workforce housing is not that important and we're changing the allocation of the tourism reserve away from workforce housing? May I ask you a question? Who's that a question to? No, it's a question to this board. Well, I have a question. Sure. Correct me if I'm wrong.
4:39:09 I saw that we are putting a million dollars from the general fund into housing. You're correct. I am correct. So could you tell me, is there a difference? Because I know historically we've taken the tourism reserve money and taken that and put it into housing. And I believe you said about like a million dollars? Roughly, yeah. Would we be able to take this whole $903,800 and take that?
4:39:38 And then pay for the wildfire mitigation out of the general fund and then also supplement, you know, with another $96,200 from the general fund to make it an even million dollars to housing? Yeah, we can, if we're rearranging the same sets of dollars in this space, obviously I can make that work. I will
4:40:07 I will press on this board that I am recommending that we kind of look at how we're going to continually fund wildfire efforts in subsequent fiscal years. And the only dollars I have to play with are the tourism reserve unallocated fundings. So that's where this space is. So the question that Brent asked is a good one. I think while I don't agree that we can't
4:40:37 We're not funding workforce housing because of this change. That's not at all what's happening. But it is a fundamental change in this. And I think we have to recognize that we do have to, and I hope this demonstrates that we have to balance across a multitude of needs for the community. And so while we are fully committed to housing, other efforts have to be made to protect those. And I apologize for not giving a question, but I just want...
4:41:06 Go on that same portion. I don't disagree with that at all. And I believe that we have to recognize what the total needs for the community is. But I believe we have enough unallocated resources to fulfill almost what Amanda has suggested, where dollars are. And we don't have to upset our political commitment we made on the tourism reserve. Go ahead.
4:41:30 I have a question. Rob, the destination management plan, I didn't hear anything mentioned in your presentation. Yeah, thank you, and thank you for that. It was, it's in the staff report as a recommendation that we remove original stipulations that were placed on the funding. So if you remember back in September of 24,
4:41:53 We had a request from Tourism Reserve to fund this destination management plan to the tune of $200,000, and the council approved that with a stipulation that we would secure partnership from other agencies that they would participate or commit to participate in that activity, and I think where we've struggled is to, number one, obtain that, and two, with the federal partners where they are today, I don't expect that to come, and I don't...
4:42:21 I want to ask that that be removed as a stipulation. It's not on here as a funding request because the money has already been allocated. It just has the, you know, stipulation that doesn't allow us to move forward without those elements. So in the staff report, I had requested that we remove that stipulation. And so thank you, John, for bringing that up. I just want to make sure that was clarified. Thank you. Thank you. Questions, Bill? No questions. When you're ready for comments, I've got some of those. I have a question. Let's get finished questions because we need to take public comment. I'm just waiting patiently.
4:42:52 Is it correct that like the Whitebark Institute to get funding for these projects to protect the town of Mammoth Lakes, they need some contributions from our town? So, you know, when you, and I have to ask Whitebark for that feeling, but my understanding of this process is that there are cash flow challenges. The town is already contributing money in that space where
4:43:22 You know, we have a bank of, I think, $500,000, and those assist in paying bills and being reimbursed by grants. There's often a very long delay in the reimbursement process and how things come back. So being able to pay your bills and then float that process. But when you look at these grant-funded programs, they're often looking at where
4:43:46 Is the community investing for themselves, right? So that commitment of continual annual, an annual commitment of funding really helps the equation, right? They're able to go and say, yeah, no, the town is putting X number of dollars in there. I'll say that a number of partners, large partners within the community have asked those questions when questions are asked of them of what they're funding. Well, what is the town putting into this, right? So there's a little bit of a...
4:44:13 We're going to push in some space there to, number one, fix the issue and challenge, make our equation or their applications more favorable for success. And then also, you know, challenge our rest of our community to step into that space. So that was the goal in that. Can I ask just a clarifying question, your question? I think part of the reason why this is coming before us now is the fact that the federal government has suspended
4:44:40 Between $7 and $10 million of awarded grants. So to clarify, I think. And reimbursement grants as well, right? So there's two elements of this. Yeah, there's a couple of elements. This particular request is associated with the frozen funding that John was mentioning. But the other question that you're discussing is where I'm leaning for
4:45:09 Like budget recommendations for 25-26, right? And so those I have that gap only in the tourism reserve at this point and how that part is funded. So the decision or the questions about whether it's appropriate or not to utilize those particular funds are going to have to be answered at some point. Those are all my questions before deliberation. Sure. Okay. Any other questions?
4:45:39 Are there any public comments, either in the room or online? I see some public comments about to happen. Sure, thanks. Janet Hatfield, Whitebark Institute, joined by our finance director, Ryan Bobick. So I would like to just address counsel that we too are sorely disappointed that federal grants have been suspended. That used to be
4:46:11 The gold standard for secure financing and with the number of years of work we've put into this, we share that disappointment. However, I think we all saw in the wake of the LA fires the constituent concerns around the immediate need for action by the outpouring of comments and the highly attended community coffee events, etc. and just questions among public conversations.
4:46:41 And so, you know, the timing of this probably couldn't have happened at a worse time in that this money was awarded last year. It goes out for bid. Those bids were awarded, and then funds are frozen. So we're mid-term, mid-stream in contracting with entities and contractors that don't know if they're going to have work and really
4:47:06 To me, maybe more importantly, is that we communicated to the town via community coffee, hey, we've got your concerns addressed, here's all the work that's coming forward, and two-thirds of that work is at risk of being cleaved off. So I will say the town's potential allocation is about a third of the funding that has been suspended currently. It does not meet the whole, and the absolute intention is to
4:47:35 Leverage the town's leadership to attract additional emergency funds and then
4:47:41 If and when the federal funding is reinstated to get more work done, and I would absolutely say that it is, we've said this, I've been here at this lectern multiple times, this is an essential investment in housing security and our financial security, et cetera, so I think it does, I would agree with Mr. Patterson that there is a nexus with housing here and with our economic sustainability, quite frankly. I get that
4:48:11 It's not to mean that this priority is higher than any other. I agree wholeheartedly. Housing is a major issue, even more so that we need to protect so that we don't have a worse housing scenario. Anything you want to add? Yeah, I think, first of all, for those who have MME, Ryan, the finance director, appreciate the town's support for the position, so thank you. But I think a couple things come to mind, and, you know, I've been at White Park since December here.
4:48:39 The few ways that I look at it, too, is, you know, there's this emergency funding and the work that we have for the summer, and there's a continued plan of what we want to implement here in the areas surrounding the town, right? And so I think part of the thought process, too, is every delay that we have in a season, it doesn't only increase the wildfire risk of this town, but it also increases the cost in the future of how much it costs per acre for us to actually implement.
4:49:09 You know, prices go up, contractors go up, etc. And so, you know, ultimately, a gap in a year isn't only an increase in financial risk for potential wildfire issues, but also an increase in the cost that we have to move forward. And I think one thing that's important to note is, like, White Park has been very successful in winning grant money. That's great. It's supported the local counties and the towns. I think...
4:49:35 Where we're at right now is like a lot of our grants have matching requirements and for us to go and apply for new grant funding, they need to see investments from local communities and stakeholders and beneficiaries here. And so it's not only getting other beneficiaries that are local to support our mission, it actually allows us to level up and start to apply for those larger 50 million block grants that we can start to bring.
4:50:03 Really trying to disperse and use for the region. And so I think the last thing that I really just want to highlight is, you know, we are very appreciative of the cash flow assistance support that the town's currently providing. You know, just coming into the organization and looking at where we're at, it is very clear, you know, it takes us, it takes us north of sometimes four or five months to collect and our bills, you know, I mean, as an organization, our expenses can be north of
4:50:29 5 million, right, for a season, and often our receivables are sitting north of a million, and so it really is a challenging environment that we're playing with really thin margins here, so happy to answer any questions that you guys have, but just want to give that context. Thank you. And yeah, with Prop 4 money coming down the line, the local investment helps us leverage more state, someday more federal investment, and it helps us weather these boom and bust cycles. This is not the first time this has happened.
4:50:59 We've endured, not White Bark, but in my nonprofit tenure, we've endured state funding cycles similar, maybe not as extreme, and certainly this is not the first of the federal. So the local investments helps us weather those storms. Thank you so much. Can I ask another question? Of what? Well, I guess it is of Janet, if that's okay. Yeah, we can do that, right, Andy? Sure. Okay, go ahead. So I just...
4:51:27 The map, Rob, that you included in the report, it has sort of like different parcel shapes and how much they cost. I just had a question because this is zoomed in to one part of Mammoth, but when we were talking about
4:51:44 Earlier in the meeting tonight, it had all of the neighborhoods categorized as moderate, low, high, and Old Mammoth was, I think it had the highest risk associated with it, and so I just kind of wanted to know, like, are there parcels around?
4:51:59 Like, why aren't we addressing that area first? Good question. Thanks for paying attention this late at night. Those funds, we are doing work in Old Mammoth, those are under state funds, so they're not impacted. Okay, so that's all, so we're taking care of the... Yep, there's work in Old Mammoth on the Valentine Reserve and off Red Fur Road up by the Mill City Track that is, and Panorama Dome, that is all also moving forward under CAL FIRE funds. Okay, and then we selected, because, you know, like the Knolls and the Holidays.
4:52:27 That was also, I think it was yellow, and then there were some other parts that were orange. So we had plans to get all of these. I don't know what map you're looking at, but I think I know what map. I don't see it. I wrote it on page 16 in Lawson's presentation. Yeah, so our bids were so competitive this year that, which is good, we're attracting people because we're reliable partners with work consistently and they see the progress that we're making.
4:52:53 So we have a little surplus that Whitebark can invest to cover some of the federal, and we're doing those, those are the units right off Forest Trail. And so this would be, the town's investment would handle sort of off, right off the knolls on the scenic loop on the east side of the road. We're still working on the rest of Earthquake Dome on the other side of the scenic loop, but this is the next highest priority of the federal funding that is suspended.
4:53:21 Okay, thank you for clarifying that. Okay, so now deliberation. Bill's been waiting so patiently to give his comments. Please, Mr. Sauser. While I agree in some of my questions about allocating the sixes because we're taking it out of what we were spending on housing, but in a way we're actually spending it on housing. We're spending it so that we don't have to rebuild the millions of dollars of housing that we're in the process of building.
4:53:54 In terms of whether the fund we're taking it out of as the appropriate fund, the tourism fund, it's getting late. Frankly, if we burn, there's no tourism. There's no need for housing. There's no need for anything. I almost opposed taking housing out of tourism in the first place because I didn't see the close fit. I see a really close fit with tourism and fire and losing.
4:54:27 And remember, it's not just the housing. It's not just if the town burns down. If the lake's basin goes, how many people want to come and hike to Duck Lake through a burnt, if you want to see pictures of what the forest on the other side of 395 looks like that burnt, we've ridden our snowmobiles through it this time many years. Tourism is not going to come up to see that. So I would love to see this come and changing it by just changing where the funding sources come from.
4:54:57 It's just staff time and money wasted, in my opinion. I think this fits. I do think that the conditions get put on it, that if those funds get freed before this has to be used, that this goes to fund future fire projects. This is like a one-time funding source that keeps us moving down that road, and I would like to see those confines put on it.
4:55:23 But in terms of whether it's appropriate, I view this as fully appropriate fire. While I may disagree with Whitebark that these are the most important places, because there's dead forest out there that if they get going, the fire will be so intense there's no stopping it no matter how much we clear around town. But I view this as appropriate. I think we need to move this forward before I fall asleep in my chair. Sorry.
4:55:51 If I can't get a laugh, I'm no good at all. You're good, Bill. You're good. We're here. You're good. Part of who we are up here. Who would like to go next? Go ahead. Okay, great. I agree with you, Bill. I think that I'm comfortable moving it forward as is presented. I do see, you know, wildfire mitigation is immensely important, and I'm comfortable taking it out of the tourism reserve. And I did just want to, like, point out that we are...
4:56:20 Also putting a million dollars into housing. Yes. Yeah. So who's that? Okay. So I am, the fire stuff is critical. Just to add, Bill, a little bit to your characterization. If we burn, it stops before they've even put it out. And you just look at the communities of Paradise and others, it's over. And whether we rebuild or not, so it's a...
4:56:55 It's a zero-sum kind of a proposition. In terms of taking it from the Tourism Reserve, I think that there's something that we have to do, and I focus very keenly on our relationship with MLT, the working relationship we have with that organization, and I think we need to figure out a better way, an appropriate way to be communicating with MLT.
4:57:22 That if the council is going to be, you know, making these kind of changes in terms of what we're doing with that, that we're doing that in partnership with MLT. So that it's kind of clear what's happening. I think also, as I was kind of mentioning before, I apologize for getting into commenting before we got to the stage of the meeting. But, you know, we have responsibilities for the product. And I think that's part of my concern I was expressing earlier. We have to make sure.
4:57:51 That we are rising to the moment that we're in, such that MLT, which is recognized as one of the premier DMOs in the state, that we're putting the resources into the things that we need to be able to do for them to be able to say, the bathrooms are going to be clean. Look at this unbelievable fire program that this community has taken on.
4:58:13 Trails that people come up are being maintained. We're working with our federal partners to take care of these things while we're also building these beautiful municipal resources. So we have to really get into that moment. So, Bill, I'll go along with everything that's been said, but I do need to add these things. I really want to see the plans. What's on the books? What's dead wood? What do we get rid of? What are the things we've got to pursue?
4:58:41 And I really want to look at the things we've identified as part of that destination investment. What are we putting into that wildlife program? What are we putting into the host program to make sure it's successful? What are we doing with our recreation product, which drives the visitation? I'm looking forward to that as we get into the next quarter. Can I ask you a question? Sure. I just want to clarify. So you're saying that you want to take MLTs?
4:59:11 Requests into account when we're dealing with the Tourism Reserve or giving them a say in how we're spending the Tourism Reserve? I want to be careful about the language that I use with that. But we've done a lot of work, we're trying to do a lot of work to really build a truly functioning relationship. This is the point about the projects, the T-Bit projects, which Hayes advised, look, it's sort of on the town, we're not getting there yet. We have to do everything we can.
4:59:40 To weld together our functioning relationship with the voice of our community that's talking to the entire world. And look, there are people all over the world. They're not going to come to the United States because of what's happening in the federal government right now. It's an incredibly challenging environment. And we need to make sure that we continue to bring in those resources for housing, for municipal projects, for all the rest of it. So we just have to be working very closely together. And then I guess I would just kind of follow up that question where I agree. I think it's wonderful.
5:00:10 Work closely with them. But, you know, like the tourism reserve, I feel like that's separate from MLT. You know, I'm like, I guess I kind of feel like the housing reserve, would you go say, okay, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, tell us what to do with all the housing reserve? No, no, no. I'm speaking more in terms of a partnership of a communication. I think there may have been, I think we maybe could have done a better job. I mean, I don't know how the sequencing of this work, we're in sort of new times. But when I'm at the,
5:00:40 And I think if I dig down into where I'm at with part of my portion as the past chair of MLT and
5:01:09 Communication. It is the same thing. It may be a process, but this group here, and I say this group and now I'm part of it, voted to say all the tourism reserves are going to go to workforce housing. It would have been nice if it came up through a process and said we're going to look at where we're allocating funding versus just having a request that takes money out of it for something else that may not be any unethical means. I'm not suggesting there's any wrongdoing about allocating where money is.
5:01:37 But a better process for clarity that everybody knows where we're putting money. I don't think everything has to go to Workforce Housing. I mean, we have needs. We have fire needs. We have other things that we need to do. I'm not against that. To me, it's a reflection of the process that we just went through. It was not as clean as I'd like it. So it's clear to everybody why we're using these money and what we're using it for. Yeah, and Amanda, the other thing I would add to that is I think to make clear to MLT so they understand if they have needs.
5:02:05 Which they do, and they're in a challenging environment. So it's a clear understanding to that board, this is how these things need to come forward to us. And I don't think it's clear to the MOT board exactly how that works. And how if they want to make a request of the Tourism Reserve to say, hey, we're dealing with these, you know, marketing challenges or something like that, how that process works, so that would come forward to us. I don't think that's clear. There's probably a better process for this. Yeah. However,
5:02:33 We didn't know four weeks ago or three weeks ago that these funds were going to be frozen. Oh, no, I get you, I get you, I get you, I get you. These are extraordinary circumstances. Understand completely. And we have to, I am very proud at how this came forward from our staff because we have to be flexible. We've talked about it over and over again and this is part of that flexibility. This is being able to respond by the way we budget. This is our ability to respond quickly to
5:03:01 Outrageous circumstance. I agree. Just as we go down this road, we learn things along the way. Let's pay attention to this. Let's pay attention to that. We can do things better. And moving, if I can, to a separate subject, I just would, as part of this moving forward, though, I want to make sure that we're brought back from Hayes and talking about the roundabout. I think it'd be beneficial to have that discussion sooner rather than later so that we're comfortable to keep moving forward in that direction.
5:03:30 What were we asking Hayes to bring back about the roadmap? No, I'm just saying as part of this, we're looking at saying we're going to move ahead with, for instance, $20,000 for, whatever, $20,000 for roundabout design work that there were a number of questions that were raised by a couple of council members and would love more information sooner rather than later about that and what is going to take place there. And I'm sure that'll happen. Yep, I'm just reinforcing the... He's either nodding or snoring. He's sleeping.
5:04:00 I'd like to address some of the MLT comments, if I may. You know, we go back to the time in which every dollar of TOT associated with Measure A allocations to tourism went to Mammoth X tourism. Those efforts were done, I think, probably seven or eight years ago where adjustments were made. And in the transitional time period, there was a joint account, right? Consider it, you know, two hands on.
5:04:27 The missile keys and any decision on a dollar was made in that space. We, and that was also part of the contract with MLT. It was written in the contract. We migrated away from that and there was prior councils. I mean, some of you were on those, but some of you were not. Where there was a strong desire to ensure, as it is appropriate, the council dictates
5:04:51 Ultimately, where the funds go in the end, right? And so while consultation from the board is there, I think as staff, so fast forward for the last five years, doing five budget presentations a year, I have never consulted MLT on where those funds should be allocated, nor have I heard any challenge to those decisions that have been there. So if we're going to
5:05:21 Take it back to where there's a consultation and a review and a recommendation we have to be prepared for. If there is a difference in desire between what the council sees and what the recommendations from MLT is, that will be, you know, a difficult threshold to pass. So I think MLT is fully aware that they can come to the
5:05:42 The Council and request funds. I know we have a good conversation about that frequently. I have actually the liaison between MLT and the town from my prior role. So I think that's really, really clear. I just think we've got some unintended consequences by sort of preintroducing this dual representation here. So I just wanted to say those. If that is the desire of Council, what I would bring back is a policy procedural discussion.
5:06:09 For a policy item from Council on exactly how that will work. So I just want to be clear, I'm not asking for anything like that. But what I've heard from MLT board members is it's not clear to us how we bring, if they want to access something from the Tourism Reserve or any other place, it's not clear how we do that.
5:06:28 So if that's something that, I mean, you and John work very closely together, but if that could be clearly articulated so that the full board understands, hey, you've got a request or a need, this is how you do it. So that they, it feels like it's an even. No, that's fair enough. That's easy.
5:06:46 I think they know how to ask for money, but I'll definitely clear that up. They know how to ask for money, but they don't know how to write agenda bills, if you notice. Oh, that's up to me. I'd have to do that. They can't, they don't, they've got limited skills. Pretty pictures, you know, but, you know. No, I just, I'm sorry, I didn't want to belabor the conversation, but I just wanted to kind of draw that point together, right? It's really a critical thing, and I think.
5:07:09 Help folks understand the progression of things and how they have been. So I certainly didn't want to, in this shift, bring this extra sense of burden on that relationship because that's our marketing arm, right? That's critically important to our success. And I don't want to do anything that damages that, but just this whole span of control is a challenge at times. Madam Mayor.
5:07:36 I would love to try and bring this to a close by making a motion to adopt. I didn't give any, you didn't give me a chance to even say boo. I know it. I'm moving here. All right, go for it. I just wanted to say thank you to Rob and the team for all of the work that goes into this. It's quite a lot. And I strongly support making sure that the
5:08:00 Wildfire Task Force, including our Fire Protection District and Whitebark have the resources they need to keep our town safe this summer and into the future. So that is all. And Mr. Salzer, take it away. Thank you. I would love to make a motion to adopt the proposed resolution amending the fiscal year 24-25 budget as recommended in attachment A, budget adjustments. I'll second. Further discussion, please?
5:08:25 Further discussion? Yes. She has to answer that, not me. I just add something to that. The points I made earlier, which again, were not appropriate in terms of the process, but the issues around the Office of Outdoor Recreation stuff, the wildlife program, host programs, all those things that are related to our product that encourages and compels visitation, that with staff, we could be bringing those things back.
5:08:52 As part of the next allocation, because I think, I hope there's a consensus that we do that, because right now I'm seeing short shrift for that. So where I'm at with that, John, and I agree all of those need to come forward. Right. But I view that as part of the regular budget process, which we are just starting now. That's the appropriate form, not the quarterly budget amendments. Understood. Because what you're talking about is all ongoing expenses that belongs in the budget.
5:09:19 I just want to make sure I'm just checking with my fellow council members as a consensus as part of the budget process that those things are going to come. I have no problem with that. I'm still struggling with a little bit. I'm not sure if I can go with this motion, but I'm still struggling with that. I'm not amending the motion. I know. I understand. Okay. I would ask that we do amend the motion slightly, though, to remove that stipulation that we talked about earlier on the $200,000 that was previously allocated and requiring
5:09:48 The partner commitments, if we can have that language. Oh, for the destination management. Yeah, if we can have that language added in that motion. Okay, did you make the motion? I did. So is there a second yet? There is. There is. Okay. I would amend it to include the $200,000 allocation for the destination resort marketing study. Removal of the stipulation that we work with partners on there. Removal of that stipulation, yes. Yeah, okay. But wasn't that the recommendation in attachment A?
5:10:19 No, it's not. Attachment A is only the budget recommendations, the dollars being allocated. I got that part wrong. Okay. We have a motion that staff is comfortable with. We have a second. Jamie, please call the roll. Do you second the amendment? Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Truax? No. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. All right. Let's see. Where are we? That's the best part of the meeting.
5:10:49 The end? Are we at the end? We are at 11.3, annual evaluation of the town manager and consideration of a merit pay adjustment. Thank you, Mayor Bubser. Before you is a part of the annual review of town managers, both the evaluation, which occurred in previous meetings, and then this is a review of
5:11:19 Any merit increase that would be awarded for those efforts. And for the contract, what is available is a 0 to 5% increase on an annual basis. And what has been, I think, recommended by the subcommittee is a 5% increase, which would take the annual wage to $219,558.
5:11:46 That would put me slightly above the middle band of the range. Can I make a motion? Well, Ms. McNamara, can we hear from the committee, please? Absolutely. That's what I was just about to... Vanda, you think you're getting out of here? You've got another thing coming. Councilmember Sauser, would you like to talk about the committee meeting and how that recommendation was reached? We had a committee meeting and we reached...
5:12:15 This recommendation. Sorry. Okay, I will. We met at Mayor Bubser's house and had a long and productive discussion over the merits. I believe that while I have been probably the stingiest council member in increasing pay for our executives, the job that Rob has done in the last year, the amount of time that he has put into this effort.
5:12:44 I think a 5% bump is certainly not overcompensation for the efforts of the last year. Anything further, this is the renewal of, not renewal, but this is his contract review at when the contract was originally stated, put in force. We will get a chance to talk about what we think appropriate salaries are.
5:13:13 Because next year we have to renegotiate, not renegotiate, but we have to re-up the contract, which gives us a complete fresh toolkit. But for this year and for the work that Mr. Patterson has put in, I felt very strongly that that 5% is more than due him and thought that it was incredibly appropriate. And I think we agreed on that during that meeting. After you broke my arm. After I broke her arm, yes.
5:13:41 And I would just like to add that, you know, I always think very carefully because I want to give people, I don't want to get them too close to the top of their band because you want people to have the incentive to continue to work hard and grow. And yet this puts our town manager about just right in the middle of the salary band.
5:14:05 You know, I think when Rob came in, he was very reasonable in the negotiations, hoping that, you know, he would have a good year and we would, you know, compensate him commensurately, which I believe is true after Bill twisting my arm, because I'm just tough.
5:14:23 Believe it or not, usually on this. So yes, so that is our committee's recommendation. We're really grateful to you for the way that you threw yourself into this job and handled everything that came at you and led your team. And so that is how we recommend the council proceed. Thank you. Do you want any public comment or anything?
5:14:49 Are there any more questions for us? My questions were to the committee. So you can ask us and then we'll do public comment. I'm satisfied with your report. Okay. Is there any public comment? Anyone online? So now we can deliberate. Or Amanda's ready. I'm ready to make a motion. You want to deliberate? I just really appreciate the work that Rob has done.
5:15:18 Now that we have a finance director, I'm looking forward to the return of stingy old Bill for the next round. So for now, I'm good with the recommendation of the committee. Yeah, and I'm good with the recommendation of where it goes. There's a part of me that wonders, not even wonders, I think Rob has done an excellent job. I think he has done two jobs this last year, and there's a part of me that felt that it was...
5:15:45 Worth more than what we're doing here. But I also recognize we're in the mid part of his contract. His contract comes up in next year. We can review where the salary is in the contract reviews. So I'm comfortable with what it is here. But at the same time, I think he's done a heck of a good job and probably worked too much for us. And probably we don't say thank you enough. S.O.B. Stingy old bell.
5:16:09 Amanda, go for it. Amanda, this is your time. Amanda, can I make a motion? Yes, please. Okay, I move that the town manager's merit adjustment is 5% resulting in an annual wage of $219,558. I'll second that. Fantastic. Jamie, please call the roll. Councilmember Salzer? Yo. Councilmember Truex? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. All right.
5:16:39 Thank you all for your kind words. I really appreciate that. We appreciate you more than you know. As John stated, now that we have a finance manager, we just expect more, more, Rob. You have more free time. Okay. All right. We're going to take a two-minute break. We'll just wait for Councilman, Mayor Pro Tem. But I'm signing this, Rob. Is this a two-minute bio break? It's a bio break. Just two minutes. That's all you get.
5:17:11 Look, even, everyone's running away. Don't leave us. And I will tell you that when I get home, my wife will not have eaten. She won't eat until I die. This is the new Chris. Because prior to the stroke, she'd be in bed on the stroke.
5:17:39 You're trying to use the money here to build the sites. I'm broke. I'm broke. I know.
5:17:44 You good? Hurry, Bill. Hurry, hurry. Maybe I'll start now. Well, I can't sign these yet because they're not voted on. Okay. I'll just sign away. Thank you, Jamie.
5:18:13 Yeah. Dying. Why'd you vote no?
5:18:43 Okay, good.
5:19:11 Okay, Mayor Buffsor, am I the only person who wants to get some work done here tonight? Come on, Bill, run. All right. Item 11.4.
5:19:39 Item 11.4, we're going to consider resolutions and a letter opposing local forest health, wildfire mitigation, and social and economic impacts that will result from federal funding cuts. Thank you. I'll launch this and Lawson sitting next to me because he is the one who has worked on this process along with Pam has done a lot of editing as well.
5:20:04 In my office. And so Truckee Council had sort of led the charge on this process as we've all been sort of writing letters to address concerns about impacts to our federal partners and especially reduction in their ability to service. What we have in this request is kind of a way of bringing together multiple agencies to highlight the need for more action from our local representatives. And so the intent of this is
5:20:33 Truckee put together two different resolutions covering different bases on impact from forest health and economic impacts. So they've asked us to kind of follow suit. We tailored the staff report a little bit to address what Mammoth Lakes individual needs are. And then you received, or you should have received today, resolutions that were worded in such a way to address the concerns that Mammoth Lakes has.
5:21:00 And those are recommended for approval tonight. What that will do is it will be combined with Truckee's efforts and hopefully other municipality efforts that will be delivered to a meeting in person with Congressman Kiley on April 18th. And so I may crash the party if I can and hand deliver my own resolutions.
5:21:26 Yeah, we'll do that. But essentially, we're looking for approval of those tonight. And again, this is really to try to stem the tide on some of the negative impacts that we expect to the town, right? I mean, what happens on the federal level happens on the federal level. But when it has a negative impact on our daily lives, that's where we need to step into this space. So I'll open it up if there are any questions or any thoughts. I don't have any. I have one question.
5:21:59 Andy, you may know this. We may not know the answer to this directly. My understanding is that in the Congress, the goal is to pass one, to put everything into one piece of legislation that would then go through the reconciliation process for adoption, for a signature by the President. A budget? Yes. I believe, well, there was a continuing resolution that will fund the government through the end of the fiscal year that's...
5:22:25 Already been signed, I think. Okay. So the clarification for that is in terms of our advocacy to Congressman Kiley. What expectations can we all have that if we write these letters and we do these things that there's going to be any, is there any decision point or to your point, maybe that's already done and it's over with.
5:22:46 What expectation can we have of our federal representatives that they can address any of the things we've got here in this letter? Well, they have to do the next budget. Yeah, the CR is done, but this is going forward in the future. Well, no, but to Andy's point. The budget they just passed, in my understanding, did not take any of those funds out. They just aren't being allocated. Well, there's two problems here. So there's a difference between Congress allocating funds and the president and the executive branch deciding to spend them.
5:23:14 I don't know what's in the budget that was just signed. And as for what can we expect from our member of Congress, I cannot peer into his mind. I simply don't know. Well, but even if, I mean, is there, I guess, is there any possibility that writing a letter through a congressional representative, that there's, is there any recourse in the continuing resolution which goes to the end of the year or if they do this reconciliation bill?
5:23:41 to make adjustments to address our concerns? I don't have a specific answer for that. I would like to think that just in general that Congressman Kiley will be sensitive to the needs of his district and his constituents and that if we can make a good case, I'm hoping that he will advocate for all of us.
5:24:03 I love Annie Morris. Hope's not much of a strategy. So maybe we should perhaps follow up on this because it's part of our situational awareness. If we can look at what's going on and say, look, there's not going to be any recourse, that comes back to inform our policymaking decisions, the kind of things that we do, like with our budget. So that might be something to consider as we go forward. But that was my question. Certainly. But I do think that
5:24:32 Making our voices heard about the fact, because this is about the frozen funds and future funding, correct? We talked about all of the ways that cutting federal funding, whether it's through freezing, currently allocated funds, or cutting things that we depend upon, that's how it was worded. I thought it was worded quite well and really just demonstrated just a fraction of what these harmful effects could be.
5:25:01 What process environment are we in? It sounds like we don't really know. I don't know, but I'm not the one who's been bird-dogging this on Truckee's behalf. One of my colleagues has, and I can certainly ask her if she has heard anything, either from Congressman Kiley's chief of staff, or if she's aware of anything from any other source that might shed light on this. Yeah, share that with Rob. And by the way, it's not just us in Truckee. They're up to many municipalities, and they announced it six times at the Civic World Conference, and there were up.
5:25:28 100 local electeds there. So I think this is going to be far and wide because it impacts everyone. So with that, anyone want to make a motion? Anyone? I'll make it. Oh, dang. Public comment. Sorry. It's just so late. No? Jamie, anyone online? No. I'll make a motion to adopt a resolution opposing federal funding and staffing cuts that will have negative local impacts to forest health.
5:26:01 And wildfire mitigation. Two, to adopt a resolution opposing federal funding cuts that will have negative local impacts on, yeah. Direct staff to draft a letter, which I think we have, expressing the town's opposition to federal staffing and funding cuts. And I'll second that. Thank you. Jamie, could you please call the roll? Councilmember Sauser? Yep. Councilmember Truax? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Rice? Yes. Mayor Bubzer? Yes. All right.
5:26:32 Councilmember reports. I'll go first. Okay. Nothing to report. Well, we did the Innsbruck. I guess I could report that. We did the Innsbruck. That's so wonderful. Cutting today, which was so great. Yeah, that's it. Okay, Councilmember Sauser, council report. Yeah, I attended the LTC on Monday the 10th. There was a great presentation from town and county, both on the trails and where we're at.
5:27:04 I frankly think the county's approach is a little convoluted and don't quite understand it on how it can move forward in the direction that it should, but they've got some very well-meaning staff there that's doing good work. I asked a question about federal funding and how they were going to deal with that. Also, we got that I found kind of useful for me, and I didn't bring a copy of it, we got a map.
5:27:33 Showing what all of Caltrans' proposed projects are that can affect our area going up and down 395, and I thought that was a great thing. You could probably find that on the Caltrans website, I would assume. I met with our mayor on the town manager's side, and we went to the Innsbruck and cut a ribbon. Some things LTC covered.
5:28:01 Kim did MLR earlier, also went to Innsbruck, but also I don't know if anybody else was able to attend, but the mountain at the chamber luncheon did a talk that you mentioned about, John, in regards to the change and some of the things they're doing, but they covered their capital projects really for the next seven to ten years from now on. Some interesting things they're looking at. We'll see if all comes to fruition, but it was just good to have the communication and see what the mountain is planning to do over the next several years. They plan to go carbon neutral?
5:28:28 They didn't talk, they talked about capital projects and chair lifts and the new village site and then they're not moving 203 up on the main. Well, it'd be great if they could come down and give that presentation to us. Sure would. I'd love to ask him if they plan to go carbon neutral anytime soon. Well, I was, I was, before we get those, maybe with whatever they.
5:28:47 Gave to the Chamber. We can start with that at least. Yeah. Well, yeah, because the fact that they now don't plan on moving 203 is a pretty huge change. Yeah, that's huge. Tom would not give a copy of his presentation, said it was privileged information and would be glad to talk to people, but he wouldn't share the presentation. Okay. All right, Council Member Wentworth, what have you got? Okay, so a couple things. So first, the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting. A lot of, you know, there's, they,
5:29:16 You know, that group gets involved in a lot of litigation, so there's a lot of closed session stuff, but building staff capacity, we've got a very good APCO, Air Pollution Control Officer in place, an assistant's being hired, so it's, the organization's really getting back on its feet, and it's in good stead. And as mentioned, again, if there are recommendations from the fire world here for control burns and things like that, please bring those things forward.
5:29:42 I attended in Sacramento the Land Use and Climate Initiative Technical Advisory Council I serve on behalf of the town, which used to be part of OPR. It's an interesting meeting, but it's concerning in many ways that large portions of the state of California government bureaucracy has really not gotten the memo yet of what we're dealing with with federal partners.
5:30:11 So it's still kind of running around in the same old California stuff. And I'm thinking like, you know, where, you know, as an example, in L.A. with the fires, the state and local organizations gathered together all the information for FEMA. It was full of all the California speak, the California values, equity and all this kind of stuff. Went into FEMA. FEMA said, okay, thanks a lot for that. We need, can you give us 24 hours? Yeah, sure. Do what you got to do.
5:30:41 They scrubbed, you know, it's like the Iwo Jima Memorial, the Navajos, the Whispers, scrubbed from the Pentagon website. That stuff is real. It is happening. And so how, like, the Climate Technical Advisory Committee in California is going to start to kind of get to, you know, look, understanding what the program is like, that'll be interesting. But it's an interesting thing to be a part of.
5:31:08 To see what's going on instead of in state government. And then finally, the MLT board meeting, which was very interesting today. I couldn't stay for the whole thing because I needed to make sure I got to our beautiful ribbon cutting. And there's a couple things on there. So consent agenda stuff, minutes. Tom Parker gave the same presentation he gave to us about the hospital. There was discussion about
5:31:37 Giving in some additional allocations to Bluesapalooza for marketing. I voted against it. It was a 5-3 vote, so they're going to give them a little bit more money for Bluesapalooza. I felt the town's making significant contributions anyways. I voted against that. The finance reports are good. Everything's sort of within budget, but we're nothing alarming there. The good news really is around the airport and the air service. It's really stabilized, and it's something that...
5:32:05 The reliability of the service is being demonstrated year over year. It's something that we're going to be able to grow from. It's going to take some interesting strategic and tactical discussions, but that's good. And in terms of the reports from the various departments, it's pretty interesting to be hearing from the international side. So far, at least, California is a place that people from around the world are still perhaps willing to come to. But when you ask about how many bookings are you getting from Ottawa, you know, it's...
5:32:35 But it's serious stuff. I mean, this is our audience, our market, despite our wonderful reputation, despite the reputation of California, it's going to get tricky. So those are my reports. Thank you. Okay. And I'll try to be quick.
5:32:51 I will be having office hours tomorrow at 5 o'clock. I alternate it monthly between a morning office hours and an evening so people can come. I'll be at Black Velvet Coffee because I'm sharing the love at all the coffee shops around town. And I've had some lovely conversations. People have come to talk about issues and it is a much more relaxed opportunity. So please come to office hours and tell me what's on your mind. 5 p.m.
5:33:21 I also wanted to let everyone know I mentioned the Civic Well Conference, and I just want to talk very briefly about some of the key topics. I'm planning to do a written report. It was so valuable that I just would love to share it with everyone. So, you know, really, they're all about building sustainable, resilient communities, which is...
5:33:40 Something we're all about too. Some of the topics were insights from federal agencies, so what we could expect to see coming. How state and local government can collaborate better given what's happening at the federal level. So these guys did get the memo, John. Safeguarding housing by reducing risk to communities, but also insurance uncertainty. So I learned a lot of great initiatives that are happening there. There was a whole section on water innovation.
5:34:09 And how to get access to climate bomb funds. And then we created a local elected wildfire task force where we're going to meet monthly with people from, there's already people from 20 jurisdictions, including our friends from Truckee, to just share best practices. Because what it's really about for me is
5:34:29 Thank you. Thank you.
5:34:58 There will probably be no reportable action, but as mentioned earlier, we'll be going in a closed session to discuss an item of anticipated litigation. Thank you. All right. Thanks, everybody. Thanks for hanging with us. Thank you. Good night.